banyule city council agenda 1 december 2014 part 2 of 4
DESCRIPTION
ÂTRANSCRIPT
ATTACHMENTS
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 115
3.1 The 2013-2014 State of the Environment Report
Attachment 1 The 2013-2014 State of the Environment Report ........................... 116
3.2 The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2014 -2017
Attachment 1 The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017 ....................... 128
3.3 Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
Attachment 1 Biodiversity Plan 2014-17 .............................................................. 148
4.1 Banyule Planning Scheme Amendment C93 - Adoption of Amendment
Attachment 1 Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents ..................................................................................... 164
Attachment 2 Planning Scheme Amendment Documents ................................... 186
Attachment 3 Revised Ivanhoe Structure Plan .................................................... 256
4.2 Introducing a new Special Building Overlay schedule into the planning scheme
Attachment 1 SBO Map ....................................................................................... 397
Attachment 2 SBO Development - Technical Report ........................................... 399
Attachment 3 Draft Schedule 2 to the SBO ......................................................... 413
Attachment 4 FAQ's SBO .................................................................................... 414
Attachment 5 SBO information brochure ............................................................. 416
4.4 Ivanhoe Primary School - Parking and Traffic Issues
Attachment 1 Attachment 1 – Issues and Solutions Identified at the Public Meeting ......................................................................................... 418
5.1 Disability and Inclusion Advisory Committee Meeting Membership
Attachment 1 Terms of Reference for Disability and Inclusion Advisory Committee ..................................................................................... 420
5.2 Banyule Youth Summit
Attachment 1 Youth Summit Recommendations ................................................. 424
5.3 Macleod Recreation and Fitness Master Plan
Attachment 1 Draft Macleod Recreation and Fitness Centre Master Plan Executive Summary ....................................................................... 428
Attachment 2 Draft Site Plan ............................................................................... 447
Attachment 3 Draft Concept Plan - Ground Floor ................................................ 448
Attachment 4 Draft Concept Plan - First Floor ..................................................... 449
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.1
Item: 3.1 Attachment 1: The 2013-2014 State of the Environment Report
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 116
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.1
Item: 3.1 Attachment 1: The 2013-2014 State of the Environment Report
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 117
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.1
Item: 3.1 Attachment 1: The 2013-2014 State of the Environment Report
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 118
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.1
Item: 3.1 Attachment 1: The 2013-2014 State of the Environment Report
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 119
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.1
Item: 3.1 Attachment 1: The 2013-2014 State of the Environment Report
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 120
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.1
Item: 3.1 Attachment 1: The 2013-2014 State of the Environment Report
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 121
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.1
Item: 3.1 Attachment 1: The 2013-2014 State of the Environment Report
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 122
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.1
Item: 3.1 Attachment 1: The 2013-2014 State of the Environment Report
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 123
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.1
Item: 3.1 Attachment 1: The 2013-2014 State of the Environment Report
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 124
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.1
Item: 3.1 Attachment 1: The 2013-2014 State of the Environment Report
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 125
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.1
Item: 3.1 Attachment 1: The 2013-2014 State of the Environment Report
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 126
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.1
Item: 3.1 Attachment 1: The 2013-2014 State of the Environment Report
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 127
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 128
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 129
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 130
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 131
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 132
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 133
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 134
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 135
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 136
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 137
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 138
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 139
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 140
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 141
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 142
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 143
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 144
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 145
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 146
Att
ach
me
nt
1
3.2
Item: 3.2 Attachment 1: The Environmental Stewardship Plan 2013 - 2017
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 147
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.3
Item: 3.3 Attachment 1: Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 148
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.3
Item: 3.3 Attachment 1: Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 149
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.3
Item: 3.3 Attachment 1: Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 150
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.3
Item: 3.3 Attachment 1: Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 151
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.3
Item: 3.3 Attachment 1: Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 152
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.3
Item: 3.3 Attachment 1: Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 153
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.3
Item: 3.3 Attachment 1: Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 154
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.3
Item: 3.3 Attachment 1: Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 155
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.3
Item: 3.3 Attachment 1: Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 156
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.3
Item: 3.3 Attachment 1: Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 157
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.3
Item: 3.3 Attachment 1: Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 158
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.3
Item: 3.3 Attachment 1: Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 159
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.3
Item: 3.3 Attachment 1: Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 160
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.3
Item: 3.3 Attachment 1: Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 161
Att
ach
men
t 1
3.3
Item: 3.3 Attachment 1: Biodiversity Plan 2014-17
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 163
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 164
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 165
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 166
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 167
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 168
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 169
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 170
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 171
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 172
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 173
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 174
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 175
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 176
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 177
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 178
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 179
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 180
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 181
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 182
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 183
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 184
Att
ach
men
t 1
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 1: Proposed changes to Structure Plan and Amendment documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 185
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 186
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 187
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 188
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 189
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 190
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 191
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 192
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 193
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 194
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 195
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 196
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 197
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 198
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 199
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 200
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 201
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 202
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 203
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 204
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 205
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 206
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 207
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 208
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 209
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 210
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 211
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 212
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 213
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 214
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 215
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 216
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 217
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 218
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 219
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 220
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 221
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 222
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 223
Att
ach
men
t 2
4.1
Item: 4.1 Attachment 2: Planning Scheme Amendment Documents
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL ON 1 DECEMBER 2014 Page 224