aeschylus’ libation bearers the downward spiral. eumenides: writing assign. trial scene…...

14
Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers The Downward Spiral

Upload: violet-watkins

Post on 13-Jan-2016

222 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers The Downward Spiral. Eumenides: Writing Assign. Trial Scene… Closure? Unsatisfying expedient? Submit via Blackboard “Assignments”

Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers

The Downward Spiral

Page 2: Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers The Downward Spiral. Eumenides: Writing Assign. Trial Scene… Closure? Unsatisfying expedient? Submit via Blackboard “Assignments”

Eumenides: Writing Assign.

Trial Scene…• Closure?• Unsatisfying expedient?

Submit via Blackboard “Assignments”

Page 3: Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers The Downward Spiral. Eumenides: Writing Assign. Trial Scene… Closure? Unsatisfying expedient? Submit via Blackboard “Assignments”

3

Agenda

• Recap & Update– From Agamemnon to Libation Bearers

• Character and Chemistry(pp. 216 ff.)

– Is Clytemnestra Human?– Is Orestes a Pawn?

• Blood for Blood– Tragic Dilemma in Libation Bearers

Page 4: Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers The Downward Spiral. Eumenides: Writing Assign. Trial Scene… Closure? Unsatisfying expedient? Submit via Blackboard “Assignments”

Recap & Update

From Agamemnon to Libation Bearers

Page 5: Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers The Downward Spiral. Eumenides: Writing Assign. Trial Scene… Closure? Unsatisfying expedient? Submit via Blackboard “Assignments”

5

Agamemnon Cassandra Scene: Analysis• amoibaion (lyric

dialogue) 144 ff.– impassioned cries– self-lament– feast of Thyestes– Paris’ crime– riddling visions

• spoken dialogue (“no more riddles”) 149 ff.– vision of Furies

(Erinues)– Thyestes adultery– Cassandra’s

gift/credibility– concrete prediction– overlaid visions (pp.

151-152)

Page 6: Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers The Downward Spiral. Eumenides: Writing Assign. Trial Scene… Closure? Unsatisfying expedient? Submit via Blackboard “Assignments”

6

Libation Bearers: Characters• Orestes• Pylades• Electra• Cilissa (nurse)• Doorman (“Porter”)• Slave• Clytemnestra• Aegisthus• Chorus of Slave Women

– Trojan captives

Page 7: Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers The Downward Spiral. Eumenides: Writing Assign. Trial Scene… Closure? Unsatisfying expedient? Submit via Blackboard “Assignments”

7

Crime Blotter…Old Crimes• Ag’s death• feast of Thyestes• sacr. of Iphigenia• war-crimes, war-

losses…– related: red carpet

symbolically connecting Trojan destruction with Argos» with impiety-hubris –

Greeks disrespecting Trojan shrines

New Crimes• adultery

– cl & aegisth

• matricide and killing of aegisth

Page 8: Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers The Downward Spiral. Eumenides: Writing Assign. Trial Scene… Closure? Unsatisfying expedient? Submit via Blackboard “Assignments”

Libation Bearers: Analysis

(numbers = Penguin pages)

prologue 177 f.• Orestes

– offering of hairparodos 178 ff.

– mourning, libations, Clytemnestra’s dream, general foreboding

1st episode (begin) 180 ff.• Electra, Leader, Orestes, whole

Chorus– recognition, reunion

kommos (lyric interlude) 192 ff.• Electra, Orestes, Chorus

– mourning, invocation1st episode (end) 198 ff.• Electra, Leader, Orestes

– more invocation, Clytemnestra’s dream, plan

1st stasimon 204 f.– Clyt’s crime, natura/myth parallels

2nd episode 206 ff.• Orestes, Porter (doorman), Clyt,

Leader, nurse– deception

2nd stasimon 212 f.– prayers for justice

3rd episode 213 ff.• Aegisthus, Leader, Chorus,

Servant, Clytemnestra, Orestes, Pylades

– killing, agōn, killing3rd stasimon 219 f.

– victory songexodos 221 ff.• Orestes, Chorus, Leader

– victory, madness, Furies

Page 9: Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers The Downward Spiral. Eumenides: Writing Assign. Trial Scene… Closure? Unsatisfying expedient? Submit via Blackboard “Assignments”

Character and Chemistry(pp. 216 ff.)

Is Clytemnestra Human?Is Orestes a Pawn?

Page 10: Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers The Downward Spiral. Eumenides: Writing Assign. Trial Scene… Closure? Unsatisfying expedient? Submit via Blackboard “Assignments”

Blood for Blood

Tragic Dilemma in Libation Bearers

Page 11: Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers The Downward Spiral. Eumenides: Writing Assign. Trial Scene… Closure? Unsatisfying expedient? Submit via Blackboard “Assignments”

11

Tragic Themes, Patterns• Aristotle• “tragic

formula”• epiphany

• clyt

And the ancient pride no war,no storm, no force could tame,

ringing in all men’s ears, in all men’s hearts is gone.They are afraid. Success,

they bow to success, more god than god himself.But Justice (Dike) waits and turns the scales….

and frenzy goes through the guiltyseething like infection, swarming through the brain. (Chorus, p. 179 – parodos)

Page 12: Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers The Downward Spiral. Eumenides: Writing Assign. Trial Scene… Closure? Unsatisfying expedient? Submit via Blackboard “Assignments”

12

Intertwined Imagery

• Libations• Nets• Snakes

Page 13: Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers The Downward Spiral. Eumenides: Writing Assign. Trial Scene… Closure? Unsatisfying expedient? Submit via Blackboard “Assignments”

13

Blood-Guilt: similia similibus

• pollution• purification-

retribution• pollution?

Sacrifice of piglet

“Wash old works of blood | in the fresh-drawn blood of justice” (Chorus, 795-6)

Page 14: Aeschylus’ Libation Bearers The Downward Spiral. Eumenides: Writing Assign. Trial Scene… Closure? Unsatisfying expedient? Submit via Blackboard “Assignments”

Is dikē hubris?ELECTRA:

… teach me what to sayCHORUS LEADER:

Let some god or man come down upon them.ELECTRA:

Judge or avenger, which?LEADER:

Just say ‘the one who murders in return.’ELECTRA:

How can I ask the gods for that and keep my conscience clear?

LEADER:How not, and pay the enemy back in kind?