business intelligence at bca - sascommunity · business intelligence at bca don’t do it without...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Tim Schiffers
Senior Vice President Corporate Development
Direct Group Bertelsmann
Business Intelligence at BCADon’t do it without IT: Managing customers in a highly competitive environment
2
Agenda
BCA An introduction to company and business model
UK Book Market The challenges and BCA’s response
New Database Architecture at BCA SAS as overall database marketing environment
ROAC Benchmark SAS as integrated business intelligence solution?
3
Agenda
BCA An introduction to company and business model
UK Book Market The challenges and BCA’s response
New Database Architecture at BCA SAS as overall database marketing environment
ROAC Benchmark SAS as integrated business intelligence solution?
4
Company Overview BCA
BCA (Book Club Associates) formed in 1966, now 100% owned by
UK market leader in book club and mail order marketing
Specialist in Direct Marketing and Cross ChannelCustomer Relations: Direct Mail, Press/Inserts, Doordrops, Online, Telemarketing
Annual marketing spend of over £45 million
General clubs Fiction clubs Specialist clubs
Employees 500
Members 1.5million
Turnover ~ £100million
BCA in Numbers
5
Overview Direct Group / Bertelsmann
Employees 76.2k
Turnover (€)17.0bn
Bertelsmann
Members >30mi
Turnover (€) 2.2bn
Direct Group
BCA is the fourth biggest book club business of Direct Group Bertelsmann, the world market leader in direct-to-customer business
Other BertelsmannDivisions
6
The Club Mechanism
NM Marketing CM Marketing
Introductory Offer“Choose 5 books from 99p”Channels:- direct mail- door drops- press / inserts- online- telemarketing
Regular Catalogue Mailings(10 – 16 Mailings pa)- expert editorial selections- overall discounts- special offers / promotionsFull E-Commerce Websites
Commitmentto buy a certain number of books over the term of the membership (e.g. 4 books in a year)
Enforcement Mechanism- negative option- default
Buying licenses from publishers in contrast to retailers that buy from wholesalers
Book Club Rights
7
Agenda
BCA An introduction to company and business model
UK Book Market The challenges and BCA’s response
New Database Architecture at BCA SAS as overall database marketing environment
ROAC Benchmark SAS as integrated business intelligence solution?
8
The UK Book Market – An Increasingly Competitive Landscape
1995 2000 2005
Traditional Competition:Concentration of Booksellers
New Competitors:E-commerce &Supermarkets
Other Factors:Format change &Price Perception
‘95 – ‘97• Heavy discounting,
but without real analysis
‘98 – ‘00• More selective discounting • Stores become homogenous• Central buying introduced
‘97• Watersone
buys Dillons• Borders buys
Books Etc.
‘98• WHSmith buys
Menzies
‘03• Ottackars buys
Hammicks
‘97• AMAZON
launches in UK
‘99• BOL
launches in UK
’01• AMAZON takes over operation
of Waterstones website• BOL is integrated into BCA
and becomes club business• Supermarkets increase focus on selling
media products, initially music and videos / DVD’s, but continuously more books
• Concentration on key titles
• Tesco online becomes key competitor of AMAZON for online book retail
• Hardbacks are in decline as a format
• Size of supermarkets and chains leads to focus on key titles, which is reflected in publicity
• Cheap or free book promotions of magazines and newspapers
Net
Boo
k ag
reem
ent d
isba
nded
9
BCA Strategy
• Continuity Business
• Complementary “Club Extra” offers for book club members, sourced through strategic partnerships:
Book ClubCore Business
• Recruiting and servicing members in the traditional Book Club model
• Build on:• unique publisher
relations / editorial expertise
• state-of-the-art database marketing
• high performancesystems (SAP, SAS, Microsoft)
to constantly improve efficiency & effectiveness
Additional Products and Services
New BusinessInitiatives
• Leveraging assets and / or know-how into related new businesses, e.g.:
• Magic Offers (direct selling)
• Video/DVD, Music, Toys, Gifts(with e.g. )
• DVD Rental:
• Party plan concept forchildren’s books and toys:
10
CRM at BCA – Managing the Member Life CycleCurrent Member
GOAL:Intro-payer
New Member
Less Active Member
Dormant Member
Lapsed Member
Multi-buyer / Active Member
• Improve customer relations and customer management across all channels and stages of their membership
• Thus, increase efficiency and effectiveness and consequently maximize profitability
Commitment Reminders- Different chains according to behaviour to date
and stage in membership
Segmentation - Different treatments depending on current
and forecasted future behaviour
Contact Suppression- Frequency reduction for slow
buyers
Dormancy Reactivation- Special messages and
promotions for dormant customers
- Slow buyer programme
New Member Models- Response modelling- Backend modelling
DormancyPrevention- Special
messaging and promotions for members identified as at risk
Cancellation Reversal- Dedicated campaigns for members
that have cancelled recently
New Member ContactStrategy
New Member Activation- Welcome
material- Welcome
e-mails
Payment Reminders and Dunning- Different chains according to
life stages
11
Agenda
BCA An introduction to company and business model
UK Book Market The challenges and BCA’s response
New Database Architecture at BCA SAS as overall database marketing environment
ROAC Benchmark SAS as integrated business intelligence solution?
12
Old Database Architecture BCA
Objectives
• Implementation of an efficient DatabaseMarketing Solution to support:
– New and Current Member campaigns– Media Sales processes– Ad-hoc analysis– Modelling
• Replace the existing systems (Protagona, Customer DB, FastStats)
• Optimise the business processes
Before
SAP R/3
Protagona
FastStats
CD2 +Doc1
BW
CustDB
Issues
• Very long campaign run-times
• Very long update run-times, leading to infrequent updates of customer database
• Array of different technologies
• Over-complicated business processes
13
CustDB
Benefits New SAS Database Architecture
Before
SAP R/3
Protagona
FastStats
CD2 +Doc1
After
CD2 +Doc1
SAP R/3
SAS
• Significant reduction of IT costs
• Improved business processes
• Complexity reduction
• Reduction of data replication
• Significantly improved database marketing capabilities
BW
BW
Objectives
• Implementation of an efficient DatabaseMarketing Solution to support:
- New and Current Member campaigns- Media Sales processes- Ad-hoc analysis- Modelling
• Replace the existing systems (Protagona, Customer DB, FastStats)
• Optimise the business processes
Benefits
14
SAS
New SAS Based Database Architecture
SAP R/3
PSA
Segmentation Templates
Update Customer Account In SAP R/3• Default• Programme• Marketing Message
Update Internet & IVR
OutputSystems
Database Marketing(Analytics, Modelling, Segmentation)
Other data sourcesInternet, …
BW Cubes
Integrated Solution for:
- Campaign management
- Database marketing
- Data warehousingD
ata
Cle
ansi
ng
15
Improved Database Marketing Capabilities due to SAS
Totally up to date data as updates are run daily instead of monthly
Elimination of data redundancies and discrepancies
Faster deployment of campaigns and running of analysis
Very robust environment with checks and balances as well as security layers
Openness of platform will allow to easily ad further SAS components and tools
1
5
2
3
4
16
Agenda
BCA An introduction to company and business model
UK Book Market The challenges and BCA’s response
New Database Architecture at BCA SAS as overall database marketing environment
ROAC Benchmark SAS as integrated business intelligence solution?
17
The ROAC Benchmark – Setting the Stage
Overall Situation BCA
SAP R/3Transactional Backbone
(Finance, Sales Order Process,Billing and Payment, Marketing
Campaign Planning, …)
Database of R/3(> 3.4 TB)
Database(≈ 1 TB)
Database(≈ 450 GB)
BWReportingAnalysis
SASAnalysisModellingSegmentation
• R/3 as the transactional backbone• BW utilised for:
– Reporting– Analysis– Base for Protagona (segmentation engine
until 09/2004)• SAS
– Analysis– Modelling – Segmentation
– Current Member campaigns– New Member campaigns– Media sales
18
Core Questions
The ROAC Benchmark – Setting the Stage
• Does BCA (or other clubs) really need 2 data warehouse systems?
• Does SAS offer adequate and sufficient functionality in the areas of:
– Analysis – Reporting (Finance, Marketing, … )– Scenario building & forecasting – Profiling
• Does SAS provide a sufficient technical environment in terms of:
– SAP integration– Scalability & flexibility– Performance
• Does an integrated solution based on SAS provide cost advantages in comparison to a split BW / SAS environment?
• Does an integrated solution provide synergy potential?
SAP R/3Transactional Backbone
(Finance, Sales Order Process,Billing and Payment, Marketing
Campaign Planning, …)
Database of R/3(> 3.4 TB)
Database(≈ 1 TB)
Database(≈ 450 GB)
BWReportingAnalysis
SASAnalysisModellingSegmentation
?
19
What and Why ROAC Prototype as Benchmark The Concept
ROAC =Return On
Acquisition Cost =Profit over lifeAcquisition cost
• Measures the effectiveness of NM marketing investment decisions
• Is measured for each individual campaign
Complexities Requirements
• Expenditures and associated revenues are recorded over entire life of member
• Therefore ROAC will always have an element of actual performance and an element of forecast performance
• Profiles created so forecasts can be made- Lifecycle Profile
speed at which members leave- Activity Profile
idea of member quality over life- Purchase Profile
shows how much and when members spend
• Forecast has to be possible 6 months after the campaign begins
• Reporting process has to be automated; manual data inputs should be kept to minimum
• Profile production has to be automated; user should be able to specify level at which profile is produced
• Reports have to be easily accessible and easy to interpret for all business users
20
Benchmark - Implementation
Transactional Data:• Customer• Campaign• Products
Financial Data
LoadingCleansingExtraction
SAS Foundation Layer
Segmentation Cube
SAS: Database MarketingSAS: ROAC Benchmark
SAP R/3
CampaignTemplates Ad-Hoc
Output
Staging Area
SAS Solution Adapter for SAP R/3
Architecture SAS:• SAS Base• ETL Server• Metadata Server
Tools SAS:• Enterprise Guide• ETL Studio• Data Quality Solution• SAS Base
21
Benchmark - Implementation (II)
Transactional Data:• Customer• Campaign• Products
Financial DataData fromother
Systems
LoadingCleansingExtraction
SAS Foundation Layer
ROAC Aggregation Cube
Importfrom
MS Excel
Reporting
Segmentation Cube
ForecastingProfiling
End User (MS Excel, Internet)
SAS: Database MarketingSAS: ROAC Benchmark
SAP R/3
PrototypeTables
CampaignTemplates Ad-Hoc
Output
Staging Area
SAS Solution Adapter for SAP R/3
Architecture SAS:• SAS Base• ETL Server• OLAP Server• Metadata Server
Tools SAS:• Enterprise Guide• ETL/OLAP Studio• Data Quality Solution• SAS Base
22
Benchmark Findings - Functionality
SAS provides very powerful tools for analysis and the running of reports as well as simulations
Forecasts and profiles can be generated efficiently with a great level of detail
All of the above is supported by a large array of analytical and statistical functionalityIn addition, the flexibility to produce own functionality remains
While use of reporting and what-if-scenario is facilitated by Excel, analysis and forecasting require in-depth knowledge of SAS
Data retrieval is fast and large sets of data can be sorted, grouped, structured and displayed quite easily
23
Benchmark Findings - Technology
Initial implementation process is not simpleRequires deep knowledge of SAP as well as good knowledge of SAS, interface building and the extraction tool
Performance of SAS extraction depends on data volumes, SAS input requires extensive file testing
Data Extraction
SAS provides very powerful development tools (4GL language, good support of standard SQL)
Enterprise guide is well suited for development and power user team
Flexibility
SAS shows very impressive performance even on large volumesBut, system design must be done with performance in mind, some fine-tuning necessary
Performance with concurrent activities is fine overallEnterprise guide gives a lot of power to the users, this needs to be managed
Performance
24
Benchmark Findings – Cost Advantages and Synergies
Unified environment will reduce costs in the following areas:- Development- AMS- Operations (hosting, hardware, storage)- Training
SAS pricing is rather complex and rent instead of ownership with maintenance differs from general industry practice
Integrated solution for database marketing and data warehouse provides significant synergy potential:- Reporting / analysis and database marketing to benefit from each other’s work
(scorecards, credit screening, segmentation, planning)- Reduction of duplication of efforts- Potential to integrate database marketing and parts of finance team
Cost Advantages
Synergies
25
Benchmark – Results Summary
High acceptance within user community1
Powerful system with an excellent toolset
Broad set of standard functionalities
TechnologyIntegration SAP and SAS is acceptable
2
Flexible and scalable architectureImpressive performance
Cost3
Synergy Potential4
☺
☺
☺
Functionality
Integrated solution reduces the operational IT cost
Integrated solution provides synergy potential
Data retrieval and manipulation are fast
26
SAS Could Definitely Serve as the One Integrated BusinessIntelligence Solution for BCA
SAP R/3
PSA
SAS
Segmentation Templates
Update Customer Account In SAP R/3• Default• Program• Marketing Message
Update Internet & IVR
OutputSystems
Data Warehouse(Reporting & Analytics)
ROACProduct AffinityAuthor AffinityProfilingCorrelations Product MixCustomer behaviour
Other data sourcesInternet, …
Dat
aC
lean
sing
Database Marketing(Analytics, Modelling, Segmentation)BW Cubes