cardiff local development plan · 2014-08-14 · cardiff local development plan 2006 - 2026 city of...

1007
Cardiff Local Development Plan 2006 - 2026 City of Cardiff Council Consultation Report - Appendix 15 Summary of Deposit Representations and Recommended Responses Updated May 2014

Upload: others

Post on 12-Jan-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • Cardiff Local Development Plan2006 - 2026

    City of Cardiff Council

    Consultation Report - Appendix 15Summary of Deposit Representations and Recommended ResponsesUpdated May 2014

  • The Summary of Deposit Representations is ordered on Representor Number.  For ease of reference an alphabetical list of representors with their allocated representor number is included. 

    Representations are coded as either Objections (O), Supports (S) or  Comments (C)  and these are under the heading Type in the report. 

  • List of Representors in Alphabetical Order

    2471 AB Ports

    1212 Adams & Mrs R S Adams, Malcolm, Dr

    2462 Aldi Foodstores Ltd

    1222 Allen, Val

    2443 Alternatives for Transport -- Russell, Grant

    2415 Andrews, Brian, Mr

    1226 Andrews, David, Mr

    2484 Angell, Phillip

    1227 Appleby, Alison, Mrs

    2318 Arnold, Malcolm, Dr

    1239 Ayres, John & Pam

    2349 Babecki, L

    2322 Badcock, Peter, Dr

    2313 Bailey, Ian, Mr

    1243 Baldwin, Fiona

    1010 Barratt South Wales Ltd -- Quealey, Charlotte, Ms

    2372 Basketter, Norman

    2347 Batchelder, Sian, Mrs

    1262 Baxter, Valerie J.

    1266 Beckett, Paul

    2553 Bellerophon Partnerships and Centuar Property Estates Ltd

    2542 Belward, Colin

    2410 Bevan, Angharad, Dr

    1273 Bibby, Jan

    1274 Bibby, Peter

    c735821Typewritten Text

  • 1282 Blake, John

    2329 Bond, Geoffrey, Dr

    2333 Bond, J, Mrs

    1289 Boundy, Simon, Mr

    2382 Bourne, Liz

    2467 Bovis Homes Ltd

    2351 Bowden, Fenella, Cllr

    1291 Bowen, Delme, Professor

    2306 Boyd, Alison, Mrs

    2416 Boyle, Joe, Cllr

    2449 Brightmore, Gillian, Ms

    2538 Britton, Mike

    1297 Brodie, Barbara

    1298 Brodie, Scott

    2373 Brooks, Ann

    1300 Brooks, P

    2337 Broughton, Anne, Mrs

    2370 Brown, Patricia

    2379 Brown, Peter

    2419 Budd, Mr & Mrs

    1315 Burdett, Christopher

    1319 Burgess, Stuart

    2392 Burr, Sheila, Mrs

    2521 Burt, Howard

    2319 Burton, Adrian, Mr

    1024 Caerphilly County Borough Council -- Lucas, Dave

    2452 Cahill Dickenson, J

  • 1025 Campaign for the Protection of Rural Wales -- Simpson, Robin, Mr

    1330 Cane, Stuart

    2301 Cardiff & Vale Parents Federation -- Harding, Philip, Mr

    1027 Cardiff & Vale University Health Board Cardiff -- Hopkins, Sharon, Dr

    2444 Cardiff Against the Incinerator -- Prosser, William

    1030 Cardiff Bus -- Heath, Peter, Mr

    2432 Cardiff Bus Users -- Greagsby, A

    2518 Cardiff Civic Society -- Lloyd Pierce, Nerys

    1034 Cardiff Cycling Campaign -- Barker, Ken

    2451 Cardiff Gate International Business Park

    2472 Cardiff Gate Pradera Ltd

    2492 Cardiff Greenpeace -- Baker, Nigel

    2500 Cardiff Liberal Democrat Group -- Woodman, Judith, Cllr

    1038 Cardiff Local Access Forum -- Rees, Steve, Mr

    2427 Cardiff Naturalists -- Dean, Michael, Mr

    1040 Cardiff North Labour Party -- Morgan AM, Julie

    2573 Cardiff Pedestrian Liberation -- Greagsby, Anne

    2506 Cardiff Plaid Cymru -- McEvoy, N, Cllr

    2489 Cardiff Transition -- Groves, Christopher, Dr

    2560 Carey, David

    2510 Carillion Plc

    2457 Castell Y Mynach Estate

    2397 Catani, Nicole

    2556 Cathays Labour Councillors -- Knight, Sam, Cllr

    1338 Catherwood, Phillip

    2513 Celsa Manufacturing (UK) LTD -- Ellis, James

    2552 Cemex Uk Operations Ltd -- Denny, Shaun

  • 2391 Charles, John

    1348 Charlton, David

    2456 Cheshire West and Chester Council Pension Trust c/o Rockspring

    2361 Clare Webster/ Leighton Rolley

    1363 Clissold, Carole

    1364 Clissold, Richard, Mr

    2534 Coal Authority

    2307 Cole, Matthew, Mr

    1372 Collings, C & L, Mr & Mrs

    2479 Community Land Advisory Service Cymru -- Taylor, Lucie

    2368 Cowie, Richard, Dr

    1389 Crane, John

    1391 Crawford, John

    1397 Cross, Glyn

    2550 Currie, David

    2515 Danescourt Community Association -- Gibbs, Edgar

    1409 Davidson, Robert

    2311 Davidson, Robert, Mr

    1413 Davies, Diane , Ms

    1416 Davies, F J

    1419 Davies, Jane

    1420 Davies, Jeffrey

    2539 Davies, M & L

    1424 Davies, Margaret E, Mrs

    2390 Davies, Nicola, Miss

    1441 Davies, P O

    2502 Davies, Paul

  • 1438 Davies, Sarah

    1448 Davies, Sarah

    2355 Davies, Y, Mrs

    2367 Dawkes, Mark

    2551 Dawkins, David

    2386 Dean, Michael, Mr

    2365 Delahunty, Terri

    2549 Design Circle RSAW South

    1465 Deslandes, Paul, Dr

    2420 Devonald, B M

    1467 Dewhurst, Keith

    2142 Diane Stevens / Soheal Athar

    2343 Dickson, Morgan

    2341 Dickson, Peter

    2340 Dickson, Sally

    2342 Dickson, Terry

    2371 Dixey, Marian

    2496 Dorrington, P, Dr

    2448 Duggan, Malcolm

    2344 Dwr Cymru Welsh Water -- Todd-Jones, Matthew

    2531 Edenstone Homes Ltd

    1492 Edwards, J, Mr & Mrs

    2543 Ellis Owen, Wynford

    2487 Ely Bridge Development Company

    2523 Emma, Wilkins

    2412 Evans

    2481 Evans, Angela

  • 2454 Evans, Carol Ann, Mrs

    1509 Evans, J.W. & S.

    2320 Evans, K & J, Mr & Mrs

    2366 Evans, Ros

    2435 Fairbrother, Paul, Dr

    2453 Fermandell, E A, Mrs

    2317 Flower, David, Mr

    2458 Ford, Lisa, Cllr

    2439 Frazer, Diana

    2332 Freeman, Chris, Mr

    1543 Freeman, E J, Mrs

    2363 Furlong, John, Professor

    1546 Gainsbury, Andrew

    2512 Garden Centre Group

    2530 Gately, Elaine

    1550 Gee, Anne

    2331 Gibbs, Charles & Julie

    2574 Gibbs, Julie

    1559 Gifford, Peter

    2554 Glen House Estates Ltd

    2426 Gokhale, Satish, Mr

    2486 Gordon, Iona, Cllr

    1573 Gowans, Douglas S.

    2312 Graig Community Council -- Davies, Sian

    2436 Graig Protection Society

    2501 Green Circle Sustainable Developments Ltd

    2302 Griffiths, DC & JSA

  • 2303 Griffiths, John

    2505 Haines Family

    1599 Hanson, Mr Vernon

    2504 Hansteen Group

    2547 Hardy, Rosemary

    2514 Harvard, Mr & Mrs

    1608 Hawkes, Freda, Dr

    1610 Hawkins, Grant

    1612 Haynes, J. A.

    2507 Heath Residents Association -- Jones, John

    1616 Heavens, Christopher, Dr

    2545 Herbert, Nick

    2431 Holmes, Thomas, Dr

    2417 Holtam, D & J, Mr & Mrs

    1094 Home Builders Federation

    2411 Howard, Nikki, Ms

    2576 Howell, Deb, Ms

    2477 Hudson, Lyn, Cllr

    1654 Hudson, Veronica, Mrs

    2376 Hughes, Jonathan

    1657 Hughes, Kelvin, Dr

    2375 Hughes, Mari

    1669 Hunter, David, Mr

    2438 Hutchings, Michael

    2434 Hutchings, Sonia

    2409 Huws, Laura, Mrs

    2540 Independent Group Councillors -- Cllr Cowan, Cllr Sander/Cllr Robson

  • 1676 Inglis, D B & J, Dr & Mrs

    1677 Ings, Richard

    1680 James, Howard

    2561 James, Peter

    2338 Jenkins, JH & S, Mr

    2555 Jenkins, M A

    1698 Jenkins, R & E

    2440 John Jones Deceased Will Trust

    2572 John, Christine

    2401 John, Margaret

    2494 John, Phillip

    1711 Johnson, Susan

    2400 Jones, Gwyn & Lesley

    2423 Jones, Janet, Mrs

    2305 Jones, John, Mr

    2362 Jones, Lee

    2364 Jones, Llywela, Ms

    1732 Jones, R

    2398 Jones, Stephen T

    2544 Jones, TC & CF

    1744 Jordan, Myles

    2563 Judd, Dave

    2389 Knapman, Ceri, Miss

    1768 Knight, David, Dr

    2348 Lafarge Tarmac Ltd

    2495 Lenaghan, Anne

    2480 Lewis, Bryan, Mr

  • 2377 Lewis, Chris

    1788 Lewis, Frances

    2413 Lewis, Julia Rachel, Ms

    2324 Lewis, Richard, Professor

    2323 Lewis, Sian, Mrs

    2442 Lidl Uk GmbH

    1802 Ling, Stephen, Mr

    2527 Lisvane Community Council

    2511 Livermore, David

    2327 Llandaff Conservation Group -- Davies, Kirsty, Cllr

    2558 Llandaff Society -- Barton Greenwood, G

    1809 Llewellyn , Tony

    2304 Llewellyn, D, Mr

    2387 Llewellyn, J & N, Mr & Mrs

    2465 Llewellyn, John & Brenda

    1807 Llewellyn, Julia

    2309 Lloyd, Anthony, Mr

    2308 Lord, Amanda, Mrs

    2485 Loveless, Jon

    2422 Lynch, D R, Mrs

    2421 Lynch, P R, Mr

    1827 Mackay, J S

    2497 Maddocks, W G, Mr & Mrs

    2519 Mark Drakeford AM and Kevin Brennan MP

    2330 Marshall, Grettta, Cllr

    2326 Marshfield Community Council -- Thomas, Gerry

    2463 Mathias, Owen

  • 2429 McAllister, Ian

    2424 McCarthy and Stone Retirement Lifestyles Ltd

    2570 McCormack, B

    1853 McEvoy, M & D

    1855 McKay, Chris

    2388 McLean, FJ, Mr

    2499 MDA Renewables Ltd

    2468 Memory Lane Cakes

    2473 Messers R, H, S, & M Bogod

    2369 Miller, David

    2491 Mineral Products Association -- Ratcliff, Malcolm

    1881 Mitchell, John

    1882 Monaghan, Stephen

    1883 Monaghan, Valerie

    2537 Montgomery, Emma

    2430 Moore, Roger

    2536 Moorfield Group Ltd

    2356 Morgan, GRT, Mr

    2360 Morgan, L, Mrs

    1894 Morgan, Peter

    2359 Morgan, Ronald, Mr

    1900 Morris, Margaret Patricia, Mrs

    2425 Mr Rhidian Thomas

    2328 Mulligan, Les, Mr

    1909 Murray, Robert

    2316 Mutter, Jane, Ms

    1120 National Grid

  • 2520 National Grid Property (Holdings) Ltd & Wales & West Utilities Ltd

    2548 Natural Resources Wales -- Walters, Jackie

    1122 Neal Soil Suppliers Ltd & Atlantic Recycling

    2559 Network Rail -- Whitaker, Lydia

    1914 Newland, David

    2380 Newport City Council -- Hand, Mark

    1920 Noaks, John & Lesley, Mr & Dr

    2393 Norris, Raymond, Mr

    2441 North East Cardiff Landownership Group

    2374 O'Donnell, James

    1924 O'Donoghue, Mr & Mrs S

    1928 O'Reilly, Peter

    2469 Park Properties

    1938 Parker, Arthur

    2525 Parrott AM, Eluned

    2339 Parsons, Mrs

    1946 Parsons, Vincent

    2385 Pearce, Howard, Mr

    1952 Pearce, Z

    1958 Pendlebury, Maurice, Professor

    2335 Pendlebury, Tom, Mr

    2447 Penhale, A & L

    2562 Pentyrch Community Council -- Davies, Alec

    2568 Perry, Martin

    1135 Persimmon Homes

    2418 Phillips, E C A, Mr

    2455 Plender, Aidan, Mr

  • 2565 PMG Estates Limited (Pip Cole)

    2474 PMG Estates LTD (SLR Consulting

    1986 Powell, Martin & Sian

    1988 Powell, Paul

    2314 Pritchard, David, Mr

    2315 Pritchard, Kathryn

    2428 Pritchard, Stephen

    2321 Punter, John, Professor

    2524 Radyr and Morganstown Community Council -- Fox, Helena

    2569 Radyr and Morganstown Partnership and Community Trust (PACT) -- Vaughan, RS, Dr

    2450 Radyr Golf Club -- Dance, S, Mr

    2012 Ramsay, Richard & Jan

    2017 Read, Mary

    2358 Read, R J, Mr

    2575 Redrow Homes (South Wales) -- Porte, Ben

    2470 Redrow Homes Ltd

    2482 Rees, Dianne, Cllr

    2020 Rees, Jenkin T

    2399 Reservoir Action Group (RAG) -- Davies, D C, Mr

    2031 Revill, David

    2033 Revill, Sarah

    1144 Rhondda Cynon Taf County Borough Council -- Gale, Simon

    2041 Ritson, Anthony

    2055 Robinson, Andrew

    2396 Roche, Isobelle, Mrs

    2394 Roche, Jack, Mr

    2395 Roche, John, Mr

  • 2059 Roche, P & M, Mr & Mrs

    2346 Rodgers, Susan

    2066 Roszkowski, Mr Julius

    2336 Rothwell, Alwyn, Mr

    2067 Rowlands, B.H.

    1151 Royal Mail Group Ltd

    2535 RSPB Cymru -- Webb, Mike

    2464 Ryan Family

    2546 Sainsbury's Supermarkets Ltd

    2079 Salter, David

    2445 Saunders, Catherine

    2089 Savage, Phil, Mr

    2493 Save Creigiau Action Group -- Thomas, Graham, Cllr

    2094 Sendell, C A & D M, Mr & Mrs

    2104 Sherwood, Michael

    2437 South Wales Land Developments Ltd

    2300 South Wales Police -- Brown, Jon, Mr

    2488 South Wales WIN -- Wallis, Max

    1168 St David's Partnership/Land Securities

    2459 St Fagans Community Council -- Barnard, David

    2460 St Fagans No1 and No 2 Trust

    2461 St Fagans Nos 1, 2, & 3 Trust

    2564 Stallworthy, M W

    2136 Steed, Geoffrey, Dr

    2137 Steed, Melanie

    2516 Steele, Lindsay & Ewan

    1967 Susan Phillips / MJ Grange

  • 2354 Suthers, J D, Mr

    2433 Sutton, Bethan

    2154 Symons, C

    2490 T. S. Rees Ltd

    2408 Tailby, Joanna, Miss

    2334 Taylor, Catherine, Dr

    2162 Taylor, Mike

    2164 Taylor/Claire Bennett, Simon

    2350 Telereal Trillium

    2526 Theatres Trust -- Freeman, Rose

    2171 Thomas, Donald, Dr

    2498 Thomas, Graham, Cllr

    2404 Thomas, Ian, Mr

    2325 Thomas, Sian

    2184 Thomas, Stuart

    2528 Threipland, Andrew

    2532 Threipland, Helen

    1186 Tongwynlais Community Council -- Lane, Ceri

    2571 Torfaen County Borough Council -- Murray, R

    2310 Torosyan, John, Mr

    2508 Trustees of the Cottage Trust and the Marjorie Pallott Will Trust -- Ian & Hugh Pallott

    2478 Tudor, Hywel

    2557 Valad Europe Plc

    2345 Vaughan, Peter, Mr

    2209 Walker, David, Cllr

    2381 Walker, Leslie

    2475 Wallis, Max

  • 2215 Walters, Iolo, Mr

    2483 Walton, David

    2383 Ward, Heather

    2476 Waterstone Homes

    2407 Webb, Tim, Mr

    1204 Welsh Government

    2405 Welsh Government - Economy Science and Transport Division -- Evans, Paul, Mr

    1205 Western Power Distribution (South Wales) Plc

    2533 Westgate Park (Cardiff) Ltd

    2352 White, Diane, Mrs

    2406 White, Paul, Dr

    2236 Wilkinson, G & J

    2240 William, Mary, Mrs

    2522 Williams, Hugh

    2244 Williams, Jane R

    2541 Williams, L

    2403 Williams, Michael, Mr

    2402 Williams, Samantha, Mrs

    2257 Williamson, Sian

    2259 Willis, Eric

    2509 Willott MP, Jenny

    2566 Wilson, Dana

    2567 Wilson, Joe

    2261 Wilson, John

    2414 Wilson, Keith, Mr

    2271 Wood, Jean

    2353 Worwood, Mark, Professor

  • 2517 Wyndham Lewis Trust

    2529 Wyndham Lewis Trust and Mr Bassett

    2378 Yates, Frank & Margery

    2384 Yearsley, Helen

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1010.D1 C I MBarratt South Wales Ltd Asbri Planning Ltd KP1

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Level of Growth

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Level of provision under KP1 should be regarded as an absolute minimum

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Extensive evidence contained within the Deposit LDP and supporting documentation demonstrates the need to provide the level of new homes and jobs set out in the LDP which is consistent with the overall Plan Strategy and takes full account of cross-boundary considerations. The LDP shows how this need can be met including the allocation of a range and choice of sites with over 60% of dwelling provision over the plan period being met from brownfield land.

    It is considered that the LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for a different level of growth, a different approach or alternative sites to deliver the evidenced need. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1010.D2 S MBarratt South Wales Ltd Asbri Planning Ltd KP2

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Strategic Sites

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Generally support the strategic sites identified in Policy KP2

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Support is welcomed

    1010.D3 O I MBarratt South Wales Ltd Asbri Planning Ltd KP2

    Site No: 116 Site Reference: A-KP2-G-D Site Name: North of Junction 33 on M4

    Strategic Sites

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: In Table 1 the number of houses apporportioned to North of J33 on M4 should be increased rather than accommodating the 1,500 units proposed to contribute to the flexibility allowance to the west of the site.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Support is welcomed

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1010.D4 O I MBarratt South Wales Ltd Asbri Planning Ltd KP3(A)

    Site No: 255 Site Reference: Site Name: Land north of Llantrisant Road

    Green Belt

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Remove land north of Llantrisant Road from greenbelt

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    A Green Belt is designated to strategically manage urban form and protect the setting of the urban area. The proposed designated area was subject to careful analysis and related to strategically important land with well-defined boundaries based on the distinctive green backdrop to the urban area. Importantly, extensions to the designated area are not considered appropriate and would run contrary to national guidance which, in recognition of the long-term permanence of Green Belts beyond the Plan period, would unnecessarily restrict future development options. Written supporting text to KP3(A) clarify this point and Green Belt Technical Background Paper provides further justification.

    Overall, it is considered that this designation is appropriate for Cardiff and accords with national guidance relating to Green Belts as set out in Planning Policy Wales. Importantly, given the Plan proposes some significant greenfield releases, this Policy provides some longer-term certainty as to the future urban form of the city. It should also be noted that the land within a Green Belt should be protected for a longer period than the Plan period.

    Furthermore, it is important to note that all other non-allocated land outside the Settlement Boundary is sufficiently protected by a range of policies in both the LDP and national planning policy. This protection provides a presumption against development during the Plan period (subject to material planning considerations).

    Given this, there is considered no justification to remove this land from the allocated area and it is considered that the LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1010.D5 O I MBarratt South Wales Ltd Asbri Planning Ltd KP3(B)

    Site No: 255 Site Reference: Site Name: Land north of Llantrisant Road

    Settlement Boundaries

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Include land north of Llantrisant Road in settlement boundary

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Extensive evidence contained within the Deposit LDP and supporting documentation demonstrates the need to provide the level of new homes and jobs set out in the LDP which is consistent with the overall Plan Strategy and takes full account of cross-boundary considerations. The LDP shows how this need can be met including the allocation of a range and choice of sites with over 60% of dwelling provision over the plan period being met from brownfield land.

    Furthermore, policies, supporting text and documentation have set out how the Council proposes to manage the delivery of new development including details on the masterplanning approach, infrastructure planning and sustainable transportation solutions. This approach shows how development can be managed, phased and all impacts mitigated including factors relating to the natural environment, flood risk, infrastructure/capacity issues, transport implications, community facilities, air quality, contaminated land, built environment, culture/language, land quality and impact on adjacent areas/features.

    Updated Technical Background Papers will be formally submitted alongside the Deposit LDP relating to this matter. However, work will continue on masterplanning, infrastructure and sustainable transportation solutions and will inform the independent examination process in due course.

    Therefore, in the light of the above, there is considered no justification to include this land within the settlement boundary.

    It is considered that the LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for a different approach or alternative sites to deliver the evidenced need. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1010.D6 O I MBarratt South Wales Ltd Asbri Planning Ltd H1

    Site No: 255 Site Reference: Site Name: Land north of Llantrisant Road

    Non-Strategic Housing Sites

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Include land north of Llantrisant Road in Policy H1 as a non strategic housing site.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    The representation supports the inclusion of a greenfield site not included in the Deposit LDP. Having considered the policy context, Plan strategy and other relevant material factors, it is concluded there is no demonstrable need to include the site in the Plan and the inclusion of the alternative site proposal is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1010.D7 O I MBarratt South Wales Ltd Asbri Planning Ltd KP2

    Site No: 255 Site Reference: Site Name: Land north of Llantrisant Road

    Strategic Sites

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Include land north of Llantrisant Road as part of Strategic Site D North of J33 on M4

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    The representation supports the inclusion of a greenfield site not included in the Deposit LDP. Having considered the policy context, Plan strategy and other relevant material factors, it is concluded there is no demonstrable need to include the site in the Plan and the inclusion of the alternative site proposal is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1024.D1 O W MCaerphilly County Borough Council KP8

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Sustainable Transport

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Significant concerns are raised over the lack of a regional consideration of the potential transport impacts of the LDP. Particular the level of traffic resulting from in-commuting, the LDP makes no provision to address this issue.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Extensive evidence contained within the Deposit LDP and supporting documentation demonstrates the need to provide the level of new homes and jobs set out in the LDP which is consistent with the overall Plan Strategy and takes full account of cross-boundary considerations. The LDP shows how this need can be met including the allocation of a range and choice of sites with over 60% of dwelling provision over the plan period being met from brownfield land.

    Furthermore, policies, supporting text and documentation have set out how the Council proposes to manage the delivery of new development including details on the masterplanning approach including phasing, infrastructure planning and sustainable transportation solutions. This approach shows how development can be managed, phased and all impacts mitigated including factors relating to the natural environment, flood risk, infrastructure/capacity issues, transportation implications, community facilities, air quality, contaminated land , built environment, culture/language, land quality and impact on adjacent areas/features.

    Updated Technical Background Papers will be formally submitted alongside the Deposit LDP relating to this matter. However, work will continue on masterplanning, infrastructure and sustainable transportation solutions and will inform the independent examination process in due course.

    It is considered that the LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for a different approach (such as spreading development around the region) or alternative sites to deliver the evidenced need. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1024.D2 O W MCaerphilly County Borough Council EN7

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Priority Habitats and Species

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: No reference is made to the list under Section 42 of the Natural Environment and Rural Communities Act 2006. Those habitats and species listed that occur in Cardiff should be protected by the policy.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    This minor change of allocation/ policy/supporting text is not necessary to ensure the LDP is sound and is not supported.

    1024.D3 C W MCaerphilly County Borough Council KP2

    Site No: 118 Site Reference: A-KP2-G-F Site Name: North East Cardiff (West of Pontprennau)

    Strategic Sites

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Development of the site has potential to negatively affect Caerphilly - but could be mitigated by controlled phasing of number of units released in any particular year. Such phasing should be set out in the Masterplan for the site.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Extensive evidence contained within the Deposit LDP and supporting documentation demonstrates the need to provide the level of new homes and jobs set out in the LDP which is consistent with the overall Plan Strategy and takes full account of cross-boundary considerations. The LDP shows how this need can be met including the allocation of a range and choice of sites with over 60% of dwelling provision over the plan period being met from brownfield land.

    Furthermore, policies, supporting text and documentation have set out how the Council proposes to manage the delivery of new development including details on the masterplanning approach including phasing, infrastructure planning and sustainable transportation solutions. This approach shows how development can be managed, phased and all impacts mitigated including factors relating to the natural environment, flood risk, infrastructure/capacity issues, transportation implications, community facilities, air quality, contaminated land , built environment, culture/language, land quality and impact on adjacent areas/features.

    Updated Technical Background Papers will be formally submitted alongside the Deposit LDP relating to this matter. However, work will continue on masterplanning, infrastructure and sustainable transportation solutions and will inform the independent examination process in due course.

    It is considered that the LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for a different approach (such as spreading development around the region) or alternative sites to deliver the evidenced need. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1024.D4 S W MCaerphilly County Borough Council KP3(A)

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Green Belt

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: No concerns are raised in respect of the designation of the Green Belt

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Support is welcomed

    1024.D5 C W MCaerphilly County Borough Council EN5

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Local Nature Reserves and Non-statutory Sites of

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: SINC's should be shown either on the Constraints or Proposals Map as other Local Authorities

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    SINCS are a non-statutory designation and are subject to on-going changes through the Council’s annual SINC monitoring process. Up to date information is therefore shown on the website rather than the LDP documentation which would become quickly outdated.

    1024.D6 S W MCaerphilly County Borough Council KP1

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Level of Growth

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: No objections are raised in respect of the housing and employment requirements set out in KP1

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Support is welcomed

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1024.D7 O W MCaerphilly County Borough Council 998

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Whole Plan

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Significant concerns are raised in respect of the commuting related impacts from the housing, in particular, employment allocations and the potential effects that the traffic generation will have on the Caerphilly Air Quality Management Area

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Extensive evidence contained within the Deposit LDP and supporting documentation demonstrates the need to provide the level of new homes and jobs set out in the LDP which is consistent with the overall Plan Strategy and takes full account of cross-boundary considerations. The LDP shows how this need can be met including the allocation of a range and choice of sites with over 60% of dwelling provision over the plan period being met from brownfield land.

    Furthermore, policies, supporting text and documentation have set out how the Council proposes to manage the delivery of new development including details on the masterplanning approach including phasing, infrastructure planning and sustainable transportation solutions. This approach shows how development can be managed, phased and all impacts mitigated including factors relating to the natural environment, flood risk, infrastructure/capacity issues, transportation implications, community facilities, air quality, contaminated land , built environment, culture/language, land quality and impact on adjacent areas/features.

    Updated Technical Background Papers will be formally submitted alongside the Deposit LDP relating to this matter. However, work will continue on masterplanning, infrastructure and sustainable transportation solutions and will inform the independent examination process in due course.

    It is considered that the LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for a different approach (such as spreading development around the region) or alternative sites to deliver the evidenced need. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1025.D1 O W MCampaign for the Protection of Rural Wales KP1

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Level of Growth

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Suggest there should be a degree of flexibility in housing numbers if build rates are not met during the plan period.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    There is no set flexibility figure required for housing supply within development plans. However, during the examination of the Brecon Beacons National Park LDP Welsh Government noted a notional figure of 10% but that needed to reflect local circumstances. Other authorities within South East Wales have a range of 12-20% flexibility. It is good practice to allow for unknowns and the need for flexibility within a development plan is inherent from Welsh Government guidance. In Cardiff’s case provision has been made to deliver an additional 10% flexibility allowance (for 4,000 dwellings) which is considered appropriate to enable to plan to cope with uncertainties that may arise over the plan period.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1025.D2 O W MCampaign for the Protection of Rural Wales KP3(A)

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Green Belt

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Welcome inclusion of a greenbelt but feel it should protect area around Creigiau

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    A Green Belt is designated to strategically manage urban form and protect the setting of the urban area. The proposed designated area was subject to careful analysis and related to strategically important land with well-defined boundaries based on the distinctive green backdrop to the urban area. Importantly, extensions to the designated area are not considered appropriate and would run contrary to national guidance which, in recognition of the long-term permanence of Green Belts beyond the Plan period, would unnecessarily restrict future development options. Written supporting text to KP3(A) clarify this point and Green Belt Technical Background Paper provides further justification.

    Overall, it is considered that this designation is appropriate for Cardiff and accords with national guidance relating to Green Belts as set out in Planning Policy Wales. Importantly, given the Plan proposes some significant greenfield releases, this Policy provides some longer-term certainty as to the future urban form of the city, It should also be noted that the land within a Green Belt should be protected for a longer period than the Plan period.

    Furthermore, it is important to note that all other non-allocated land outside the Settlement Boundary is sufficiently protected by a range of policies in both the LDP and national planning policy. This protection provides a presumption against development during the Plan period (subject to material planning considerations).

    Given this, there is considered no justification to include this land within the allocated area and it is considered that the LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1027.D1 S I MCardiff & Vale University Health Board Cardiff KP4

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Masterplanning Approach

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Support. Provides a framework within which health can be promoted and services delivered in partnership across Cardiff

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Support is welcomed

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1027.D2 S I MCardiff & Vale University Health Board Cardiff KP13

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Responding to Evidenced Social Needs

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Support. Provides a framework within which health can be promoted and services delivered in partnership across Cardiff

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Support is welcomed

    1027.D3 S I MCardiff & Vale University Health Board Cardiff KP14

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Healthy Living

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Support. Provides a framework within which health can be promoted and services delivered in partnership across Cardiff

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Support is welcomed

    1027.D4 S I MCardiff & Vale University Health Board Cardiff C7

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Health

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Support. Provides a framework within which health can be promoted and services delivered in partnership across Cardiff

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Support is welcomed

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1027.D5 O I MCardiff & Vale University Health Board Cardiff

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Request amendments to BTP 6 to reflect the requirement for funding from within UHB funds and request inclusion in discussions with developers/policy makers re. S106 and CIL

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    The comment is noted and helps inform considerations around this issue. Further dialogue will take place to ensure that this matter is addressed as part of masterplanning and infrastructure considerations in relation to delivering sites. As no changes to the LDP are proposed, no focussed or minor changes are considered necessary to ensure the LDP is sound.

    1027.D6 O I MCardiff & Vale University Health Board Cardiff C1

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Community Facilities

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Add reference to health facilities in para. 5.311 together with the commitment to looking for opportunities to share facilitiies

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1027.D7 O I MCardiff & Vale University Health Board Cardiff C10

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Health Employment and Non-strategic Allocation

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Paras. 5.374-5.377 are not accurate and require amendment. The lead organisation for this development is Cardiff University and the use of the site would be for academic health related study & associated accommodation.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1027.D8 S I MCardiff & Vale University Health Board Cardiff H1

    Site No: 36 Site Reference: CS036 Site Name: Former Landsdowne Hospital site

    Non-Strategic Housing Sites

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Welcome the inclusion of Lansdowne Hospital in Policy H1

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Support is welcomed

    1027.D9 S I MCardiff & Vale University Health Board Cardiff H1

    Site No: 123 Site Reference: A-H1.3 Site Name: Rookwood Hospital

    Non-Strategic Housing Sites

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Welcome the inclusion of Rookwood Hospital in Policy H1

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Support is welcomed

    1027.D10 O I MCardiff & Vale University Health Board Cardiff H1

    Site No: 35 Site Reference: CS035 Site Name: Rookwood Hospital

    Non-Strategic Housing Sites

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Part of the Rookwood Hospital site that is available for housing has been increased to from 2.9 ha to 3.4 ha. Amend site boundary.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    The representation supports minor amendments to the boundary of a non-strategic housing site included in the Deposit LDP. Notwithstanding the appropriateness or otherwise of this suggested change, it is considered that this does not go to the soundness of the Plan and therefore no change is considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound. However, no evidence will be offered to counter this representation given the limited impact such a change would have on the application of the Plan and any subsequent outcome as a result of implementation. Any minor additional housing units would contribute to the windfall allowance built into the Plan.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1027.D11 O I MCardiff & Vale University Health Board Cardiff H1

    Site No: 36 Site Reference: CS036 Site Name: Former Landsdowne Hospital site

    Non-Strategic Housing Sites

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: It is considered this site could accommodate up to 100 units (not 75 units).

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    The representation supports minor amendments to the boundary of a non-strategic housing site included in the Deposit LDP. Notwithstanding the appropriateness or otherwise of this suggested change, it is considered that this does not go to the soundness of the Plan and therefore no change is considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound. However, no evidence will be offered to counter this representation given the limited impact such a change would have on the application of the Plan and any subsequent outcome as a result of implementation. Any minor additional housing units would contribute to the windfall allowance built into the Plan.

    1027.D12 C I MCardiff & Vale University Health Board Cardiff

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: UHB are not yet in a position to accurately predict the level/type of health infrastructure requied to meet anticipated future population

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    The comment is noted and helps inform considerations around this issue. Further dialogue will take place to ensure that this matter is addressed as part of masterplanning and infrastructure considerations in relation to delivering sites. As no changes to the LDP are proposed, no focussed or minor changes are considered necessary to ensure the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1027.D13 C I MCardiff & Vale University Health Board Cardiff

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: The additional number of houses proposed will place significant pressure on service delivery especially within Primary Care. Request engagement with phasing of development to ensure UHB can develop approriate primary care and community services.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    The comment is noted and helps inform considerations around this issue. Further dialogue will take place to ensure that this matter is addressed as part of masterplanning and infrastructure considerations in relation to delivering sites. As no changes to the LDP are proposed, no focussed or minor changes are considered necessary to ensure the LDP is sound.

    1027.D14 C I MCardiff & Vale University Health Board Cardiff 998

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Whole Plan

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Request engagement with Council and developers to progress policies and in the development of primary and community care services and facilities on strategic sites to meet population need.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    The comment is noted and helps inform considerations around this issue. Further dialogue will take place to ensure that this matter is addressed as part of masterplanning and infrastructure considerations in relation to delivering sites. As no changes to the LDP are proposed, no focussed or minor changes are considered necessary to ensure the LDP is sound.

    1030.D1 C MCardiff Bus KP4

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Masterplanning Approach

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Recommends that masterplanning principles should have a requirement so that areas of high density housing on bus access corridors are built first.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1030.D2 C MCardiff Bus KP6

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    New Infrastructure

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Suitable infrastructure e.g. bus priority measures, is vital on both the sites and existing network - bus priority measures must be in place to coincide with bus services to ensure they can be delivered effectively.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    An Infrastructure Plan has been prepared to expand on the information supplied in the Deposit LDP. This sets out the proposed phasing, constraints and infrastructure requirements for each strategic allocation.

    1030.D3 C MCardiff Bus T1

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Walking and Cycling

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Comment that it is essential that sustainable transport is looked at holistically and measures to encourage walking and cycling are not to the detriment of bus services as occurs at present.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    The comment is noted and helps inform considerations around this issue. Further dialogue will take place to ensure that this matter is addressed as part of masterplanning and infrastructure considerations in relation to delivering sites. As no changes to the LDP are proposed, no focussed or minor changes are considered necessary to ensure the LDP is sound.

    1030.D4 C MCardiff Bus T2

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Strategic Rapid Transit and Bus Corridors

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: The Council must consider the use of Quality Partnerships, preferable voluntary and if necessary statutory to ensure development is delivered in a way which meets the needs of all users.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    The comment is noted and helps inform considerations around this issue. Further dialogue will take place to ensure that this matter is addressed as part of masterplanning and infrastructure considerations in relation to delivering sites. As no changes to the LDP are proposed, no focussed or minor changes are considered necessary to ensure the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1030.D5 C MCardiff Bus T4

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Central Transport Hub

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: It is essential that operator engagement in the planning process for a regional transport hub is in the right place from the start so development is delivered that meets the needs of all users.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    The comment is noted and helps inform considerations around this issue. Further dialogue will take place to ensure that this matter is addressed as part of masterplanning and infrastructure considerations in relation to delivering sites. As no changes to the LDP are proposed, no focussed or minor changes are considered necessary to ensure the LDP is sound.

    1034.D1 O I MCardiff Cycling Campaign KP1

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Level of Growth

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: We would argue for a further reduction of housing growth of 10%, to around 37,000 over the Plan period.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Extensive evidence contained within the Deposit LDP and supporting documentation demonstrates the need to provide the level of new homes and jobs set out in the LDP which is consistent with the overall Plan Strategy and takes full account of cross-boundary considerations. The LDP shows how this need can be met including the allocation of a range and choice of sites with over 60% of dwelling provision over the plan period being met from brownfield land.

    It is considered that the LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for a different level of growth, a different approach or alternative sites to deliver the evidenced need. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1034.D2 O I MCardiff Cycling Campaign KP7

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Planning Obligations

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: CIL potentially offers resources for cycling infrastructure in a way that can contribute more effectively than planning obligations. However, the Deposit needs to be more concise and open about how and when it will be preferred.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    The comment is noted and helps inform considerations around this issue. Further dialogue will take place to ensure that this matter is addressed as part of masterplanning and infrastructure considerations in relation to delivering sites. As no changes to the LDP are proposed, no focussed or minor changes are considered necessary to ensure the LDP is sound.

    1034.D3 O I MCardiff Cycling Campaign KP2

    Site No: 113 Site Reference: A-KP2-B-A Site Name: Cardiff Central Enterprise Zone & Reg Transp Hub

    Strategic Sites

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: This policy is unsound, in subordinating the long-delayed Regional Transport Hub to an ‘employment-led initiative’ which may continue to be delayed. Site should remain for a modern Bus Station in an integrated transport hub.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1034.D4 O I MCardiff Cycling Campaign T2

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Strategic Rapid Transit and Bus Corridors

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: The Rapid Transit proposals need widening, to include the (diesel) Light Rail from the LTP.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1034.D5 O I MCardiff Cycling Campaign T4

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Central Transport Hub

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: As no proposal is being put through the LDP process, we propose modifying T4 to read: Infrastructure and facilities are being and will be developed in and around Central Railway Station, including a modern Bus Station on Central Square,

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1034.D6 O I MCardiff Cycling Campaign KP8

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Sustainable Transport

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Key Policy 8 is unsound. Clauses of KP8 cannot be achieved through (only) considering new development, nor do they commit to meeting positive duties on active travel and carbon reduction in transport.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Extensive evidence contained within the Deposit LDP and supporting documentation demonstrates the need to provide the level of new homes and jobs set out in the LDP which is consistent with the overall Plan Strategy and takes full account of cross-boundary considerations. The LDP shows how this need can be met including the allocation of a range and choice of sites with over 60% of dwelling provision over the plan period being met from brownfield land.

    Furthermore, policies, supporting text and documentation have set out how the Council proposes to manage the delivery of new development including details on the masterplanning approach including phasing, infrastructure planning and sustainable transportation solutions. This approach shows how development can be managed, phased and all impacts mitigated including factors relating to the natural environment, flood risk, infrastructure/capacity issues, transportation implications, community facilities, air quality, contaminated land , built environment, culture/language, land quality and impact on adjacent areas/features.

    Updated Technical Background Papers will be formally submitted alongside the Deposit LDP relating to this matter. However, work will continue on masterplanning, infrastructure and sustainable transportation solutions and will inform the independent examination process in due course.

    It is considered that the LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for a different approach (such as spreading development around the region) or alternative sites to deliver the evidenced need. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1034.D7 O I MCardiff Cycling Campaign KP8

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Sustainable Transport

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Urban sprawl peripheral development is worst type of development for transportation. Modelling is unrealistic and the 50:50 modal split figure over-optimistic. The LDP does not show how it will meet the abstract modal split target of 50:50

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Extensive evidence contained within the Deposit LDP and supporting documentation demonstrates the need to provide the level of new homes and jobs set out in the LDP which is consistent with the overall Plan Strategy and takes full account of cross-boundary considerations. The LDP shows how this need can be met including the allocation of a range and choice of sites with over 60% of dwelling provision over the plan period being met from brownfield land.

    Furthermore, policies, supporting text and documentation have set out how the Council proposes to manage the delivery of new development including details on the masterplanning approach including phasing, infrastructure planning and sustainable transportation solutions. This approach shows how development can be managed, phased and all impacts mitigated including factors relating to the natural environment, flood risk, infrastructure/capacity issues, transportation implications, community facilities, air quality, contaminated land , built environment, culture/language, land quality and impact on adjacent areas/features.

    Updated Technical Background Papers will be formally submitted alongside the Deposit LDP relating to this matter. However, work will continue on masterplanning, infrastructure and sustainable transportation solutions and will inform the independent examination process in due course.

    It is considered that the LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for a different approach (such as spreading development around the region) or alternative sites to deliver the evidenced need. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1034.D8 O I MCardiff Cycling Campaign KP8

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Sustainable Transport

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Housing growth could be better directed outside the city … preferably diverted to other parts of the ‘city region’, due to come in around 2016.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Extensive evidence contained within the Deposit LDP and supporting documentation demonstrates the need to provide the level of new homes and jobs set out in the LDP which is consistent with the overall Plan Strategy and takes full account of cross-boundary considerations. The LDP shows how this need can be met including the allocation of a range and choice of sites with over 60% of dwelling provision over the plan period being met from brownfield land.

    Furthermore, policies, supporting text and documentation have set out how the Council proposes to manage the delivery of new development including details on the masterplanning approach including phasing, infrastructure planning and sustainable transportation solutions. This approach shows how development can be managed, phased and all impacts mitigated including factors relating to the natural environment, flood risk, infrastructure/capacity issues, transportation implications, community facilities, air quality, contaminated land , built environment, culture/language, land quality and impact on adjacent areas/features.

    Updated Technical Background Papers will be formally submitted alongside the Deposit LDP relating to this matter. However, work will continue on masterplanning, infrastructure and sustainable transportation solutions and will inform the independent examination process in due course.

    It is considered that the LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for a different approach (such as spreading development around the region) or alternative sites to deliver the evidenced need. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1034.D9 O I MCardiff Cycling Campaign KP8

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Sustainable Transport

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: The Carbon-Lite target “citywide CO2 reduction target of 26% by 2020” wrongly omits transport. The LDP needs to use carbon from transport as an indicator, even if the city performs so poorly.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Extensive evidence contained within the Deposit LDP and supporting documentation demonstrates the need to provide the level of new homes and jobs set out in the LDP which is consistent with the overall Plan Strategy and takes full account of cross-boundary considerations. The LDP shows how this need can be met including the allocation of a range and choice of sites with over 60% of dwelling provision over the plan period being met from brownfield land.

    Furthermore, policies, supporting text and documentation have set out how the Council proposes to manage the delivery of new development including details on the masterplanning approach including phasing, infrastructure planning and sustainable transportation solutions. This approach shows how development can be managed, phased and all impacts mitigated including factors relating to the natural environment, flood risk, infrastructure/capacity issues, transportation implications, community facilities, air quality, contaminated land , built environment, culture/language, land quality and impact on adjacent areas/features.

    Updated Technical Background Papers will be formally submitted alongside the Deposit LDP relating to this matter. However, work will continue on masterplanning, infrastructure and sustainable transportation solutions and will inform the independent examination process in due course.

    It is considered that the LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for a different approach (such as spreading development around the region) or alternative sites to deliver the evidenced need. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1038.D1 C MCardiff Local Access Forum KP8

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Sustainable Transport

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: LAF would not object to moving ROW if it helped achieve modal split

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    The comment is noted and helps inform considerations around this issue. Further dialogue will take place to ensure that this matter is addressed as part of masterplanning and infrastructure considerations in relation to delivering sites. As no changes to the LDP are proposed, no focussed or minor changes are considered necessary to ensure the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1038.D2 C MCardiff Local Access Forum KP9

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Responding to Evidenced Economic Needs

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Prioritise non-car use in the City Centre and Cardiff Bay

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    The comment is noted and helps inform considerations around this issue. Further dialogue will take place to ensure that this matter is addressed as part of masterplanning and infrastructure considerations in relation to delivering sites. As no changes to the LDP are proposed, no focussed or minor changes are considered necessary to ensure the LDP is sound.

    1038.D3 C MCardiff Local Access Forum KP10

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Central and Bay Business Areas

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Should be no need for car use for people living and working in these areas. Provision should be made for cycle storage etc.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1038.D4 C W MCardiff Local Access Forum KP16

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Green Infrastructure

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Green infrastructure needs to be linked for it to be effective

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Extensive evidence contained within the Deposit LDP and supporting documentation demonstrates the need to provide the level of new homes and jobs set out in the LDP which is consistent with the overall Plan Strategy and takes full account of cross-boundary considerations. The LDP shows how this need can be met including the allocation of a range and choice of sites with over 60% of dwelling provision over the plan period being met from brownfield land.

    Furthermore, policies, supporting text and documentation have set out how the Council proposes to manage the delivery of new development including details on the masterplanning approach, infrastructure planning and sustainable transportation solutions. This approach shows how development can be managed, phased and all impacts mitigated including factors relating to the natural environment, flood risk, infrastructure/capacity issues, transport implications, community facilities, air quality, contaminated land, built environment, culture/language, land quality and impact on adjacent areas/features.

    Updated Technical Background Papers will be formally submitted alongside the Deposit LDP relating to this matter. However, work will continue on masterplanning, infrastructure and sustainable transportation solutions and will inform the independent examination process in due course.

    Therefore, in the light of the above, there is considered no justification to remove this land from the allocated area.

    It is considered that the LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for a different approach or alternative sites to deliver the evidenced need. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1038.D5 S MCardiff Local Access Forum T1

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Walking and Cycling

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: LAF fully support this policy

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Support is welcomed

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1038.D6 S MCardiff Local Access Forum T3

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Transport Interchanges

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Fully support policy. Cycling provision should be provided at park and ride.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Support is welcomed

    1038.D7 S MCardiff Local Access Forum T5

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Managing Transport Impacts

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Fully support, but concern horse riding is bottom of the list.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Support is welcomed

    1038.D8 C MCardiff Local Access Forum T7

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Strategic Transportation Infrastructure

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Keen to see cycle provision inlcuded in Eastern Bay Link

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1038.D9 S MCardiff Local Access Forum T8

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Strategic Recreational Routes

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Fully support policy. Would like ROW at Ty yn Berllon into green belt north forming extension of Nant Fawr corridor.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1040.D1 S MCardiff North Labour Party KP2

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Strategic Sites

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Welcome the LDP and support the housing allocations.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Support is welcomed

    1040.D2 S I MCardiff North Labour Party KP3(A)

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Green Belt

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Support KP3(A) Greenbelt allocation

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Support is welcomed

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1040.D3 C MCardiff North Labour Party KP4

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Masterplanning Approach

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Support masterplanning framework but recommend an explicit timetable for implementation for each strategic site.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    An Infrastructure Plan has been prepared to expand on the information supplied in the Deposit LDP. This sets out the proposed phasing, constraints and infrastructure requirements for each strategic allocation. The Delivery of each site is considered here, setting out the justification for its continuation in the plan based on evidence from developers and impact on development by the economic recession is to be considered and the plan takes a long term view across the entire plan period.

    1040.D4 O I MCardiff North Labour Party 999

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Any New Policy suggested by Representor

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Include new policy for university expansion and student accommodation

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1040.D5 O MCardiff North Labour Party 999

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Any New Policy suggested by Representor

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Include new policy on Welsh language in line with TAN 20

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    The Equalities Impact Assessment included an assessment of the impact of the Plan on the Welsh language. This process did not identify any required changes to the Plan in response to this issue.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1040.D6 O I MCardiff North Labour Party 999

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Any New Policy suggested by Representor

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Include new policy on neighbourhood planning

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1040.D7 O MCardiff North Labour Party T3

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Transport Interchanges

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Add to policy a commitment to seek an additional park and ride site to serve north Cardiff

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1040.D8 O MCardiff North Labour Party KP16

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Green Infrastructure

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: The proposed SPG should include references to the development of management plans to maximise the socio-economic and environmental benefits of these assets

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Noted.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1040.D9 O MCardiff North Labour Party R4

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Retail Development (Out of Centre)

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Policy should discourage large areas of surface parking and encourage integrated parking with other uses. Large units when redeveloped provide opportunities for housing units above retail units.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1040.D10 O MCardiff North Labour Party H6

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Change of Use or Redevelopment to Residential U

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Policy provides only a framework and should be more proactive. Where there is a potential change of use of an existing commercial activity, housing should be a more explicit priority unless there are over-rinding arguments for retaining jobs.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1094.D1 O I MHome Builders Federation KP1

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Level of Growth

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Level of growth absolute minimum acceptable to HBF but due to various factors it could be increased to Option B level (45,400 dwellings)

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    Extensive evidence contained within the Deposit LDP and supporting documentation demonstrates the need to provide the level of new homes and jobs set out in the LDP which is consistent with the overall Plan Strategy and takes full account of cross-boundary considerations. The LDP shows how this need can be met including the allocation of a range and choice of sites with over 60% of dwelling provision over the plan period being met from brownfield land.

    It is considered that the LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for a different level of growth, a different approach or alternative sites to deliver the evidenced need. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1094.D2 O I MHome Builders Federation H3

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Affordable Housing

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: H3 should not be adopted in current form - would adversely impact on delivery, want more discussions to re-draft policy.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It should be stressed that the targets are derived from the findings of the housing viability study undertaken by Peter Brett Associates which assessed the viability of a range of housing scenarios for different development types with varying levels of affordable housing. In order to demonstrate viability and take account of the higher costs associated with the development of brownfield sites the study recommended a two tiered affordable housing target and confirms that affordable housing is viable at 30% on greenfield sites and 20% on brownfield sites whilst making provision for other ‘policy costs’ including community infrastructure.

    1094.D3 O I MHome Builders Federation KP3(A)

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Green Belt

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: No cogent planning rationale for Green Belt, not supported by evidence, other policies can prevent development there, collaborative group of officers from other LAs gave no support to this. Delete Policy & Green Belt.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    A Green Belt is designated to strategically manage urban form and protect the setting of the urban area. The proposed designated area was subject to careful analysis and related to strategically important land with well-defined boundaries based on the distinctive green backdrop to the urban area. Importantly, extensions to the designated area are not considered appropriate and would run contrary to national guidance which, in recognition of the long-term permanence of Green Belts beyond the Plan period, would unnecessarily restrict future development options. Written supporting text to KP3(A) clarify this point and Green Belt Technical Background Paper provides further justification.

    Overall, it is considered that this designation is appropriate for Cardiff and accords with national guidance relating to Green Belts as set out in Planning Policy Wales. Importantly, given the Plan proposes some significant greenfield releases, this Policy provides some longer-term certainty as to the future urban form of the city, It should also be noted that the land within a Green Belt should be protected for a longer period than the Plan period.

    Furthermore, it is important to note that all other non-allocated land outside the Settlement Boundary is sufficiently protected by a range of policies in both the LDP and national planning policy. This protection provides a presumption against development during the Plan period (subject to material planning considerations).Given this, there is considered no justification to delete the Green Belt and it is considered that the LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1094.D4 O I MHome Builders Federation KP4

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Masterplanning Approach

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Criterion KP4(ii) should be deleted - contrary to national guidance, delegates decisions to SPG that should be dealt with under local planning policy.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1094.D5 O I MHome Builders Federation C5

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Provision for Allotments and Community Growing

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Insufficient evidence for allotment requirements and/ or threshholds. Delete the policy C5

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    1094.D6 O I MHome Builders Federation KP7

    Site No: Site Reference: Site Name:

    Planning Obligations

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Policy KP7 should indicate viability will be taken into account to ensure development remains viable and deliverable.

    Item Question Council Responses

    14 Council's Response

    It is considered that the Deposit LDP meets the tests of soundness without the need for changes relating to this matter. Therefore, the proposed change is not considered necessary to ensure that the LDP is sound.

    Return to List of Representors

  • Rep'n No. Representor Agent Type Mode Status Policy No Policy Name

    Cardiff Council Local Development Plan

    Filtered to show: (all of) Stage=D; StatusD

    Grouped by: (No grouping)

    Representations Register - Deposit Stage

    1120.D1 C MNational Grid AMEC Environment & Infrastructu KP2

    Site No: 118 Site Reference: A-KP2-G-F Site Name: North East Cardiff (West of Pontprennau)

    Strategic Sites

    Council's Response(s):

    Summary: Site crossed by National Grid high voltage o