catalytic mechanism_turninggoalsintoresults

13
Turning Goals into Results The Power of Catalytic Mechanisms by Jim Collins by Jim Collins Courtesy: Harvard Business Review Courtesy: Harvard Business Review Compiled by: Syed Muhammad Ijaz, FCA, LLB Group CFO, City Schools. Special thanks and assistance by: • Imran Akram-ACA Senior Manager Finance •Zarka Farooq-Assistant Manager.

Post on 13-Sep-2014

89 views

Category:

Business


0 download

DESCRIPTION

"Turning Goals into Results". Presentation based on article by Jim Collins. Explaining how big and audacious goals can be turned into reality? How to think out of box? How you can convert dreams into reality?

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Catalytic mechanism_turninggoalsintoresults

Turning Goals into Results

The Power of Catalytic Mechanismsby Jim Collinsby Jim Collins

Courtesy: Harvard Business ReviewCourtesy: Harvard Business Review

Compiled by:Syed Muhammad Ijaz, FCA, LLBGroup CFO, City Schools.Special thanks and assistance by:• Imran Akram-ACA Senior Manager Finance•Zarka Farooq-Assistant Manager.

Page 2: Catalytic mechanism_turninggoalsintoresults

What does that mean “turning goals into

results?”• Executives have big hairy audacious goals also known as BHAGsBHAGs. Too

that end they put forward ambitious vision statements, enthusiastic speeches, and aggressive goal oriented schemes, building layers of bureaucratic tantrum. How much of these are materialized is very well known to all of us, isn’t it?

• Time and over again, many of the powerful managerial tools have been invented to codify the apparently impossible dreams into reality – one of the tools is named as Catalytic Mechanism.

• Catalytic mechanism are the link between the objectives and performance;

1. They galvanize non- bureaucratic means into one another,

2. They are easy to create and implement,

3. They are the most underutilized and most promising devices,

Executives can use to achieve their BHAGs – Big, Hairy, Audacious, Goals.BHAGs – Big, Hairy, Audacious, Goals.

Page 3: Catalytic mechanism_turninggoalsintoresults

Anatomy of BHAGsThere are three characteristics if a good BHAGs:

Page 4: Catalytic mechanism_turninggoalsintoresults

Examples of BHAGsThe following example better explains the BHAG its characteristics and catalytic mechanism;•Granite Rock, that sells crushed gravels, concrete, sand and asphalt gave their company a new BHAG, total customer satisfaction. •This was not at all an easy goal to achieve for a family owned company whose employees are mostly though sweaty people operating rocks and whose customers are not easily dazzled.•Now think how we can achieve this ambitious goal?•Instead of going for the traditional galvanized leadership methodology, Granite Rock, opted for the concept of “short pay”. •The bottom of very invoice reads “if you are not satisfied for any reason, don’t pay us for it, imply scratch out the line item, write a brief note about the problem and return copy of this invoice along with your check for the balance”.•No doubt “short pay” was a critical device for turning BHAG into reality and improving razor thin margins to profits ratios.•Granite Rocks was dead serious about the customer satisfaction in a what that goes far beyond slogans and finally it keep Granite Rock from basking into glory of its remarkable success. •Another device “red flag” concept was introduced by Jim Collins in his class which gave the students the right to use it once for a quarter, since its non transferable and saleable. But it give opportunity equally to each student to share their views and take part in upfront discussions.

Page 5: Catalytic mechanism_turninggoalsintoresults

Characteristics of a Catalytic Mechanisms

Page 6: Catalytic mechanism_turninggoalsintoresults

Catalytic Mechanisms produces desired results in unpredictable ways:• Executives while identifying bold organizational goals, first design

plethora of systems, controls, procedures and practices, this process is named “alignment”.

• Controls that undergird alignment also creates bureaucracy and it should be news to no one that bureaucracy does not breed extraordinary results, since bureaucracy leads to predictability and conformity.

• Organizations achieve greatness when they are allowed to do unexpected things and take initiative for the creativity and think out of the box. That is when amazing results occur.

Example:1. Take example of 3M where 15% rule was introduces when the scientists were

allowed to utilize the lab out for 15% of their total time and they come up with big great ideas and see 3M sales increases by 40 folds since then.

• Ultimately, introducing catalytic mechanism leads to better results , variation, improvement and enhances results.

• Thus, giving up controls and decreasing predictability, you increase the probability of attaining extraordinary results.

Page 7: Catalytic mechanism_turninggoalsintoresults

Catalytic Mechanism distributes power for the benefit of overall system, often to the great discomfort of those who traditionally hold power;• With enough powers executives can always get people jump through hoops.Example:If increasing market share is the dream, then they will only promote those managers who

make it happen.

• “Short pay” distributes powers to the great discomfort of Granite Rock’s executives, similarly, “Red Flag” distributes powers to the great discomfort of teachers but to the ultimate improvement of learning in general.

• Catalytic mechanisms force the right things to happen even though those in power often have a vested interest in the right things not happening.

• Catalytic mechanism exemplifies the beauty and power of redistributing powers.

• Catalytic mechanism tilts the balance of power away from inertia and towards change.

• When executives vest people with power and responsibility and step out of the way, vast reservoirs of energy and competence flow forth.

• Again we have a paradox, the more executives disperse power and responsibility the more likely the organization is to reach its big hairy audacious goal.

Page 8: Catalytic mechanism_turninggoalsintoresults

Catalytic Mechanism has teeth;

• Plenty of the organizations state the lofty intentions to empower people few translates that into results with a mechanism that has teeth like “Red Flag”.

• Catalytic mechanism puts a process in place that all but guarantees that the vision will be fulfilled. A catalytic mechanism has a sharp set of teeth.

Example:Take an example of a Nucor’s Steel Corporation, to be an organization whose workers and

management share the common goal of being the most efficient, high quality steel operation in the world, thereby creating job security and corporate prosperity in and industry ravaged by foreign competition.

• Nucor’s vision may sound warm and fuzzy. Dig deeper, and you will see that it actually leaves no room for unproductive employees.

Examples:Powerful mechanism with teeth;• Five people do the work that ten do at other steel companies and get paid like eight.

Page 9: Catalytic mechanism_turninggoalsintoresults

Catalytic mechanism ejects viruses;

• Traditionally controls are designed to get employees to act the “right” way and do the “right” things even if they are not inclined.

• But catalytic mechanism help organizations to get the right people in the first place keep them and eject those who do not share the company’s core values.

• “People are your most important asset” is wrong, “right people are your most important asset”.

• The real challenge is to find people who already share your core values and create a catalytic mechanism and those who don’t share the core values will self eject themselves.

• You are a leader if and only if people chose you to be and thus W.L Gore & associates come up with an idea that most creative and productive work came when people freely made commitments to one another not when the bosses told them to do so. This mechanism attracted the right people like magnet and pulled the wrong ones away.

Page 10: Catalytic mechanism_turninggoalsintoresults

Catalytic Mechanism produces an ongoing effect;

• Leaders who feign a crisis, and creates a burning platform without simultaneously building catalytic mechanism do more harm than good by creating a syndrome of crisis addiction.

• To produce lasting effects they have to shift from orchestrating a series of events to building catalytic mechanism.

• Part of failure is based upon the approach to reform , too often buzzwords rather than catalytic mechanism that produces sustained effects.

• The ongoing effect of a catalytic mechanism in a corporate setting goes like;

CEO of kimberly-clark created his BHAG to transform the company from a mediocre forest and paper product company onto a world class consumer goods company, for that he create a catalytic event and a catalytic mechanism, “he sold a big chunk of company’s paper production mills thus leaving no easy escape route from the dream and committed company head to head competition with the best consumer products company in world Proctor and Gamble.”

With entry into disposable diapers kimberly clark entered as a direct rival of P&G “The beauty of catalytic mechanism unlike the “change or die”

is its ongoing effect as powerful today as it was in past”.

Page 11: Catalytic mechanism_turninggoalsintoresults

Traditional managerial device,

control or mechanism.

Catalytic Mechanism Examples of Catalytic Mechanism

Reduces variation as it enlarges the organization’s bureaucracy

Produces desired results in unpredictable ways

Ref Flag made ferociously opinionated CEO listen to the challenge of an MBA student improving the knowledge of whole class despite of the unexpected nature of exchange.

Concentrates power in the hands of authorities who can force people to obey their commands

Distributes powers for the benefit of overall system to the discomfort of those who have traditionally holding powers

New government rule allowed a low level manager to expunge an immensely wasteful regulation that required nearly new uniforms to be burned.

Is understood by employees and executives alike as merely an intention

Has sharp set of teeth Short pay at granite rock allows customers to pay only for the products that satisfy them.

Attempts to stimulate the right behaviors from the wrong people

Attracts the right people and ejects viruses

W.L.Gore & associates employees can in effect fir their bosses ensuring non hierarchical leadership.

Has the short lived impact of a single event or a fad

Produces an ongoing effect Kimberly clark put itself into head to head competition with proctor and gamble to impel better performance in the comsuner goods arket place such a strategy is still working 30 years later.

Catalytic Mechanism-Breaking from Tradition;

Page 12: Catalytic mechanism_turninggoalsintoresults

Principles to follow while forming a catalytic mechanism;1. Don’t just add, remove2. Create, don’t copy3. Use money but not only money4. Allow your mechanism to evolve5. Build an integrated set

• Developing a set of catalytic mechanism should be an organic process, an ongoing discipline, a habit of mind and action.

• Catalytic mechanism should be catalysts not inhibitors.• After all, a catalytic mechanism alone will not create greatness

they need a dream to guide them but if you blend huge intangible aspirations with simple tangible catalytic mechanism then you will have the magic combination from which sustained excellence grows.

Conclusion:“If you build castles in the air, your work need not to be lost, that is where they should be. Now put foundations under them”.BHAGs are the company’s wildest dreams. Catalytic Mechanisms are their foundations. Build them both.

Page 13: Catalytic mechanism_turninggoalsintoresults

That’s it!That’s it!