Literatuur OnderzoekPsychologie, November 2012

Janneke Staaks j.staaks@uva.nl

Universiteitsbibliotheek

jstaaks @

2

1

2

Opdracht: Google ‘Martin Luther King’ en vergelijk onderstaande sites met elkaar

Welke site is het meest betrouwbaar?

3

Archive.org

4

Welke rangorde kreeg de meeste stemmen?(1 = meest betrouwbaar, 2 = minst betrouwbaar)

1. www.martinlutherking.org

2. Wikipedia

1. Wikipedia

2. www.martinlutherking.org

A B55%

slechts 30% gaf het goede antwoord

5

What about researchers?

Original papers cited 17 times more (on average: 426 vs 13)

Only about 5% of the citations to the original papers were critical (at all) of the original article.

Some papers cited the original and the rebuttals as though they both supported the same position!

Citation frequency not diminished by rebuttals

http://www.flickr.com/photos/hollywoodplace/5424709209/

PsycINFO

www.uba.uva.nl

Link

Welke zoekopdracht in de Multi-Field Search is de beste uitwerking van het goede antwoord in opdracht 3?

3. Bovenstaande opdrachten zijn hetzelfde

1.

2. ( ) ( )

Search History

Kindt, M. (1998) Cognitive inhibition in phobia. British Journal of Clinical Psychology. 37(1), 103-106.

9

Davey, G., Burgess, I. & Rashes, R. (1995) Coping strategies and phobias: The relationship between fears, phobias and methods of coping with stressors. British Journal of Clinical Psychology. 34(3), 423-434.

10

11

Literatuur zoeken en vinden 12

Thuis toegang

Foto: http://www.flickr.com/photos/striatic/241843728/

Google ‘UvA VPN’

Willingham, D. T. (2007). Cognition: the thinking animal.

13

Werken vanuit zoektermen

Werken vanuit een geschikte basispublicatie

14

Verslaglegging van Psychologisch Onderzoek

15

Evidence Based Medicine (EBM)

Bron: Laika’s Medlibblog

o.a. Pubmed, PsycINFO, Google scholar, Web of Science

o.a. Cochrane Library

o.a. BMJ

o.a. NHG standaarden

o.a. TRIP database

16

Meta-analyse gehechtheid en depressie

Gezocht in: Google Scholar, meta-zoekmachine UB, ScienceDirect en Pubmed

#1 Depressie #2 Attachment #3 (ouder-) kinddepression attachment child    childhood    maternal    adultdepressie gehechtheid  

17

(major depression/ OR recurrent depression/ OR reactive depression/ OR dysthymic disorder/ OR dysthymi*.ti,ab,id. OR anaclitic depression/ OR seasonal affective disorder/ OR "depression (emotion)"/ OR depress*.ti,ab,id. OR affective disorders/ OR affective symptom*.ti,ab,id. OR affective disorder*.ti,ab,id. OR mood disorder*.ti,ab,id.) AND (attachment behavior/ OR attachment disorders/ OR attachment theory/ OR object relations/ OR attachment*.ti,ab,id. OR bond*.ti,ab,id. OR parent-child relation*.ti,ab,id. OR parent child relations/ OR father child relations/ OR mother child relations/ OR parent child communication/ OR father child communication/ OR mother child communication/ OR interpersonal relationships/ OR interpersonal interaction/ OR interpersonal influences/ OR family relations/ OR relationship quality/ OR relationship satisfaction/) AND ((neonatal birth 1 mo or infancy 2 23 mo or preschool age 2 5 yrs or school age 6 12 yrs or adolescence 13 17 yrs or young adulthood 18 29 yrs).ag. OR neonatal development/ OR infant development/ OR early childhood development/ OR childhood development/ OR adolescent development/ OR child psychiatry/ OR orthopsychiatry/ OR adolescent psychiatry/ OR child psychopathology/ OR adolescent psychopathology/ OR child psychology/ OR adolescent psychology/ OR child psychotherapy/ OR adolescent psychotherapy/ OR paediat*.ti,ab,id. OR pediat*.ti,ab,id. OR infant*.ti,ab,id. OR toddler*.ti,ab,id. OR child*.ti,ab,id. OR puberty/ OR puberty.ti,ab,id. OR teen*.ti,ab,id. OR young*.ti,ab,id. OR youth*.ti,ab,id. OR adolesc*.ti,ab,id. OR girl*.ti,ab,id. OR boy*.ti,ab,id. OR nursery school students/ OR kindergarten students/ OR preschool students/ OR preschool*.ti,ab,id. OR elementary school students/ OR primary school students/ OR middle school students/ OR junior high school students/ OR high school students/ OR school*.ti,ab,id. OR junior college students/ OR college students/ OR college*.ti,ab,id. OR universit*.ti,ab,id.) AND (parenting/ OR parental role/ OR parenting skills/ OR exp parenting style/ OR parental characteristics/ OR parental attitudes/ OR parental expectations/ OR parental involvement/ OR parental investment/ OR parent*.ti,ab,id. OR childrearing practices/ OR childrearing attitudes/ OR nuclear family/ OR caregivers/ OR caretak*.ti,ab,id. OR caregiv*.ti,ab,id. OR mothers/ OR mother*.ti,ab,id. OR matern*.ti,ab,id. OR fathers/ OR father*.ti,ab,id. OR patern*.ti,ab,id.) AND ((child* depression inventory OR CDI).ti,ab,id,tm. OR (beck* depression inventory OR BDI).ti,ab,id,tm. OR (youth self report OR YSR).ti,ab,id,tm. OR (child behavio?r checklist OR child behavio?r check list OR CBCL).ti,ab,id,tm. OR (child* hope* scale OR CHS).ti,ab,id,tm. OR ((Kiddie AND Affective AND Schizophrenia) OR Kiddie-SADS OR K-SADS).ti,ab,id,tm. OR (depression questionnaire ADJ2 children).ti,ab,id,tm. OR ((anxiety sensitivity ADJ3 (index OR inventory OR scale OR questionnaire OR profile)) OR ASI).ti,ab,id,tm. OR (revised AND "child anxiety and depression scale").ti,ab,id,tm. OR (sci OR scid OR structured clinical interview).ti,ab,id,tm. OR depressive mood list.ti,ab,id,tm. OR (diagnostic interview schedule OR DISC-C).ti,ab,id,tm. OR DISC.tm. OR inventory to diagnos* depression.ti,ab,id,tm. OR dimensions of depression profile for children.ti,ab,id,tm. OR Screen for Child* Anxiety Related Emotional Disorder*.ti,ab,id,tm. OR SCARED.tm. OR ("mood* and feeling* questionnaire*" OR "mood* and feeling* self-report").ti,ab,id,tm. OR structur* diagnostic interview.ti,ab,id,tm. OR (depress* OR affective).tm. or DSM.ti,ab,id,tm. OR (strange situation* OR SSP).ti,ab,id,tm. OR (Attachment Questionnaire for Children OR AQ-C OR AQC).ti,ab,id,tm. OR ((adult attachment ADJ3 (interview OR inventory OR scale OR dimensions OR questionnaire)) OR AAI OR RAAS).ti,ab,id,tm. OR (adolescen* attachment ADJ3 (questionnaire OR interview OR inventory OR scale)).ti,ab,id,tm. OR ("inventory of parent* and peer attachment" OR "inventory of peer and parent* attachment" OR IPPA).ti,ab,id,tm. OR (hazan AND attachment).ti,ab,id,tm. OR (report* questionnaire for children OR RQC).ti,ab,id,tm. OR experiences in close relationships.ti,ab,id,tm. OR (kern* AND security).ti,ab,id,tm. OR (((separation-reunion OR attachment) AND classification) OR separation-reunion procedure*).ti,ab,id,tm. OR family draw*.ti,ab,id,tm. OR (attachment* OR bond* OR security).tm. OR separation anxiety/ OR separation reactions/)

De zoekopdracht

18

Zoektermen

Ophidiophobia/ 306

snake fear 361

snake phobia 179

overlap (1 OR 2 OR 3) 746

19

Slimmer zoeken

depression

depressive

depressed

depress*depressogenic

depressie

depressotypic

child behavio?r checklist vindt zowel behavior als behaviour

revised ADJ4 "child anxiety and depression scale" vindt ook:

revised version of the child anxiety and depression scale

revised child anxiety and depression scale

child anxiety and depression scale – revised

20

Slimmer zoeken

In welke velden ga je zoeken?

(beck* depression inventory OR BDI).ti,ab,id,tm.

(depress* OR affective).tm.

Zoeken zonder velden: Mapping (mp)

PsycINFO versus Medline

21

Slimmer zoeken

You searched a database and found far too few results. How can you broaden your search and increase the search results? Choose the three right answers from the following.A.  Add search terms and combine with AND.B.  Search more fields, for example "words in abstract".C.  Limit to the most recent publications.D.  Combine the search terms with OR.E.  Use different search terms, for example synonyms.

Tests and measures

Parent-child relationship

Depression ANDAND ANDAND

meta-analyse gehechtheid en depressie

203.000 titles 62.000 titles 114.000 titles

You searched a database and found far too few results. How can you broaden your search and increase the search results? Choose the three right answers from the following.A.  Add search terms and combine with AND.B.  Search more fields, for example "words in abstract".C.  Limit to the most recent publications.D.  Combine the search terms with OR.E.  Use different search terms, for example synonyms.

Depression Parent-child relationship

Tests and measures

meta-analyse gehechtheid en depressie

203.000 titles 62.000 titles 114.000 titles

You searched a database and found far too few results. How can you broaden your search and increase the search results? Choose the three right answers from the following.A.  Add search terms and combine with AND.B.  Search more fields, for example "words in abstract".C.  Limit to the most recent publications.D.  Combine the search terms with OR.E.  Use different search terms, for example synonyms.

Tests and measures

Depression

Parent-child relationship

1.745 titles

203.000 titles 62.000 titles 114.000 titles

meta-analyse gehechtheid en depressie

25

PsycINFO Medline

E

C

NB. 2 titels overlap tussen ERIC en de Cochrane Library

26

Medline/Pubmed: 530 titelsPsycINFO: 238 titelsCinahl: 108 titelsCochrane: 24 titelsEmbase: 958 titels Na ontdubbelen: 1.220 unieke titels

Parenting Stress of Parents with Children with Epilepsy

+ 516

+ 88

+ 33

Retrieved May 24, 2012 with Anna Ridderinkhof

+ 8

EMBASE

Medline

P

Refworks

32

www.refworks.com

of www.uba.uva.nl > dienstenschrijven en publiceren ofcursussen en workshops