application of sugar foam to red soils in a semiarid mediterranean environment

Upload: 1ab4c

Post on 04-Jun-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/14/2019 Application of Sugar Foam to Red Soils in a Semiarid Mediterranean Environment

    1/9

    O R I G I N A L A R T I C L E

    Application of sugar foam to red soils in a semiaridMediterranean environment

    F. J. Garca Navarro J. A. Amoros Ortiz-VillajosC. J. Sanchez Jimenez S. Bravo Martn-ConsuegraE. Marquez Cubero Raimundo Jimenez Ballesta

    Received: 15 June 2008 / Accepted: 8 January 2009/ Published online: 10 February 2009

    Springer-Verlag 2009

    Abstract The study described here involved evaluating

    the effects that the application of one by-product (sugarfoam waste) has upon red soils in the region of La Mancha

    (Central Spain). In view of the fact that this is a location

    where this type of soil abounds, this technique has been a

    common practice for many years. The principal goal was to

    investigate the impact of this approach on some of the soil

    properties and, secondly, on its level of fertility. As a

    result, this represents an investigation into the effects that

    this type of waste has on some soil quality parameters. The

    results showed that, after the addition of by-products over

    25 years, sugar foam waste is of agricultural interest

    mainly due to the increase in organic matter concentration

    (about 2%) and, to a lesser extent, by increases in calcium

    carbonate (more than 30%) and P (four times more). The

    soil pH was also found to increase slightly (1.4), while the

    electrical conductivity almost did not change. The prop-

    erties associated with these pedological qualities therefore

    had a positive effect by improving nutrient availability. As

    a result, foams arising from sugar industries have a positive

    effect on soil quality and the application of such foams to

    soils is beneficial since the need to dispose this residue is

    also removed.

    Keywords Sugar foam waste Red soils Semiarid

    Mediterranean environment La Mancha Spain

    Introduction

    The combination of agricultural and industrial activity

    generates residues that must be disposed of owing their

    negative effects on the environment and to maintain the

    natural ecological equilibrium (Ros2000). The generation

    of agro-industrialist residues has grown quickly in recent

    decades, with soils being one of the main destinations for

    this material. The addition of wastes, such as sugar foam,

    compost and wine vinasse wastes, to agricultural soils is a

    common cultural practice, especially in the last 23 dec-

    ades, due to the improvements observed in some soil

    properties (Sikora and Azad1993), and the increase in crop

    yield and quality (Tejada and Gonzalez2003, etc.).

    Amongst the better known residues used in La Mancha

    (agricultural semiarid Mediterranean region situated in

    central Spain), wine vinasse, beet vinasse and sugar foam

    waste are worth mentioning. This product (sugar foam

    waste) is known as foam is not fit for consumption; is

    often applied to red soils that, apart from having an

    appreciable agronomic value, have a paleoclimatological

    and paleopedological significance and are therefore of

    environmental interest.

    The potential impact of the materials accumulated in the

    so-called sugar foam wastes in soils used for dry-farmed

    crops is undoubtedly of interest, especially given that

    such waste has been applied to red soils with a great

    paleoclimatological, paleodophological, and in general

    F. J. Garca Navarro J. A. Amoros Ortiz-Villajos

    S. Bravo Martn-Consuegra E. Marquez Cubero

    Esc. Univ. Ing. Tecn. Agrcola, UCLM,Ronda de Calatrava, 7, 13071 Ciudad Real, Spain

    e-mail: [email protected]

    F. J. Garca Navarro C. J. Sanchez Jimenez

    Unidad de Suelos, Instituto Tecn. Qumica y Medioambiental

    (ITQUIMA-UCLM), 13071 Ciudad Real, Spain

    R. Jimenez Ballesta (&)

    Departamento de Geologa y Geoqumica,

    Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad Autonoma de Madrid,

    Campus Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain

    e-mail: [email protected]

    1 3

    Environ Earth Sci (2009) 59:603611

    DOI 10.1007/s12665-009-0058-9

  • 8/14/2019 Application of Sugar Foam to Red Soils in a Semiarid Mediterranean Environment

    2/9

    environmental significance (Gonzalez Martn et al. 2007).

    This material may also cause a modification in agronomic

    soil quality.

    The concept of soil quality appears to be relatively new

    but, at the same time, this topic is widely debated. Agricul-

    tural productivity has usually been put on the same level as

    the sustainability, the fertility of the soil and its usefulness. In

    any case, it is necessaryto define the functions of the soil and,

    in this respect, the most recent definitions of the soils quality

    are based on its multifunctionality rather than on a single

    specific use, bearing in mind that the concept is continually

    evolving (Singer and Ewing2000). Thus, the inappropriateuse of the soil might lead to a disruption in its chemical,

    physical and biochemical properties, such as a decrease in

    the cationic exchange capacity, pH, permeability, etc. Such

    changes could even affect the nutrients available for the

    microorganisms and plants (Clark et al.1998).

    The extraction of sugar from sugarcane is a very old

    process. More than 50% of the sugar consumed worldwide is

    obtained from sugar cane, which grows in tropical and

    subtropical climates. The rest of the sugar comes from sugar

    beet, which is planted in temperate countries like Spain. The

    roots are cut into strands in order to extract the juice. During

    the extraction process for sugar from sugar beet it is neces-

    sary to separate the non-sweet substances from the beetroot

    juice in a refining process that consists of two steps. The

    colloidal substances must first be flocculated by white-

    washing with lime. The flocculated substances are called

    foams and these, in the traditional manufacture process

    considered here, are swept away by water to large pools for a

    natural drainage (Espejo2001). After the extraction, lime is

    usually added to the juice and the rest of the process con-

    tinues. The sugar foam waste is therefore a relatively new

    and unknown organic residue that has emerged from the

    significant growth in the sugar beet industry. Another char-

    acteristic of these residues is that they are difficult to deposit

    although they can provide certain nutrients to the soils.

    The addition of amendments is currently being consid-

    ered as an effective technique to improve soils quality, e.g.

    for the remediation of contaminated soils. For this reason,

    in this study we deal with the impact that the different

    superficial disposal of these by-product over the last

    25 years has had on soil quality. The treatment has been

    carried out on red soils that are mainly used for dry farming

    and are occasionally left fallow.

    Materials and methods

    Study area and sampling procedure

    The work was carried out upon typical red soils used for

    dry farming in the semiarid Mediterranean region (La

    Mancha). The foams were obtained from the Azucarera de

    Ciudad Real S.A. industry and they were deposited at

    different levels over a time that spanned more than

    25 years. The amounts involved can be estimated as

    between 20 and 40 tons/ha per year.

    The area of La Mancha spreads over the central Iberian

    Peninsula (Fig.1) and is characterised by great geodiver-

    sity. This region is dominated by Rhodoxerafs together

    with Xerochrepts, (Soil Survey Staff 2006) with some

    calcium carbonate accumulation. According to FAO ISRIC

    ISSS (2006) the soils are Luvisols and Cambisols.

    In this study, two soil profiles, one disturbed and the

    other one undisturbed (treated with sugar foam and

    Fig. 1 Location map of studied

    area

    604 Environ Earth Sci (2009) 59:603611

    1 3

  • 8/14/2019 Application of Sugar Foam to Red Soils in a Semiarid Mediterranean Environment

    3/9

    untreated) were described and sampled from widely dis-

    tributed soils series in La Mancha. The soil moisture

    regime for the area is Xeric and the temperature regime is

    Mesic (Soil Survey Staff 2006). Soil samples were col-

    lected from two geo-referenced locations throughout La

    Mancha (Central Spain). In each location a typical red soil

    was described according to FAO (2006) criteria (Table1).

    Samples collected from both soils were air dried at roomtemperature and carefully sieved through a 2-mm mesh; the

    coarser material was discarded and the remaining fine-earth

    fraction was gently mixed until it appeared to be homo-

    geneous. The dried samples were used for subsequent

    analysis. Aliquots of this fraction were taken randomly for

    chemical and physico-chemical analysis.

    Analytical methods

    The analytical determinations were carried out according to

    SCS-USDA (1972). In particular, soil texture was deter-

    mined using the hydrometer method (Gee et al. 1986) withthree replicates. Soil pH was measured in H2O and in

    0.1 M KCl using a 1:2.5 soil/solution ratio. Electrical

    conductivity was measured in a 1:5 soil:water extract. For

    calcium carbonate determination CO2 was measured in

    a calcimeter. The active calcium carbonate equivalent

    (ACCE) or active lime was determined with NH4-oxa-

    late as described by Drouineau (1942). The method of

    Olsen et al. (1954), which is based on extraction with

    0.5 M NaHCO3, was used to estimate available P. Soil

    organic matter was determined by potassium dichromate

    oxidation and titration of dichromate remaining with

    ammonium ferrous (II) sulphate (Anne 1945). Exchange-

    able cations were determined using an ammonium acetate

    extraction method (Thomas 1982). Exchangeable Na, K,

    Ca and Mg were determined by atomic absorption spec-

    trometry. Total nitrogen content was determined by the

    Kjeldahl method (Bremner and Mulvaney 1982). All

    samples were extracted and analysed in duplicate.

    The semi-quantitative mineralogical analyses were car-

    ried out by X-ray diffraction (XRD) techniques; about 2 g of

    sample was hand-milled to below 53 lm in an agate mortar

    and used for the determination of the bulk mineralogy

    (random powder method). For the detailed study of phyllo-

    silicates, 100 g of sample was treated to remove components

    that prevent complete dispersion (e.g. carbonates, sulphates,

    organic matter, etc.). The\2 lm (clay fraction) particles

    were extracted by sedimentation techniques and analysed on

    thick glass slides by XRD according to Moore and Rey-

    nolds (1989); samples were chemically treated [(a) ethylene

    glycol, to detect expandable minerals; and (b) dimethyl

    sulphoxide, to differentiate chlorite and kaolinite] and ther-

    mally treated (550C for 2 h, to study the behaviour of

    phyllosilicates). The samples were analysed using a CuKa

    radiation source (Philips-Panalytical X-PERT diffractome-

    ter) with a graphite monochromator, 40 kV and 40 mA, and

    sensitivity of 2103 cps. The ranges measured were 275 or

    250 2h, goniometer speed of 0.04 or 0.05 and time constant

    of 0.4 or 1 s for random powder or glass slides, respectively.

    The chemical compositions of whole samples were deter-

    mined using an X-ray fluorescence spectrometer (PHILIPS

    PW 2404) in solid mode.

    Results and discussion

    A 25-year study was conducted with a view to assessing

    the effect of sugar foam waste on moderately basic red

    soils. Representative profiles of degraded and undegraded

    morphological red soils of La Mancha were examined

    for morphological physico-chemical and mineralogical

    properties.

    The impact of sugar foam addition is manifested by the

    changes in the soil morphology as a new and quite differentnew Ap horizon appear (a change is observed in structure,

    colour, porosity, etc.). The addition of sugar foam also

    causes noticeable effects on certain soil properties. An

    increase in the pH, (Fig. 2a), is observed due to the pres-

    ence of by-products with basic pH values. Nevertheless, it

    was observed that in the upper horizon, Ap1, the increase is

    less marked, probably due to the washing. The electrical

    conductivity barely changes, (Fig.2d).

    Carbonate and the active lime are common compo-

    nents in a large number of soils in the surrounding areas,

    but not in the samples used in this study as we employed

    a moderately acidic soil, developed on a lithological

    substrate without carbonates (quartzite and slate). How-

    ever, this component increased clearly (more than 30%)

    as can seen in Fig.2a and b, after the application of

    sugar foam, similar to obtained by Lopez et al. (2001).

    Moreover, the soil contained traces of calcium oxide and

    was rich in organic matter and some nutrients such as

    Mg, P, Zn, and Cu. It is not unexpected that having

    applied the sugar foam, a considerable rise in P (four

    times more) and organic matter (Fig.2a, b) took place.

    The behaviour of N mirrors that shown by the organic

    matter. The organic matter content grows and this must

    help to increase the stability of the aggregates, followed

    by the number and the size of the macropores, which will

    in turn enhance the structure and quality of the soil.

    (Chaney and Swift 1984). The normal levels of organic

    matter in soil in the area studied do not exceed 2%.

    Therefore, despite the high content of organic matter

    caused by the addition of the molasses under investiga-

    tion, the increase in organic matter (2%) is important in

    comparison to the level in the initial soil (Fig.2). This

    finding is attributed to the rapid mineralization of organic

    Environ Earth Sci (2009) 59:603611 605

    1 3

  • 8/14/2019 Application of Sugar Foam to Red Soils in a Semiarid Mediterranean Environment

    4/9

    Table1

    Generaldescriptionandm

    acromorphologicalcharacteristicsoftwosoilsinvestigated

    SoiltypeFAO/soiltaxonomy

    Location/coordinates

    Parentmaterial

    Vegetation/use

    Topography

    Slope

    Drainage

    Stoniness

    TerricAnthrosol(eutric

    ,

    clayic)/typicRhodoxeralf

    LA

    SCASAS39010

    2100

    N

    0

    3560

    3200

    W,

    0

    418432

    .73(X),-

    4

    319768

    .58(Y)

    Slatesand

    quartzites

    Dryfarming

    Undulating

    C-2

    Gently

    sloping

    C-3

    Mode

    rately

    welldrained

    C-1

    Few

    stoniness

    Horizonsdepth(cm)

    Colour(dry)

    Structure

    Consistence

    Roots

    Pores

    Limit

    Stoniness

    (%)

    Ap1

    (0

    12)

    10

    YR7/3

    Moderate,

    subangular

    blocky,co

    arse

    Slightlysticky,

    nonplastic

    ,

    friable

    ,slightlyhard

    Commonfineand

    v

    eryfine

    Fewfineand

    veryfine

    Gradualandwavy

    5

    Ap2

    (12

    20)

    10

    Y7/2

    Moderate,

    subangular

    blocky,co

    arse

    Slightlysticky,

    slightly

    plastic

    ,

    friable

    ,slightlyhard

    Commonvery

    fi

    ne

    Fewfine

    Abruptandsmooth

    2

    Ap3

    (20

    32)

    10

    Y7/2

    Moderate,

    subangular

    blocky,co

    arse

    Slightlysticky,

    slightly

    plastic

    ,

    friable

    ,slightlyhard

    Commonvery

    fi

    ne

    Fewfine

    Abruptandsmooth

    2

    2Bw

    (32

    60)

    7.5

    YR8/3

    Strong,

    prism

    atic

    ,

    coarse

    Stickily,

    plastic

    ,firm,

    hard

    Few

    fine

    Commonfine

    Gradualand

    irregular

    2

    2Bt(

    60

    110)

    10

    R4/6

    Strong,

    prism

    atic

    ,

    coarse

    Verystickily,

    veryplastic

    ,

    firm,

    hard

    Veryfewfine

    Commonfine

    andveryfine

    10

    SoiltypeFAO/soil

    taxonomy

    Location/

    coo

    rdinates

    Parentmaterial

    Vegetation/use

    Topography

    Slope

    Drainage

    Stoniness

    LepticLuvisol(skeletic

    ,

    chromic)/typic

    Haploxeralf.

    Fuente

    E

    lFresno

    Slatesand

    quartzites

    Pastureanddry

    farming

    Hillside

    C-4 M

    oderately

    steep

    C-5

    Somewhat

    excessively

    drained

    C-2 C

    ommon

    stoniness

    Horizonsdepth(cm)

    Colour(dry)

    Structure

    Consistence

    Roots

    Pores

    Limit

    Stoniness

    (%)

    Ap

    (0

    25)

    7.5

    YR6/4

    Moderate,

    subangular

    blocky,m

    edium

    Sticky,

    plastic

    ,friable

    ,

    slightlyhard

    Abundantfine

    Common

    coarse

    Gradualand

    irregular

    20

    Bt1

    (25

    65)

    7.5

    YR5/8

    Moderate,

    subangular

    blocky,m

    edium

    Sticky,

    plastic

    ,friable

    ,

    slightlyhard

    Abundantfine

    Common

    coarse

    Diffusean

    dwavy

    20

    Bt2

    (65

    96)

    5Y

    R5/8

    Moderate,

    subangular

    blocky,m

    edium

    Sticky,

    plastic

    ,friable

    ,

    slightlyhard

    None

    Common

    coarse

    Gradualand

    irregular

    25

    C([96)

    606 Environ Earth Sci (2009) 59:603611

    1 3

  • 8/14/2019 Application of Sugar Foam to Red Soils in a Semiarid Mediterranean Environment

    5/9

    matter that occurs in well-aerated soil (Levi-Minzi et al.

    1985) and at high temperature.The percentages of sand, lime and clay from the hori-

    zons and according to the texture classes diagram (Soil

    Survey Staff 2006), are shown in Table2. These are

    classified as loam-clay. A substantial contrast can be seen

    in the clay content between the argilic (Bt) and the Ap

    horizons.

    The mineralogy corresponding to degradation profile is

    shown in Fig. 3ac and these are qualitatively and quan-

    titatively similar to those in profile 2 (undegraded profile)

    (Table1). The diffractograms for the bulk mineralogy of

    the seven analysed samples are shown and it can be seenthat the major component is calcite in the first three sam-

    ples (Ap1Ap3) (6585%). Quartz is found in all of the

    samples. On the other hand, in samples Ap1Ap3 it is

    evident that there is a very low level (\5%) of alkaline

    feldspar, while in the Bw and Btsamples this feldspar is of

    the plagioclase type.

    The latter samples, were analysed in a separated form

    (\2 lm), with the existence of Illite and Kaolinite at low

    levels in both samples. This fraction was solvated with

    pH

    5 5,8 6,6 7,4

    pH H2O

    pH KCl

    E.C.

    0,2 0,25 0,3 0,35

    % O.M.

    0 1 2 3 4

    % N

    0 0,1 0,2

    P (mg/Km)

    0 1 2

    Ap

    B t1

    B t2

    Ap

    B t1

    B t2

    Ap

    B t1

    B t2

    Ap

    B t1

    B t2

    Ap

    B t1

    B t2

    E.C. Electrical Conductivity O.M. Organic Matter

    pH

    7,2 7,8 8,4 9

    pH H2O

    pH KCl

    Ap1

    A p3

    Ap2

    2Bw

    2B t

    E.C. (dS/m)

    0,2 0,3 0,4

    Ap1

    Ap3

    Ap2

    2Bw

    2Bt

    % Ca carbonate

    0 10 2030 40 50

    Ap1

    Ap3

    Ap2

    2Bw

    2Bt

    % A. Limestone

    0 4 8 121620

    A p1

    A p3

    A p2

    2Bw

    2B t

    P (mg/Kg)

    0 2 4 6 8 1012

    Ap1

    Ap2

    Ap3

    2Bw

    2B t

    % N

    0,05 0,15 0,25

    Ap1

    Ap2

    Ap3

    2Bw

    2Bt

    % O.M.

    0 1 2 3 4 5

    A p1

    A p2

    A p3

    2B w

    2B t

    E.C.: Electrical conductivity Ca carbonate: calic carbonate

    A. Limestone: Active Limestone O.M.: Organic matter

    a

    b

    0

    Fig. 2 a, b Some pedological properties of selected the two soils

    Environ Earth Sci (2009) 59:603611 607

    1 3

  • 8/14/2019 Application of Sugar Foam to Red Soils in a Semiarid Mediterranean Environment

    6/9

    ethylene glycol in order to detect the presence of Smectite-

    type minerals and was heated at 550C in order to confirm

    the presence of Kaolinite. However, only the presence ofKaolinite (1530%) and Illite (5065%) was detected and

    Smectite was absent. Therefore, from the study of dif-

    fractograms, it can be deduced that the samples Ap1, Ap2

    and Ap3 belongs together with the horizons described as

    anthropogenic, where the addition of the foams has led to

    high contents in calcite, as well as their possible concen-

    tration in lower horizons (Ap3 mainly). The result obtained

    is consistent with the composition of the foam, which

    contains calcium carbonate and traces of calcium oxide. It

    was observed that the level of exchangeable K? remained

    unaltered although there was an increase in exchangeable

    Ca2? in the surface horizons.

    The retention in situ of toxic elements by the application

    of amendments is a remediation technology for contami-

    nated soils (Vangronsveld and Cunningham1998) as it aids

    the mechanism for the retention of these materials in the

    soil (Karaka 2004). As a result, we analysed a series of

    chemical elements. The interest in the chosen elements is

    based on their presence in different contamination pro-

    cesses, on their varied mobility and their different ionic

    forms and different geochemical performance (McBride

    1994). The contents in silica, aluminium and iron show an

    imbalance in favour of the soil and to the detriment of the

    added materials, which are lost in large amounts due to

    calcination (Table3). Mg and Ca are two of the chemical

    elements that are added in large amounts to the soil after

    the application of sugar foam. Mn, Na, K, Ti and Ba also

    increase in 2Bt or in the horizon 2Bw.

    Different effects of sugar foam waste on the morpho-

    logical, chemical and mineral composition of red soils have

    been investigated. Hence, it can be assumed that although

    we could have expected a much more marked impact [as

    pointed out by (Clark et al. 1998) because of handling

    effects], this does not seem to show a clear trend. Thus

    after at least 25 years of treatment the only major changes

    observed concern the carbonate, organic matter, phospho-

    rus and nitrogen. Consequently, the properties related with

    these edaphic qualities have been affected positively.

    Furthermore, although the pH and the electrical conduc-

    tivity do not change significantly, we can conclude that

    these foams have a positive final effect on the quality of thesoil and can therefore recommend the application of this

    material (under the same conditions) to this kind or any

    other kind of soil. In fact, the observed increase in pH will

    enhance the availability of the elements and nutrients for

    plants and microorganisms; therefore, improving the eda-

    phical conditions of the environment. Based on the increase

    in the organic matter in the soil, as well as on the small or

    insignificant effects on soil mineralogy, these agro-indus-

    trial products can be considered as effective alternatives for

    organic matter accumulation and for the improvement of

    soil quality in agriculture. The results obtained are con-

    sistent with those reported by various authors (Madejonet al. 1996, 2001; Diaz et al. 1996; Lopez et al. 2001;

    Garrido et al. 2003; Vidal et al. 2004; Alonso et al. 2006;

    Vidal et al. 2006).

    The disposal of sugar foam is one the main environ-

    mental problems related to sugar industries. Since

    numerous studies have shown a positive correlation

    between soil organic matter and microbial biomass con-

    centration (Bending et al. 2000; Tejada and Gonzalez

    2003), we expected that the supply of sugar foam waste

    would enhance soil microbial biomass. Many authors,

    including Cegarra et al. (1996), Tomati et al. (1995),

    advocate the use of certain agricultural products and waste

    in some industries as an alternative, simple and yet cost-

    effective way to reuse and dispose of such waste. An

    increase in the amount of Na was not observed in the work

    described here, but futures studies should focus on this

    aspect. The control of salinity is essential when dealing

    with an area of low rainfall, as there is a risk of reaching

    high saline values, with the consequent impact this has on

    the availability of water for the crops.

    These by-products can contain heavy metals, either

    added from the original matter or from industrial origin,

    and as such they can be a source of soil pollution (Fauziah

    et al.1996). However, one of the remediation technologies

    used today on soils contaminated with heavy metals is the

    application of amendments for the retention of these metals

    (Vangronsveld and Cunningham 1998). Therefore, the

    addition of the foams will minimize the possibility of these

    metals reaching phreatic levels. Carbonell et al. (1999)

    have used phosphogypsum with at least 60% of the sul-

    phates. Materials rich in calcium carbonate, such as the

    sugar foam from the sugar refinery, have been used for the

    recovery of the soils in the Aznalcollar mines (Spain). It

    Table 2 Particle size distribution and textural class

    % Gravels

    ([2 mm)

    % Sand % Silt % Clay Textural

    classification

    Profile 1

    Ap1 5.2 Silta

    Ap2 6.2 34.6 41.8 23.6 Silt

    Ap3 0.2 Silta

    2Bw 12.2 65.8 11.8 22.9 Loam-clay-sand

    2Bt 15.5 23.9 16.2 59.9 Clay

    Profile 2

    Ap 33.8 35.8 49.0 15.2 Loam

    Bt1 45.9 26.6 29.3 44.1 Clay

    Bt2 49.7 28.6 28.0 43,4 Clay

    a Texture resolute by touch

    608 Environ Earth Sci (2009) 59:603611

    1 3

  • 8/14/2019 Application of Sugar Foam to Red Soils in a Semiarid Mediterranean Environment

    7/9

    Fig. 3 X-ray diffractograms of samples

    Environ Earth Sci (2009) 59:603611 609

    1 3

  • 8/14/2019 Application of Sugar Foam to Red Soils in a Semiarid Mediterranean Environment

    8/9

    was also mentioned that such treatments contribute to the

    vegetable growth and the microbial activity (Mennch et al.

    2000). The present project reveals the necessity to inves-

    tigate the beneficial effect of the latter possibility.

    Given the fact that most of these industrial by-products do

    not have a suitable site for disposal, it is clear that the pos-

    sibility of using them to improve soil quality opens a whole

    new prospect for their reuse. Moreover, we believe that theaddition of sugar foam could prove more useful than treat-

    ment with lime, as has traditionally been carried out (Ahmad

    andTan 1986; Mennch et al. 2000;Gunnetal. 2001), bearing

    in mind that the effectiveness of the application of this by-

    product can lead to the reduction of mobility of some toxic

    elements as it increases the capacity for their retention. Our

    future research will be concentrated in this area.

    Conclusions

    The continuous application over 25 years of sugar foam

    waste to a red soil produces a positive impact on the soils

    characteristics. Such treatment improves the mineral fer-

    tilization satisfactorily, opening a new and interesting

    alternative from an environmental point of view. Treatment

    with sugar foam leads to an increase in pH, but not the

    electrical conductivity. Such treatment also leads to

    increase in the contents of N, P and Ca, as well as in the

    organic matter. Due to the contents of phosphorus and

    nitrogen, such foam can be used as a fertilizer and as an

    alterative to lime for soil amendment. Therefore, sugar

    foam waste has appropriate characteristics to improve soil

    quality. As a key conclusion, we can state that the use of

    molasses to replace traditional fertilization has three

    effects: the economic cost is lower, it produces a similar

    effect to fertilizer and solves the problem of finding loca-

    tions to dispose of such waste. However, in the future it

    will be necessary to investigate whether this treatment

    causes stimulation of the microbiological activity and

    therefore alters the biological and biochemical properties.

    References

    Ahmad F, Tan KL (1986) Effect of lime and organic matter on

    Soybean seeding grown in Aluminium-oxic soil. Soil Sci Soc

    Am J 50:656661

    Alonso FP, Arias JS, Fernandez RO, Fernandez PG, Serrano RE

    (2006) Agronomic implications of the supply of lime and

    gypsum by-products to palexerults from western Spain. Soil Sci

    171(1):6581

    Anne A (1945) Sur le dosage rapid du carbone organique de sols. Ann

    Agro 2:161172

    Bending GD, Putland C, Rayns F (2000) Changes in microbial

    community metabolism and labile organic matter fractions asTable3

    Chemicalcompositionof

    soilsamplesandsugarfoam

    PPC

    Si2

    (g/kg)

    Al2O3

    (g/kg)

    Fe2O3

    (g/kg)

    MnO

    (g/kg)

    MgO

    (g/kg)

    C

    aO

    (g/kg)

    Na2O

    (g/kg)

    K2

    O(g/kg)

    TiO2

    (g/kg)

    P2O5

    (g/kg

    )

    SO3

    (g/kg)

    SrO

    (g/kg)

    BaO

    (mg/kg)

    ZrO2

    (mg/kg)

    NiO

    (mg/kg)

    Cr2O3

    (mg/kg)

    Profile1

    Ap1

    48

    .00

    21

    .85

    4.0

    1

    1.1

    3

    0.0

    2

    1.5

    4

    21

    .51

    0.0

    8

    0.8

    3

    0.2

    1

    0.36

    0.3

    6

    0.0

    5

    0.0

    2

    0.0

    2

    Ap2

    32

    .17

    21

    .39

    3.8

    3

    1.5

    1

    0.0

    4

    1.6

    4

    36

    .92

    0.1

    0

    0.8

    7

    0.2

    6

    0.55

    0.5

    9

    0.0

    6

    0.0

    3

    0.0

    2

    Ap3

    57

    .76

    3.4

    5

    0.7

    8

    0.2

    7

    1.0

    6

    35

    .34

    0.0

    4

    0.1

    6

    0.0

    4

    0.53

    0.5

    3

    0.0

    3

    2Bw

    5.5

    2

    73

    .42

    12

    .05

    4.0

    6

    0.0

    6

    0.8

    6

    0.9

    3

    0.1

    4

    1.7

    7

    0.7

    8

    0.19

    0.1

    1

    a

    0.0

    4

    0.0

    4

    a

    0.0

    2

    2Bt

    14

    .33

    47

    .05

    23

    .17

    9.1

    6

    0.0

    3

    1.1

    2

    1.5

    5

    0.1

    0

    2.0

    0

    1.1

    4

    0.12

    0.0

    7

    a

    0.0

    4

    0.0

    2

    0.0

    2

    0.0

    3

    Profile2

    Ap

    5.3

    3

    72

    .3

    12

    .7

    4.1

    7

    0.0

    5

    0.8

    1

    0.8

    0

    0.1

    3

    1.9

    4

    0.6

    7

    0.18

    0.1

    0

    0.0

    5

    0.0

    3

    0.0

    3

    Bt

    1.9

    7

    46

    .4

    21

    .4

    9.1

    4

    0.0

    3

    1.1

    5

    1.4

    3

    0.1

    1

    1.6

    3

    1.1

    9

    0.13

    0.1

    0

    0.0

    4

    0.0

    3

    0.0

    4

    Sugarfoam

    512

    26

    .1

    6.7

    2.3

    0.2

    9.7

    42

    .8

    1.1

    2

    1.1

    9

    0.2

    0.51

    6.3

    3

    0.3

    4

    0.3

    4

    0.0

    3

    PPC

    calcinationloss,aTrace

    610 Environ Earth Sci (2009) 59:603611

    1 3

  • 8/14/2019 Application of Sugar Foam to Red Soils in a Semiarid Mediterranean Environment

    9/9

    early indicators of the impact of management on soil biological

    quality. Biol Fertil Soils 31:7884

    Bremner JM, Mulvaney CS (1982) Nitrogen total, pp 621622. In:

    Page AL (ed) Methods of soil analysis Part 2 chemical and

    microbiological properties, 2nd edn. American Society of

    Agronomy and Soil Science Society of America, Madison, WI

    Carbonell A, Porthouse JD, Mulbah CK, DeLaune RD, Patrick JWH

    (1999) Metal solubility in phosphogypsum-amended sediment

    under controlled pH and redox conditions. J Environ Qual

    28:232242

    Cegarra J, Paredas C, Roig A, Bernal MP, Garca D (1996) Use of

    olive mill wastewater compost for crop production. Int Biode-

    terior Biodegradation 38:193203

    Chaney K, Swift RS (1984) The influence of organic matter on

    aggregate stability in some British soils. J Soil Sci 35:415420

    Clark MS, Horwath WR, Shennan C, Scow KM (1998) Changes in

    soil properties resulting from organic and low-input farming

    practices. Agrn J 90:662671

    Diaz MJ, Madejon E, Lopez R, Ron-Vaz MD, Cabrera F (1996)

    Chemical characterization of three composts of (sugar-beet)

    vinasse with other agroindustrial residues. In: de Bertoldi M,

    Sequi P, Lemmes B, Papi T (eds) The science of composting vol

    2. Blackie Academic and Professional, Glasgow, pp 11381141

    Drouineau G (1942) Dosage rapide du calcaire actif de sols. Ann

    Agron 12

    EspejoR (2001) El usode la espumade azucarera, fosfoyeso y residuos

    dolomticos de convertidor (RCD) como enmendantes de suelos

    acidos. Actas I encuentro internacional sobre gestion de residuos

    en el ambito rural mediterraneo. Pamplona, pp 377386

    FAO (2006) Guidelines for soil description. FAO/UNESCO. Rome,

    4th edn

    FAO ISRIC ISSS (2006) World reference base for soil resources. A

    framework for international classification, correlation and com-

    munication. World soil resources reports 103, FAO, Rome, 132 p

    Fauziah I, Zayah S, Jamal T (1996) Characterization and land

    application or red gypsum: a waste product from the titanium

    disoxide industry. Sci Total Environ 188:243251

    Garrido F, Illera V, Vizcayno C, Garcia-Gonzalez MT (2003)

    Evaluation of industrial by-products as soil acidity amendments:

    chemical and mineralogical implications. Eur J Soil Sci

    54(2):411422

    Gee GW, Bauder JW (1986) Particle-size analysis. In: Klute A (ed)

    Methods of soil analysis. Part 1. Physical and mineralogical

    methods, 2nd edn. Agronomy Monograph No.9, ASA-SSSA,

    Madison, pp 383411

    Gonzalez Martn J, Rubio Fernandez V, Garca Gimenez R, Jimenez

    Ballesta R (2007) Red palaeosols sequence in a semiarid

    Mediterranean environment region. Env Geol 51(7):10931102

    Gunn J, Sein R, Keller B, Beckett P (2001) Liming of acid and metal

    contaminated catchments for the improvement of drainage water

    quality. Water Air Soil Pollut 130:14391444

    Karaka A (2004) Effect of organic wastes on the extractability of

    cadmium, copper, nickel and zinc in soil. Geoderma 122:297303

    Levi-Minzi R, Riffaldi R, Guidi G, Poggio G (1985) Chemicalcharacterization of soil organic matter in a field study with

    sewage sludge and composts. In: Williams JH, Guidi G,

    LHermite P (eds) Long term effects of sewage sludge and farm

    slurries applications. Elsevier, London, pp 151160

    Lopez A, Vidal M, Blazquez R, Urbano P (2001) Differential effects

    of lime and sugar foam waste on the mineral composition and

    forage productivity of an acid soil. Agrochimica 45(34):8998

    Madejon E, Diaz MJ, Lopez R, Murillo JM, Cabrera F (1996) Cotton

    fertilization with composts of (sugar-beet) vinasse and agricul-

    tural residues. Fertil Res 43:179182

    Madejon E, Lopez R, Murillo JM, Cabrera F (2001) Agricultural use

    of three (sugar-beet) vinasse composts: effect on crops and

    chemical properties of a Cambisol soil in the Guadalquivir river

    valley (SW Spain). Agric Ecosyst Environ 84:5365

    McBride MB (1994) Environmental chemistry of soils. Oxford

    University Press, New York

    Mennch MJ, Manceau A, Vangronsveld J, Clijsters H, Mocquot B

    (2000) Capacity of soil amendments in lowering the phytoav-

    ailabitlity of sludge borne zinc. Agronomie 20:383397

    Moore DM, Reynolds RC Jr (1989) X-ray diffraction and the

    identification and analysis of clay minerals. Oxford University

    Press, Oxford, p 332

    Olsen SR, Cole CV, Watanabe FS, Dean LA (1954) Estimation of

    available phosphorus in soils by extraction with sodium bicar-

    bonate. US Department of Agriculture Circ. 939

    ROS M (2000) Recuperacion de suelos agrcolas abandonados

    mediante reciclaje en los mismos de residuos organicos de

    origen urbano. Tesis Doctoral, Universidad de Murcia

    SCS-USDA (1972) Soil Survey investigations report no. 1. Soil

    survey laboratory methods and procedures for collecting soil

    samples. US Govt. Printing Office, Washington

    Sikora LJ, Azad MI (1993) Effect of compost-fertilizer combinations

    on wheat yields. Compost Sci Util 1:9396

    Singer MJ, Ewing S (2000) Soil Quality. In: Sumner ME (ed)

    Handbook of Soil Science, chap 11. CRC Press, Boca Raton, pp

    271298

    Soil Survey Staff (2006) Keys to soil taxonomy, 10th edn. USDA-

    NCRS

    Tejada M, Gonzalez JL (2003) Application of a byproduct of the two-

    step olive oil mill process on rice yield. Agrochimica 47:94102

    Thomas GW (1982) Exchangeable cations. In: Page AL, Miller RH,

    Keeney DR (eds) Methods of soil analysis, Part 2. Am Soc

    Agron Soil Sci Soc Am, Madison, WI, pp 159165

    Tomati U, Galli E, Pasetti L, Volterra E (1995) Bioremediation of

    olive-mill wastewaters by composting. Waste Manag Res

    13:509518

    Vangronsveld J, Cunningham SD (1998) Introduction to the concepts.

    In: Vangronsveld J, Cunningham SD (eds) Metal contaminated

    soils: in situ inactivation and phytorestoration. Springer, Berlin

    and R.G. Landes Company, Georgetown, pp 115

    Vidal M, Garzon E, Garcia V, Ontanon A, Villa E (2004) Models for

    predicting composition and temporal structure of chemical

    parameters for leachates from amended acid soils. Commun

    Soil Sci Plant Anal 35(1112):15171542

    Vidal M, Garzon E, Garcia V, Ontanon A, Villa E (2006)

    Differentiating the amending effects of calcareous materialsapplied to acid soils by use of optimal scaling procedures.

    Agrochimica 50(34):132147

    Environ Earth Sci (2009) 59:603611 611

    1 3