bladder cancer diagnostic-initial team project

40
ACDS Laboratories A new biomarker for bladder cancer diagnosis Mirza Ahmed Katy Chun Sagar Desai Nik Sanyal August 29, 2013

Upload: sagar-desai

Post on 23-Dec-2014

336 views

Category:

Health & Medicine


2 download

DESCRIPTION

A mini-project to find biomarkers for bladder cancer diagnosis. We narrowed down our list of viable candidates down to three that could be used in combination to provide sensitivity and specificity values greater than 94%. Furthermore, we calculated long-term monitoring and payor costs as well as potential profit.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

ACDS Laboratories

A new biomarker for bladder cancer diagnosis

Mirza AhmedKaty Chun

Sagar DesaiNik Sanyal

August 29, 2013

Page 2: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Who We Are

Dedicated to the advancement of biomarker development to address unmet medical needs and improve patient health

Page 3: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

What is Bladder Cancer?

Stages of bladder cancerhttp://www.urologyhealth.org/urology/articles/images/anatomy_bladdercancer.jpg

1. Reasonably large population- Fourth most common cancer in men and eighth most common cancer in women5

- 72,570 new cases in the US in 20132

2. Importance of early detection- 96.4% 5-year relative survival rate if diagnosed in stage 0 or 1

- 15,210 deaths in the US in 20132

3. Costly expenses- Highest lifetime treatment costs per patient of all cancers 3

- “The natural history of bladder cancer is one of recurrence and progression necessitating long-term evaluation and monitoring”5

2National Cancer Institute, Bladder Cancer3Sievert et al., World J Uro. 20095Gilbert et al., Urology. 2003

Page 4: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Current clinical flow for the diagnosis of bladder cancer

Page 5: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Sensitivity and specificity- Sensitivity (true positive rate) measures the proportion of actual positives that are correctly identified by the test4

- Specificity (true negative rate) measures the proportion of negatives that are correctly identified by the test4

4Altman & Bland, BMJ, 1994

Page 6: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Current diagnostic methods- Voided urine cytologyPresence of abnormal (cancerous) cells in urineIssues: low sensitivity (43.8%), results not available immediately 5

- CystoscopyEndoscopy via urethra Issues: Invasive, dependent on operator skill,inability to detect recurrences in the upper urinary tractrigid cystoscopy - painful and needs general anesthesia, may lead to scarring

flexible cystoscopy - does not allow removal of tissue5

Cystoscopy of the bladder http://www.mayoclinic.com/images/image_popup/

r7_cystoscopy.jpg

5Gilbert et al., Urology. 2003

Page 7: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Demand for a better biomarker

- Need exists for biomarker that is:- High sensitivity and specificity- Easily detected using a non-invasive procedure

- cost-effective- Several candidate biomarkers 6,7, but most have drawbacks

6Urquidi et al., Urology. 20127Liu et al., BMC Cancer. 2013

Page 8: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Selected Biomarkers1) miRNA - 135b/15b/1224-3p

2) DD23 antigen

3) Protein markers - VEGF, ApoE & IL-8

Page 9: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

1. MicroRNAA combination of 3 miRNAs - 135b/15b/1224-3p - appear as promising stable biomarkers8

AssayUrinary samples (n = 121) from patients with bladder cancer and age-matched controls (n = 53) were analyzed using real-time PCR for changes in expression levels.

Clinical validitySensitivity: 94%Specificity: 51%Overall accuracy: 86%

8Miah et al., British Journal of Cancer. 2012

Page 10: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

2. DD23 antigenAnti-DD23 antibody shows increased sensitivity of urinary based detection of UCC when combined with cytology5

AssayUrinary samples (n = 151) from patients with a history of bladder cancer were evaluated for DD23 antigen expression using alcohol-fixed urinary cytology

Clinical validity Sensitivity (%)

Specificity (%)

Cytology

43.8 92.0

Cytology + DD23

78.1 58.6

5Gilbert et al., Urology. 2003

Page 11: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

3. Protein markers

A combination of 3 proteins - VEGF/ApoE/IL-8 - appear as a highly accurate biomarker10 - Vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF)- Apolipoprotein E (ApoE)- Interleukin-8 (IL-8)

AssayVoided urine samples from individuals without previous history of UCC (n = 63) and individuals with newly diagnosed UCC (n=64) were quantified by Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay (ELISA)

Clinical validitySensitivity: 90%Specificity: 97%Overall accuracy: 93%

10 Goodison et al., PLOSone. 2012

Page 12: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Scientific assessmentElevated levels of biomarkers in bladder cancer individuals

10 Goodison et al., PLOSone. 2012

Page 13: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

VEGF (Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor)Induces blood vessel formation (Angiogenesis) which helps sustains tumor growth.Frequently upregulated during bladder6, prostate12, breast cancer 13. Anti-cancer drug Bevacizumab (Avastin) targets VEGF receptor binding. ApoE (Apolipoprotein E)A type of lipoprotein found in chylomicron intermediate-density lipoprotein (IDL). In breast cancer, ApoE is upregulated via HIF1α14. IL-8 (Interleukin-8)Signaling factor produced by endothelial cells and macrophages. Promotes angiogenesis during hypoxia and environmental stress. Promotes cell proliferation in lung 15 and colon cancer16 .

Scientific assessment VEGF, ApoE and IL-8 in cancer

Waugh DJ, Wilson C. Clin Cancer Res. 2008 Nov 1;14(21)

6Urquidi et al., Urology. 201212Pratheeshkumar et al., PLoS One, 201213Marty and Pivot, Eur. J. Cancer, 200814Papi et al, PLoS One, 201315Luppi et al, Lung Cancer, 200716Ning et al, Int. J. Cancer, 2011

Page 14: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Scientific assessmentAdvantages of ELISA

- Rapid- Low detection limits - Low per sample cost- High-throughput (96 or 384-well format)

biology.arizona.edu/immunology/activities/elisa/graphics/elisa_plate.gif

Epitomics Inc.

Page 15: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Revised clinical flow for the diagnosis of bladder cancer

Page 16: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Patient ValueEarly, highly-accurate, non-invasive diagnosis

- Early stage diagnosis increases have long-term survival rates greater than 80%2

- Accurate diagnosis allows appropriate treatment and prevents unnecessary surgery- Avoid the need for invasive cystoscopy

Easy, long-term monitoring

- Cost-effective- Can be performed in outpatient setting

2National Cancer Institute, Bladder Cancer

Page 17: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Economic ValueEconomic analysis: Current prices

Cytology

Average cost = $100 17

Cystoscopy

Current Medicare reimbursement = $379 non-facility18

17Lotan and Roehrborn, J. Urology. 200218 CMS.gov, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, Cytology

Page 18: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Current pricing for the diagnosis & monitoring of bladder cancer

$100 + $379 = $479

$100 + $379 = $479

Page 19: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Economic ValueEconomic analysis: Recurrences and monitoring

80% of bladder cancer patients survive 5-years19.

Long-term monitoring of bladder cancer patients:- Cytology and cystoscopy:

Every 3 months during first 2 years (8 procedures)Every 6 months during next 2 years (4 procedures)Every 12 months during subsequent years 20

1initial + 8 + 4 + 1 = 14 procedures/patient/5 years

19 Mayo Clinic, Cancer. 201120 Hong and Loughlin, Urology. 2008

Page 20: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

- Average amount of diagnosis and monitoring procedures/patient in first 5 years = 14 times Total cost diag/monitoring = (cost of cytology+cystoscopy) X 14 = $479 X 14 = $6,706

- 72,570 new cases/year- Approximately 80% of new cases or 58,056 will survive 5 years= 58,056 X 14 = 812,784 procedures Total costdiag/monitoring = $479 X 812,784 procedures = $389,323,536

Economic ValueEconomic analysis: Current prices

Page 21: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Economic valueEconomic analysis: Pricing/cost estimate

Assay development + Instrumentation Costs$100,000* x 3 proteins = $300,000

(Source: ImmunoChemistry Technologies, LLC.)

Reagent cost per sample:3 proteins X 16 replicates21 = 48 wells/urine sample

4 samples/kit or $156/4 samples = $39/urine sample

ELISA test price to payor: $156 (Source: ImmunoChemistry Technologies, LLC.)

21 Burd, Clin Microbiol Rev. 2010

Page 22: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Projected prices for the diagnosis & monitoring of bladder cancer

$479 + $156 = $635

$156

Price of ELISA kit = $156

Page 23: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Economic valueEconomic analysis: Projected savings

Estimated cost of procedure with biomarker = $156

Initial cost of diagnosis = $479 + $156 = $635Diagnosis and monitoring costs over 5 years = $635 + (13 X $156) = $2663/patient

For 5 year survivors, total cost of monitoring = 58,056 X $2663 = $154,603,228

Therefore, diagnosis and monitoring cost savings = $389,323,536 - $154,603,228= $234,720,308

Page 24: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Market assessmentEconomic analysis: Projected value

Unit demand = Expected number of tests carried out per year = 812,784/5 years = 162,556 tests/yearPrice that payors would pay for test = $156Expected annual revenue = = $156/test X 162,556 tests = $25,358,736

Total Costs = Assay development cost + cost of reagentsAssay development cost = $300,000Cost of reagents = $39 X 162,556 = $6,339,684Total Cost = $6,339,684 + $300,000 = $6,639,684

Potential Profit = $25,358,736 - $6,639,684 =

$19,019,052

Page 25: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Investment Recommendation- High clinical validity and accuracy as a biological indicator- Non-invasive and easy long-term monitoring- Cost-effective- High unit demand

Based on our opportunity analysis, we would strongly recommend investing in this biomarker

Page 26: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project
Page 27: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

APPENDIX

Page 28: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Signs and symptoms

- Hematuria (blood in urine)- Urgent need to empty bladder- Frequent urination- Needing to strain (bear down) when urinating- Pain during urination

Source: National Cancer Institute, What You Need to Know About Bladder Cancer,

Page 29: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Bladder anatomy-Inner layer: Inner lining of bladder. Composed of transitional cells, 7 cell layers thick. Capable of stretching to accommodate urine.

-Middle layer: Smooth muscle. Contraction of muscle squeezes urine out during urination.

- Outer layer: External layer containing fat, fibrous tissue and blood vessels.

Page 30: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Transitional Cell Carcinoma- 90% of bladder cancer occurs in transitional cells (NCI)

- Known as transitional cell carcinoma (TCC) or urothelial cell carcinoma (UCC). (World Health Organization)

Page 31: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Potential BiomarkersPotential biomarkers:1) Protein assays2) miRNA3) DD23 monoclonal antibody4) YAP-15) Metallothionein6) Prefoldin

Page 32: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

IL8 (Interleukin-8) & Cancer- A chemokine (signalling factor) produced by Endothelial cells and macrophages. “Many studies have shown overexpression of IL-8 by tumor cells, often induced in response to chemotherapeutic interventions or environmental stresses such as hypoxia.”“The induction of IL-8 signaling activates multiple upstream signaling pathways that (a) impinge on gene expression via regulation of numerous transcription factor activities, (b) modulate the cellular proteome at the level of translation, and/or (c) effect the organization of the cell cytoskeleton through posttranslational regulation of regulatory proteins. As a consequence of the diversity of effectors and downstream targets, IL-8 signaling promotes angiogenic responses in endothelial cells, increases proliferation and survival of endothelial and cancer cells, and potentiates the migration of cancer cells, endothelial cells, and infiltrating neutrophils at the tumor site. Accordingly, IL-8 expression correlates with the angiogenesis, tumorigenicity, and metastasis of tumors in numerous xenograft and orthotopic in vivo models. ”

Waugh DJ, Wilson C. Clin Cancer Res. 2008 Nov 1;14(21)

Page 33: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

IL8 (Interleukin-8) & Cancer- A chemokine (signalling factor) produced by Endothelial cells and macrophages. “Many studies have shown overexpression of IL-8 by tumor cells, often induced in response to chemotherapeutic interventions or environmental stresses such as hypoxia.”“The induction of IL-8 signaling activates multiple upstream signaling pathways that (a) impinge on gene expression via regulation of numerous transcription factor activities, (b) modulate the cellular proteome at the level of translation, and/or (c) effect the organization of the cell cytoskeleton through posttranslational regulation of regulatory proteins. As a consequence of the diversity of effectors and downstream targets, IL-8 signaling promotes angiogenic responses in endothelial cells, increases proliferation and survival of endothelial and cancer cells, and potentiates the migration of cancer cells, endothelial cells, and infiltrating neutrophils at the tumor site. Accordingly, IL-8 expression correlates with the angiogenesis, tumorigenicity, and metastasis of tumors in numerous xenograft and orthotopic in vivo models. ”

Waugh DJ, Wilson C. Clin Cancer Res. 2008 Nov 1;14(21)

Page 34: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

APOE (Apolipoprotein E) & Cancer-APOE : “ class of apolipoprotein found in the chylomicron and Intermediate-density lipoprotein (IDLs) that is essential for the normal catabolism of triglyceride-rich lipoprotein constituents.[1]” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apolipoprotein_E“TAF secreted TGFβ induces TNFα expression in breast CSCs. TNFα binds TNFR1 on breast CSCs and activates the PPARα/HIF1α interplay which up-regulates miR130b expression. The interplay is counterbalanced by PPARγ via miR17-5p up-regulation. In turn, the PPARα/HIF1α interplay regulates CAIX, ApoE, IL6 and SLUG expression.”

Source: Papi et al PLoS One. 2013;8(1):e54968

Page 35: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

VEGF (Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor) & CancerVEGF: Vascular endothelial growth factor, a signalling protien that induces angiogenesis.VEGF is upregulated during hypoxia.

Source: Vishnu et al, Onco Targets Ther. 2011; 4: 97–113.

Page 36: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Role of APOE , IL8, VEGF in bladder cancer

Source: Waugh DJ, Wilson C. Clin Cancer Res. 2008 Nov 1;14(21)

Page 37: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Biomarker Selection- We selected the 3-protein (VEGF, ApoE and IL8) assay as a biomarker.

- Advantages over current protocol:--

Page 38: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Performance of urinary biomarker combinations

Source: Goodison S, Chang M, Dai Y, Urquidi V, Rosser CJ. PLoS One. 2012;7(10)

Page 39: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

Cost of cystoscopy + cytology = $11846/cancer (Kamat et al., 2010)Mean number of subsequent tumor episodes = 3.8 (Soloway et al., 2003)Total cost of initial assessment and surveillance/maintenance =$11846/cancer X 1 initial cancer = $11846$11846/cancer X 3.8 subsequent cancer episodes = $45014.80= $56860.80

Page 40: Bladder Cancer Diagnostic-Initial Team Project

3 Protein marker - Pricing assessment1. Source: BDBiosciencesIL-8 kit. (~$490/kit)

2. Refer to assay development doc. Cheaper price/kit (~$156/kit)

3. 2 x 96-well plates/kit. How many replicates for each patient sample for each protein? 2 to 4 replicates (Source: Burd, Clin Microbiol Rev. 2010 July; 23(3): 550–576. CLSI/NCCLS. 2003. Evaluation of the linearity of quantitative measurement procedures: a statistical approach.Approved guideline. CLSI document EP6-A. Clinical

and Laboratory Standards Institute, Wayne, PA.)