are native english words different from neoclassical ... · neoclassical word formation...

22
Are native English words different from neoclassical English words for German speakers? Benjamin Weiss GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.1/21

Upload: vohuong

Post on 04-Jun-2018

228 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

Are native English words differentfrom neoclassical English words

for German speakers?Benjamin Weiss

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.1/21

Page 2: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

Structure:• Introduction• Neoclassical word formation

• Neoclassical loan-words• Xenophones• An Experiment

• Material• Procedure• Results

• References

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.2/21

Page 3: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

1 Introduction• Language Systems influence each other on

several linguistic levels.• Eg. The use of loan-words and foreign names.• These are often not assimilated, they keep at least

remains of their original language properties.• Foreign words seem to be handled special.• It is claimed that they build up their own

structure(s).

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.3/21

Page 4: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

• But what about neoclassical words?• Are they special?• There is a discussion about these words being

grammatical special.• I will provide an experimental idea to test the

behavior of neoclassical words as borrowings toget further insight into this topic.

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.4/21

Page 5: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

2 Neoclassical word formation• Neoclassical words are derived from Greek or

Latin but built up after the the classic age.• They are used in daily speech and have proven

productive (in German).• However, they differ from native words in several

aspects.• A neoclassical compound may consist of two

bound forms. (hydro, graph)• Affixes can influence stress. (Instru’ment,

instrumen’tal)• There are also special inflexions used with

neoclassicals. (Examen, Examina)

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.5/21

Page 6: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

• There seems to be an agreement of neoclassicalwords being in general different from nativewords.

• The ability to identify neoclassical words isexplained by differences in phonology.

• Etymological knowledge can not account for this.Origin becomes less important than the wordproperties itself.

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.6/21

Page 7: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

• There are different cues that can be used torecognize a word as neoclassical.• Special graphemes (ph, th, rh: Rhetorik)• non-native sounds ([Z], [A]: Garage, Pendant)• phonotactics (ui, ps, [ç]V: Linguist, Psyche,

Chemie)• pluralization patterns

• But even a combination of these features can fail(eg. also arabic words are identified asneoclassical like Alkohol).

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.7/21

Page 8: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

2.1 Neoclassical loan-words• What about neoclassical words borrowed from

foreign languages?• Is the the feature of being neoclassical recognized

by Germans?• This can be tested by their behavior in German:

• What kind of inflexions are used?• How are the words pronounced?• How do they participate in word formation?• Is their phonological structure changed?

Loan-words from English seem to be the obviouschoice as they build up a great number of activeborrowings today (eg. Video vs. Computer).

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.8/21

Page 9: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

3 Xenophones• Eklund & Lindström (2001): Foreign words

produced by Swedish speakers.• Phonetic production of foreign words varies from

’Swedish’ to ’English’ pronunciation due toseveral factors (age & educational level beingmost prominent).

• Eg. about half of the participants produced thename Thatcher with [T].

• This sound is not part of the Swedishphoneme-system

• But it is part of the phone-system of lots ofspeakers –> xenophone.

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.9/21

Page 10: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

• The use of such xenophones depends on:• the foreign language competence of the

speaker• the speaker’s expectation of the foreign

language competence of the listener• the relative status of the speaker and listener• the social situation of the talk• how well-known the word is, when it first

occurred• the relative distance of the two languages in

socio-cultural and linguistic terms

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.10/21

Page 11: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

Experiment:19 sounds that are not included in the Swedishphoneme-system and quite different fromcorresponding Swedish sounds were used in foreignwords/names to build 12 Swedish sentences.

(1) Många har Roger Moore som favorit i rollensom James Bond.A lot of people prefer Roger Moore’sinterpretation of James Bond.

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.11/21

Page 12: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

• These sentences were read out aloud andrecorded.

• The possible pronunciations of the two namesrange in a continuum from total Swedish to bestEnglish possible to the speaker.

(2) Roger: target: [ô] (0 %), [r] (96.1 %, [ü] (1.5 %),Roger: target: [ô], Ø (0 %), [r] (96.8 %, [ü](1.1 %),Roger: target: [dZ] (32.5 %), [g] (67.3 %)

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.12/21

Page 13: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

• Only some speakers used no xenophones at all.• Most used non-native sounds as an

approximation to the target sounds mostlywithout reaching it (/tC/ instead of /Ù/).

• The degree of approximation depends on thetarget sound.

• however, the participants were very muchinconsistent, as the use of xenophones also variedwith the word (/dZ/: [ro:g@r] vs. [dZeI

<ms]).

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.13/21

Page 14: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

The realizations were devided into three groups(example: james /dZeI

<ms/):

1. /dZej<

ms/

maximal approximation with the use ofnon-native sounds

2. /dZEms/realization of foreigness with the use of properSwedish sounds (with can lead to non-nativephonotactics)

3. /dZams/read out aloud as a Swedish word

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.14/21

Page 15: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

• So foreign words are mostly marked withdifferent degrees of approaching target sounds.

• Results depend on• Age: Older and younger participants used

significantly more a Swedish pronunciation,while the group of 26–35-year-old speakerused these less often.

• Gender is unimportant.• Regional differences are not easy to explain.• Educational level is significant, as the speaker

with higher educational level reached a closerapproximation to the targets.

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.15/21

Page 16: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

4 Experiment• Corresponding results are expected for German.• If German speakers try to mark an English word

with non-native pronunciation, will they makeexceptions with neoclassicals?

• Now I will present an experimental idea to testthis possible differences in the pronunciation ofnative and neoclassical English words byGermans.

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.16/21

Page 17: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

4.1 Material• One abstract from a scientific journal (High

Energy Physics – Theory)• Title: Penrose Limits of RG Fixed Points and

PP-Waves with Background Fluxes

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.17/21

Page 18: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

We consider a family of pp-wave solutions ofIIB supergravity. This family has anon-trivial, constant 5-form flux, andnon-trivial, (light-cone) time-dependent RRand NS-NS 3-form fluxes. The solutions haveeither 16 or 20 supersymmetries dependingupon the time dependence. One member ofthis family of solutions is the Penrose limitof the solution obtained by Pilch and Warneras the dual of a Leigh-Strassler fixed point.The family of solutions also provides indirectevidence in support of a recent conjectureconcerning a large N duality group that actson RG flows of N=2 supersymmetric, quivergauge theories.

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.18/21

Page 19: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

4.2 Procedure• Participants were instructed to read the abstract

(5 min. time) and summarize it in German.• The short speech samples were recorded with a

SHURE 565SD microphone directly on PC viaESS ES1938S Solo-1 soundsystem.

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.19/21

Page 20: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

4.3 Results• All three speakers (2 f, 1 m) pronounced many

words with xenophones or translated them(pp-waves, fluxes, Penrose limit, Pilch andWarner)

• However, some words were spoken in a ’German’way (dual, trivial, konstant, Symmetrien)

• One notable exception: supersymmetric (1participant)

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.20/21

Page 21: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

ReferencesEisenberg, P. (1998): Grundriß der deutschenGrammatik. Band 1: Das Wort. Metzler, Stuttgart.Eklund, R. & Lindström, A. (2001): Xenophones:An investigation of phone set expansion in Swedishand implications for speech recognition an speechsynthesis. Speech Communication 35, 81–102.Jessen, M. (1999): German. In: H. van der Hulst(ed.), Word Prosodic Systems in the Languages ofEurope, de Gryter, New York, 515–545.Lüdeling, A. & Schmid, T. & Kiokpasoglou S.(2002): Neoclassical Word formation in German. In:G. Booij & J. van Marle (ed.), Yearbook ofMorphology 2001, Kluwer, 254–283.

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.21/21

Page 22: Are native English words different from neoclassical ... · Neoclassical word formation Neoclassical loan-words ... they differ from native words in several ... What about neoclassical

Munske, H. (1988): Ist das Deutsche eine Misch-sprache? Zur Stellung der Fremdwörter im deutschenSprachsystem. In: H. Munske, P. von Polenz, O. Reich-mann & R. Hildebrandt (ed.), Deutscher Wortschatz.Lexikologische Studien. Ludwig Erich Schmitt zum80. Geburtstag von seinen Marburger Schülern, Berlin,de Gryter, 46–74.

GK: Morphologie Anke Lüdeling & Penka Stateva 07.02.03 – p.22/21