arab spring, spanish revolution, and occupy movement: mainstream media vs social media coverage

50
Pablo Rey Mazón Visiting Scientist, Center for Civic Media. MIT Medialab Contact: [email protected] | numeroteca.org Twitter: @numeroteca More info and all the images at: Analyzing newspapers' front pages vs Twitter http://PageOneX.com Arab Spring, Spanish Recolution, and Occupy Movement: Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage Internacional Communication Association Phoenix, AZ. May 25th 2012

Upload: numeroteca

Post on 29-Nov-2014

3.636 views

Category:

News & Politics


2 download

DESCRIPTION

Analyzing newspapers' front pages vs Twitter. Panel at #ICA12.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Pablo Rey MazónVisiting Scientist, Center for Civic Media. MIT Medialab

Contact: [email protected] | numeroteca.org Twitter: @numeroteca

More info and all the images at:

Analyzing newspapers' front pages vs Twitter

http://PageOneX.com

Arab Spring, Spanish Recolution, and Occupy Movement: Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Internacional Communication Association Phoenix, AZ. May 25th 2012

Page 2: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

May 15th, 2011May 15th, 2011 MadridMadrid

Page 3: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

May 16th, 2011

Page 4: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

May 16th, 2011

Page 5: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

May 17th, 2011

Page 6: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

May 17th, 2011May 17th, 2011

Page 7: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

May 18th, 2011

Page 8: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

May 18th, 2011May 18th, 2011

Page 9: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

May 19th, 2011

Page 10: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

May 19th, 2011

Page 11: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

May 21th, 2011

Page 12: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

15M- Indignados May 15th – June 19th, 2011

Page 13: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 14: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 15: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 16: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Twitter and Newspaper Front PagesOccupy September 17th – December 15th, 2011

http://numeroteca.org/?p=1356

Page 17: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Occupy September 17th – December 15th, 2011http://numeroteca.org/?p=1356

Page 18: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Analyzing front pages: Shortcut

Page 19: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Show me the data!

001010100101010010000101010101001000110100010010000100101010100010101000100100110100010010001100101010101010101010101001101100110010010010001001000100010001000001010010100010001001

Page 20: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

News evolution in time

Haiti earthquake. January, 2010

Page 21: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Japanese Tsunami. January, 2010

News evolution in time

Page 22: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Using percentage to compare data

%125cm²

Page 23: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Number of articles in the front page of main Spanish and US newspapers

SpainEl País 7.5El Mundo 7.5ABC 4.5La Vanguardia 5.1La Razón 4.9Público 4.6Average 5.7

USAWSJ 34.8 (28.0 short-small headlines)The Washington post 13.1The New York times 15.5The Boston Globe 17.7 (9.2 short-small headlines)USA Today 13.0Los Ángeles Times 9.7Average 17.3 (11.1 )

Page 24: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Spanish – US Newspapers & Japanese Tsunami

Two countriesCoverage comparison

Page 25: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Spanish newspapers. Spanish newspapers January, 2010

Japanese Tsunami – Arab Spring

Page 26: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Spanish newspapers. Spanish newspapers January, 2010

Japanese Tsunami – Arab Spring

NATO & War in Lybia

Page 27: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

One at a time

11

Page 28: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Compare simultaneous news evolution in time

Arab Spring: Egipt, Lybia, Syria. January, 2011

Page 29: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 30: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

15M Movement– DSK arrest. Spanish newspapers May, 2011

Page 31: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Compare asynchronous news evolution in time

Haiti Earthquake – Japanese Tsunami.

Page 32: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Next steps

-Tool for crowdsourced analysis: PageOneX.com

-Scraping from newspaper web sites (now front pages are From kiosko.net)

-Interactive design

-Use more variables: position, number of words, image, headline size, frame of the news, content, by line.

-Integration with other news streams and analytic tools: TV broadcast, Media Meter, Twitter

Page 33: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

PageOneX.com

Open source projectSummer 2012

Page 34: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 35: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 36: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 37: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 38: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 39: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 40: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 41: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 42: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 43: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 44: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 45: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Compare with other media

-TV Broadcast transcripts-Radio transcripts-Web front pages-Social Networking Sites: Twitter

Page 46: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

http://bit.ly/analyzemediatools

Page 47: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Mixed data analysis: Trayvon MartinComparison: Twitter / Front pages / Signatures

Page 48: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

Twitter data Gathering, comparative methodshttp://www.numeroteca.org/12m15m

Page 49: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage
Page 50: Arab Spring, Spanish Revolution, and Occupy Movement:  Mainstream Media vs Social Media coverage

PageOneX.com

@numeroteca