bloodstain evidence may reveal: origin(s) of bloodstain distance of bloodstain from target direction...

80
Bloodstain Evidence Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood left its source Position of victim & assailant Movement of victim & assailant Number of blows/shots 1

Upload: marvin-warren

Post on 26-Dec-2015

227 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Bloodstain EvidenceBloodstain EvidenceMay reveal:May reveal:

• Origin(s) of bloodstain• Distance of bloodstain from target• Direction from which blood impacted• Speed with which blood left its source• Position of victim & assailant• Movement of victim & assailant• Number of blows/shots

1

Page 2: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Liquid BloodLiquid Blood• Physical properties

– viscosity

– surface tension

– specific gravity

• Behaves as a projectile in motion– biology, physics, maths

2

Page 3: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Blood lab 1

• We measured the diameter of blood drops from different heights

• Whiteboard now:– What was the independent variable?– What was the dependent variable?– What type of graph did we use and why?

Page 4: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Surface TensionSurface Tension

• Resistance to penetration & separation• Surface acts to reduce surface area

• Smallest SA to Volume ratio is offered by sphere

3

Page 5: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Dripping BloodDripping Blood

Blood drop grows until Wt (G) > S.T.

Single drop breaks free (teardrop shape)

Surface tension pulls in vertically

Shape settles into sphere (0.05 ml)

Does not break up until impact

And horizontally

Blood trickles downwards

4

Page 6: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Drop size

.

Standard drop size 50ul (0.05ml)

.

Rapid bleeding gives slightly larger drop

Shaking/movementcasts off smaller drops

.

5

Page 7: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Terminal Velocity v Distance Fallen(metric)

Terminal velocity as a function of distance fallen (metric)

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Fall distance (m)

Ter

min

al v

elo

city

(m

/s)

6

Page 8: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Terminal Velocity v Distance Fallen(imperial)

Terminal velocity as a function of distance fallen (imperial)

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

Distance fallen (f)

Te

rmin

al v

elo

cit

y (f

/s)

7

Page 9: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Free Falling Blood Droplets

.

50 ul4.6 mm

7.5 m/s

4.2 to5.4 m

0.5 ul2.12 mm

2.4 to 3 m

.4.6 m/s

0.12 ul1.32 mm

0.84 to 1 m

.3.3 m/s

0.06 ul1.1 mm

0.5 to 0.65 m

.2.2 m/s

8

Page 10: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Shape & Size of BloodspotShape & Size of Bloodspot

• Depends mostly on nature of target surface– texture (rough or smooth)– porous or non porous

• Size is related to distance fallen, provided:– standard 50 ul drop of blood

• There is little change in spot diameter beyond a fall distance of 1.2 m

9

Page 11: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Height FallenHeight Fallen

Single drops of blood falling from fingertip onto smooth cardboard from various heights.No change in diameter beyond 7 ft.

Adapted from Introduction to Forensic Sciences,W. Eckert, CRC, 1997

10

Page 12: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood
Page 13: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood
Page 14: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood
Page 15: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Blood Lab 2

• We looked at how different surfaces affect the blood splatter

• Whiteboard now:– What was the independent variable?– Dependent variable?– Control?– What kind of graph did you use and why?

Page 16: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Effect of Target SurfaceEffect of Target Surface

. .... .Spreads out smoothly ST of spreading edge is

broken by irregular surface

11

Page 17: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Experiments with Falling Blood DropletsExperiments with Falling Blood Droplets

blood

dropper

ruler

Terazzo floor

whiteboard

rough paper towel

paper

Fabric (theatre green)

Height

Target Surface

12

Page 18: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Height/Surface

Single drop of blood falling from various heights (m) onto various surfaces

smooth floor paper towel fabric

0.5

1

2

3

0.5

1

2

3

13

Page 19: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Blood Lab 3

• We looked at direction of blood splatter

• Whiteboard now:– What was the independent variable?– Dependent variable?

– CSI video

Page 20: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Blood Lab 4

• We looked at how angle has an effect on blood drops

• Whiteboard now:– Independent and dependent variable?– Name 2 characteristics you noticed of the blood

spatter relative to angle

Page 21: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Angle of Angle of ImpactImpact

90

10

70

2030

60 50 40

Adapted from Introduction to Forensic Sciences,W. Eckert, CRC, 1997

80

Gravitational dense zoneat lower edge

14

Page 22: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Wave Cast-offWave Cast-offDavid Sadler:David Sadler:

.Parent drop

wave cast-off

Tail of wave cast-off points back to parent drop

Tail of elongated stain points in direction of travel

15

Page 23: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Point of ConvergencePoint of Convergence16

Page 24: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Point of ConvergencePoint of Convergence5 ml blood squirted from a syringe from height of 1 m

17

Page 25: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Point of OriginPoint of Origin

length

width

Angle of impact = arc sin W/L

Distance from point of convergence

Hei

ght a

bove

poi

nt o

f co

nver

genc

e

Origin

85 60 45 30

181

Page 26: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Tracing Origin of Tracing Origin of BloodspotsBloodspots

• Point of convergence method– 2 dimensional image

• Point of origin method– adds 3rd dimension to image

• In practice:– use of string & protractor at scene

– use of computer at laboratory

19

Page 27: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Blood SpatterBlood Spatter

• Low velocity (5 f/s, 1.5 m/s)– e.g. free-falling drops, cast off from weapon

• Medium velocity (25 - 100 f/s, 7.5 - 30 m/s)– e.g. baseball bat blows

• High velocity (>100 f/s, 30 m/s)– e.g. gunshot, machinery

20

Page 28: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Herbert Leon MacDonell,

Laboratory of Forensic Science,P.O. Box 1111,Corning,New York,14830,USA

21

Page 29: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Cast-off from WeaponCast-off from Weapon

• First blow causes bleeding• Subsequent blows contaminate weapon with

blood• Blood is cast-off tangientially to arc of upswing

or backswing• Pattern & intensity depends on:

– type of weapon

– amount of blood adhering to weapon

– length of arc

23

Page 30: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Downswing of HammerDownswing of Hammer

24

Page 31: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Cast-off from WeaponCast-off from Weapon

ceiling

25

Page 32: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Overhead swing with bloodied metal bar26

Page 33: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Cast-off Pattern (1/2)Cast-off Pattern (1/2)

27

Page 34: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Cast off Pattern (2/2)Cast off Pattern (2/2)1

2

3

28

Page 35: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Cast off Pattern (2/2) Cast off Pattern (2/2) ? Sequence? Sequence

29

Page 36: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Cast off Pattern (2/2) Cast off Pattern (2/2) ? Sequence? Sequence 1

(4 spots)

2(3 spots)

3(2 spots)

If weapon does not pick up more blood, spatter from subsequent backswings becomes progressively less.In practice weapon picks up more blood with each successful blow.

30

Page 37: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Three overhead swings with hatchet

31

Page 38: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Cast-off & medium velocity spatter32

Page 39: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Cast-off & medium velocity spatter 233

Page 40: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Cast-off PatternCast-off Pattern? Object? Object

34

Page 41: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Cast-off PatternCast-off Patternfrom Handfrom Hand

35

Page 42: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Cast-off pattern from bloodied hand swung in front of target

6” ruler

36

Page 43: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

.... ...

..

...

Drip PatternDrip Pattern

• Free-falling drops dripping into wet blood• Large irregular central stain• Small round & oval satellite stains

.. .......

37

Page 44: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Drip 1:Drip 1:

Blood dripping into itself from height of 1 m (8 drops)

38

Page 45: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Drip 2Drip 2

Blood dripping into itself from height of 1 m (8 drops)

39

Page 46: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Dripping onto steps

40

Page 47: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Splash onto vertical surface

6” ruler

10 ml blood thrown 1 m onto a vertical target surface

45

Page 48: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Stamping in blood 1

Area seen in close-up in next slide

46

Page 49: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Stamping in blood Close-up of heel area

47

Page 50: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Stamp 1Stamp 1

Blood pool (10 drops) before stamping

48

Page 51: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Stamp 2Stamp 2

Blood pool (10 drops) after stamping49

Page 52: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Arterial Spurt PatternArterial Spurt Pattern• Blood exiting body under arterial pressure• Large stains with downward flow on

vertical surfaces• wave-form of pulsatile flow may be

apparent

50

Page 53: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Small arterial spurt

spatter

broken pottery

51

Page 54: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Neck incisions (scene)52

Page 55: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Neck incisions

Thyroid cartilage

Probe in carotid artery

‘Hesitation’ injuries

53

Page 56: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Medium Velocity Medium Velocity Blood SpatterBlood Spatter

• Blood source subjected to MV impact– (25 - 100 f/s, 7.5 - 30 m/s)

• Spot diameter: mostly 1 - 4 mm• Blows with weapon (e.g. baseball bat)

54

Page 57: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Medium velocity blood spatter.Point of impact 15 cm in front of vertical target surface

6” ruler

55

Page 58: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Flick 1:Flick 1:

Blood flicked between middle finger & thumb onto a vertical smooth surface from a distance of 15 cm

56

Page 59: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Flick 2:Flick 2:

Blood flicked between middle finger & thumb onto a vertical smooth surface from a distance of 15 cm

57

Page 60: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

High Velocity Blood SpatterHigh Velocity Blood Spatter• Blood source subjected to HV impact

– > 100 f/s, 30 m/s

• Fine mist: spot size < 0.1 mm• Small mass limits spread to 1 m• !Some larger droplets reach further• Gunshot

– back-spatter from entry wound– forward spatter from exit wound

• High speed machinery

58

Page 61: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Gunshot: back& forward spatterBloodstained foam held just above target surface.

Back-spatter on entry

Forward spatteron exit

bullet

Bullet passing L to R just above sheet

Bullet enters foam

bullet exits foam

59

Page 62: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Gunshot Back SpatterGunshot Back Spatter

• Arises from entrance wound• Passes back towards weapon & shooter• Seen only at close range of fire• Seen on:

– inside of barrel

– exterior of weapon

– hand, arm, chest of shooter

60

Page 63: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Back spatter on steadying

hand

61

Page 64: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Gunshot Forward SpatterGunshot Forward Spatter

• Arises from exit wound• Passes forwards in same direction as shot• More copious than back-spatter• Can be seen at any range of fire• Seen on nearby surfaces, objects, persons

– especially on wall behind victim

62

Page 65: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Forward spatter (5 ms after bullet impacted at 1000 f/s)

2.5 cm

blood soaked target

bullet

63

Page 66: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

6” ruler

Forward spatter onto target placed 15 cm behind point of HV bullet impact (bullet passing towards screen) 1

64

Page 67: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Forward spatter (closer view)65

Page 68: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Forward spatter (closest view)

5 mm

66

Page 69: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Wipe PatternsWipe Patterns• Object moves through a wet bloodstain• Feathered edge suggests direction

67

Page 70: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Transfer PatternsTransfer Patterns

• Wet, bloodied object contacts a secondary surface

• Transfer from:– hand, fingers

– shoes, weapon

– hair

• Transfer to:– walls, ceilings

– clothing, bedding

• Produces mirror-image of bloodied object

68

Page 71: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Transfer from hair (hair-swipe) 1

69

Page 72: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Transfer from hair (hair-swipe) 2

70

Page 73: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Flow PatternsFlow Patterns• Blood flows horizontally & vertically• Altered by contours, obstacles• Often ends in pool

71

Page 74: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Flow pattern72

Page 75: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Trapped!

73

Page 76: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Stabbing 1

74

Page 77: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Stabbing 275

Page 78: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Blood flow on shirt

Horizontally to R side

76

Page 79: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Pattern on shirt77

Page 80: Bloodstain Evidence May reveal: Origin(s) of bloodstain Distance of bloodstain from target Direction from which blood impacted Speed with which blood

Bloodspots on trousers78