a new zinc-nickel electroplating process: alternative to ... · porous cyanide cadmium plating -...

32
ABSTRACT New environmental regulations all over the world encourage the use of alternatives to cadmium plating for corrosion-protection systems used on steels. Boeing patents are pending on a non-cyanide replacement z i n c nickel alloy electroplating process with superior properties, including low hydrogen embrittlement and good corrosion protection, for use on highstrength steels and other substrates. Another advantage of this process is low cost because conventional electro- plating tank facilities can be used and waste treatment cost can be reduced. The feasi- bility of this zinc-nickel plating process has been successfully demonstrated in the laboratory and is scheduled for manufacturing scale-up during 1983. ALTHOUGH THE CADMIUM AND CYANIDE HAZARDS to human health are well known and documented W*, cyanide cadmium electroplating is widely used on steel for its many beneficial properties (2,3,4). In the United States alone, the annual cadmium consumption for plating is approximately five million pounds (5). Increasingly stringent environmental regulations all over the world encourage the use of alternatives to cadmium plating for corrosion-protection systems used on steel. For aircraft highstrength steel parts, a substitute for cadmium plating must ensure long-term corrosion protection and provide low hydrogen embrittlement (LHE) (6,7,8,9). Mechanical plating, ion vapor deposition (IVD) of aluminum, aqueous coating dispersion, and bonded solid-film lubricants are mentioned (10,111 as possible alternative candidates to cadmium plating. However, there is no A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to Cadmium Plating Grace F. Hsu Boeing Materials Technology Boeing Commercial Airplane Co. Seattle, WA equivalent process that can provide the unique characteristics of LHE and retain the use of conventional electroplating tank facilities. EVOLUTION OF LOW HYDROGEN EMBRIT- TLEMENT CADMIUM ELECTROPLATING Hydrogen may be absorbed by metals both during processing and when the finished products are in use. Because hydrogen adversely affects ductility, sufficiently high levels of hydrogen can cause brittle failure in metals subjected to sustained stress. Hydrogen embrittlement is of primary concern to the aerospace industry. The vast majority of highstrength steel landing gear parts used on jet aircraft are cadmium plated using LHE processes. Figure 1 shows the evolution of LHE plating processes for hightrength steels. The first LHE process introduced in 1960, was accomplished by plating in m unbrightened cadmium cyanide solution at high current density. One of the drawbacks of this process is the very uneven deposit thickness, as shown in Figure 2a. This feature, plus the very porous plate, accounts for the poor corrosion protection of the substrate and the susceptibility to hydrogen re-embrit tlement or "post-lating embrittlement" (12,13,14). *Numbers in parentheses designate references at end of paper. 7

Upload: dangnhu

Post on 06-Aug-2019

252 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

ABSTRACT

N e w environmental regulations all over the world encourage the use of alternatives to cadmium plating for corrosion-protection systems used on steels. Boeing patents are pending on a non-cyanide replacement z i n c nickel alloy electroplating process with superior properties, including low hydrogen embrittlement and good corrosion protection, for use on highstrength steels and other substrates. Another advantage of this process is low cost because conventional electro- plating tank facilities can be used and w a s t e treatment cost can be reduced. The feasi- bility of this zinc-nickel plating process has been successfully demonstrated in the laboratory and is scheduled for manufacturing scale-up during 1983.

ALTHOUGH THE CADMIUM AND CYANIDE HAZARDS to human health are wel l known and documented W*, cyanide cadmium electroplating is widely used on steel for its many beneficial properties (2,3,4). In the United States alone, the annual cadmium consumption for plating is approximately five million pounds (5). Increasingly stringent environmental regulations al l over the world encourage the use of alternatives to cadmium plating for corrosion-protection systems used on steel. For aircraft highstrength steel parts, a substitute for cadmium plating must ensure long-term corrosion protection and provide low hydrogen embrittlement (LHE) (6,7,8,9).

Mechanical plating, ion vapor deposition (IVD) of aluminum, aqueous coating dispersion, and bonded solid-film lubricants are mentioned (10,111 as possible alternative candidates t o cadmium plating. However, there is no

2.73. ) ?DF 83Q686

A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process:

Alternative to Cadmium Plating Grace F. Hsu

Boeing Materials Technology Boeing Commercial Airplane Co.

Seattle, WA

equivalent process that can provide the unique characteristics of LHE and retain the use of conventional electroplating tank facilities.

EVOLUTION OF LOW HYDROGEN EMBRIT- TLEMENT CADMIUM ELECTROPLATING

Hydrogen may be absorbed by metals both during processing and when the finished products are in use. Because hydrogen adversely affects ductility, sufficiently high levels of hydrogen can cause brittle failure in metals subjected to sustained stress. Hydrogen embrittlement is of primary concern to the aerospace industry.

The vast majority of highstrength steel landing gear parts used on jet aircraft are cadmium plated using LHE processes. Figure 1 shows the evolution of LHE plating processes for hightrength steels. The first LHE process introduced in 1960, w a s accomplished by plating in m unbrightened cadmium cyanide solution at high current density. One of the drawbacks of this process is the very uneven deposit thickness, as shown in Figure 2a. This feature, plus the very porous plate, accounts for the poor corrosion protection of the substrate and the susceptibility to hydrogen re-embrit tlement or "post-lating embrittlement" (12,13,14).

*Numbers in parentheses designate references at end of paper.

7

Page 2: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960

Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962

1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating* - 1983 1 Figure 1. Evolution of Low Hydrogen Embrittlement

. Cadmium and Replacement Electroplating

*Boeing Proprietary

a. Cyanide Porous Cadmium

Deposit

c. Boeing Zinc-Nickel Alloy Deposit

b. Cyanide Cadmium- Titanium Deposit

Figure 2. Scanning Electron Micrographs of Polished and Etched LOW Hydrogen Embrit tlement Electroplating Deposit Cross-Sections (4UOX)

Page 3: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

In 1962, a cyanide cadmium-titanium (Cd-Ti) plating bath w a s adopted by Boeing for coating high-strength structural steel (15,161. Figure 2b illustrates that the cyanide cadmium-titanium deposit is a more continuous plating of less porosity than cyanide porous cadmium deposit. One interesting feature of Figures 2a and 2b is that coarsegrained structures are exhibited in both deposits.

researchers a t Beijing !nstitute in 1970 invented a noncyanide cadmium-titanium alloy plating process which w a s stated to be LHE (17).

Although not utilized by Boeing,

ZINC-NIC KEL ELECTROPLATING BACKGROUND

Zinc-nickel alloy w a s commercially deposited as early as 1905 (18). Since then, many zinc-nickel alloys have been suggested for electroplating onto steel to provide corrosion protection (19,20,21). However, most of the applications for these alloys have been only suggested for high-speed plating techniques, which are unsatisfactory for rack or barrel platings.

S. Ia. Popov (22) proposed an ammoniacal electrolyte to deposit a zinc-nickel alloy. However, this process, which uses low current densities, has led to a relatively high degree of hydrogen embrittlement in plated high- strength steel parts.

Rynne (23) disclosed an alloy plating containing 95% by weight or greater zinc with the balance being nickel. From literature (19,24,25) and the author‘s experimental data, the above alloys are not in the best alloy composition range to provide corrosion protection of steel parts.

BOEING’S ZINC-NIC KEL ELECTROPLATING PROCESS

A noncyanide, zinc-nickel alloy electroplating process has been developed at Boeing to ensure long-term corrosion protection of aircraft steel parts. This zinc- nickel deposit provides low-hydrogen- embrit tlement and corrosion protection properties equivalent or superior to the currently used Cd and Cd-Ti deposits. The use or conversion of conventional electroplating tank facilities is feasible. In addition, this

single process is a viable alternative to Cd plating for both high and low strength steels. For high-strength steel parts, a flow chart of a typical plating process sequence is shown in Figure 3.

The microstructure of the zinc-nickel deposit, as shown in Figure 2c, is continuous and level. The plate porosity has been optimized to permit baking-out of hydrogen, introduced during plating, and to minimize potential re-embrittlement due to service environment.

EXPERIMENTAL TESTING

LOW HYDROGEN EMBRITTLEMENT - Notched tensile specimens (NTS) manufactured and tested in accordance with ASTM F519 Type l a (26) w e r e used to evaluate hydrogen embrittlement of plated high- strength steels. The plated and baked specimens were tested by static tensile loading t o 75 percent of established notch ultimate tensile strength continuously for 200 hours. The specimens that withstand the loading for more than 200 hours exhibit satisfactory LHE characteristics.

more than 40 plating conditions, were evaluated by dry notched tensile testing. Only three conditions produced NTS failures:

More than 150 specimens, representing

o Without proprietary additives in the bath

o Contamination of the bath with a typical cyanide cadmium brightener

o Without baking after plating Initial correlation of Boeing plating

porosity meter (BPPM) and N T S testing has been established.

Hydrogen Analysis - To further confirm the LHE characteristics of the process, the hydrogen contents in the above-NTS w e r e determined by an ultrasensitive hydrogen analyzer developed by Boeing (27). The data shows that when the substrate hydr content of 4340 steel (260 to 280 ksr:as below 1.0 ppm, no N T S failures were observed. Preliminary data indicates that the hydrogen content of the substrate is the determining factor for LHE characteristics, not the total hydrogen or the hydrogen in the deposit. Even when the Boeing zinc-nickel deposits were 4 to 6 times the nominal thickness (0.0005 inches), hydrogen contents of the substrate were also analyzed to be below 1.0 ppm. A l l N T S failures correlate with high hydrogen contents in the substrate.

Page 4: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

Dry Abrasive Blast

Cold Water R i n s e 1 1

1 Dilute Acid Activation

Cold Water Rinse

I Dry I 1

H ydtogen Embrit t lement Relief Bake I L

I Chromate Treatment 1

Cold Water R i n s e F Figure 3. Flow Chart of Typical Electroplating Process for High-Strength Steel Psrts

Page 5: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

CORROSION PROTECTION -The Boeing zinc-nickel deposit provides sacrificial corrosion protection to steel, as does cadmium or Cd-Ti deposit (fig. 4). However, the Boeing zinc-nickel deposit provides longer sacrificial corrosion protection to steel than Cd-Ti deposit when plated to the same thickness (0.0005 inches) (fig. 4). Uncoupled metals and alloys are ranked in a galvanic series according to their corrosion potentials in a given environment, e.%., seawater. Corrosion potential is useful as an indication of general trends in galvanic corrosion. After approximately two months salt-spray test, the electrode potential of Cd-Ti deposit in 3.5% NaCl solution increases from -740 mV to -400 mV indicating that the deposit no longer provides sacrificial corrosion protection to steel. The electrode potential of the Boeing zinc-nickel deposit, after approximately four months salt-spray test, increases only slightly from -770 mV to -650 mV. Therefore, it still provides sacrificial corrosion protection to steel,

Figure 5 shows the excellent salt-spray corrosion protection of Boeing zinc-nickel plating compared to Cd-Ti plating. Figure 6 demonstrates that most of the steel substrate is still protected by the Boeing zinc-nickel deposit, while the Cd-Ti deposit has disappeared after accelerated salt-spray test. Accelerated salt-spray tests were accomplished by (a) applying primer and enamel over the plating, (b) scribing the test panel t o expose the steel substrate, (c) coupling with graphite using titanium fastener, and (d) testing in 5% salt-spray per ASTM 9117.

Compatibility with Aluminum - Experimental results show that the potential difference of uncoupled dissimilar metals, is a poor indicator of the extent (rate) of galvanic corrosion of coupled dissimilar materials. The values of the average galvanic current density agree well with the increase of dissolution rates due to galvanic coupling (28). The average galvanic current densities were measured between coated steels (cathode) and 7075-T6 aluminum (anode) in 3.5% NaCl solution at 25W, as shown in Table 1. Data indicates the zincnickel coated steel is more compatible wi th 7075 aluminum than the Cd- Ti coated steel. Galvanic corrosion of aluminum alloy 7075 coupled to zinc-nickel coated steel is much less than when coupled to unexposed Cd-Ti coated st eel. Although t h e

same trend of galvanic current increase w i t h salt-spray exposure is evident for both deposits, the average galvanic current density of long-term salt-spray tested Zn-Ni deposit is smaller than unexposed Cd-Ti deposit.

MENT - For highstrength steel protection, a plating process must provide not only low hydrogen embrittlement, but also low hydrogen re-embrittlement and good damage tolerance. The hydrogen introduced into the deposit and the substrate during plating must be driven out during the bake cycle.. A porous plate enhances the removal, but it also enhances re-embrittlement. This zinc-nickel bath chemistry and plating parameters have been optimized to establish a coating that will have'the least tendency to promote hydrogen re-embrittlement of the steel substrate, due to corrosive environment or damaged plating, and w i l l still be within the parameters that produce low hydrogen embrittlement and good corrosion resistance.

LOW HYDROGEN RE-E M B RITTLE-

Re-Embrittlement Test (Wet Notched Tensile Test) - The ASTM F519 test procedure tor maintenance material (26) w a s modified t o determine reembrit tlement characteristics by testing plated notched tensile specimens under tensile stress while exposed to water. The zincnickel plating demonstrated less tendency for re-embrittlement than did the Cd-Ti plating, which in turn w a s less susceptible than porous cadmium plating (fig. 7).

Re-Embrittlement and Damage Tolerance Test (Wet and Scratched Notched Tensile Test) - The ASTM F519 test procedure w a s further modified to test a damaged plate by scratching the test specimen in the notch area prior to loading and exposing to water. Several different Zn-Ni bath formulations (a, b, and c) were tested. Figure 8 shows that Zn- N i formulations a and b provide equal or better low re-embrittlement and damage tolerance than Cd-Ti plating. The zinc-nickel deposit plated in bath a is within the present recommended bath formulation and operating parameters. Bath c illustrates that hydrogen re-embrittlement can occur when the z i n c nickel bath is operated outside of the Boeing established bath parameters.

~

Page 6: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

Boeing,Zn-Ni plating

3.5% Na U solution at 25 C \

1 I i -dm t

So I uti on potential (MVISCEI

- loo0

-800

\Cd-Ti plating

Figure 4. Long-Term Sacrificial Corrosion Protection of Boeing ZwNi Plating Compared to Cd-Ti Plating

Cd-Ti PLATING BOEING Zn-Ni PLATING

RED RUST

WHITE CORROSION

.. . .- . -. . ..

2.3 MONTHS (1848 HOURS)

4.1 MONTHS (3000 HOURS)

1020 Steel: Plated, Baked, Chromated, and Tested in 5% Salt Spray

Figure 5. Excellent Salt Spray Corrosion Protection of Boeing Zn-Ni Plating Compared to Cd-Ti Plating

Page 7: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

En

Pr

4130

amel

imer

s tee1

Near scribe l ine b l i s tered area (pa i n t removed by tape t e s t )

Cd-Ti plating missing

Original mag. 400X (a) Cd-Ti Plating - 336 Hours

Near scr ibe l i n e bl is tered area (paint removed

Enamel

Primer

4130 Steel

O r i g i n a l mag. 400X (b) Boeing Zn-Ni Plating - 672 Hours

Figure 6. Acce le ra t ed Salt-Spray Test Resul t s of Cd-Ti and Zn-Ni

P la t ing Showing Improved Pro tec t ion of t h e Boeing Zn-Ni P la t ing

n

Page 8: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

Table 1. The Average Galvanic Current Density? for A1 7075-T6 in 3.5% NaCl ,

Coupled To

C &Ti Boeing Zn-Ni

- ig ( A/cmZ) 1848 H& 3000 Hrs* Unexposed

3.6 0.012

*Exposed salt spray test hours.

m o - P

8- - Exposure

Time

(Hr.)

t o o -

150

loo -

BOEING Zn-Ni

564

.,

1-4 No Fracture (removed from test after indicated time)

I

- 1.0

Fracture after specification minimum

Fracture - (at indicated time)

Cd-TI POROUS Cd

Loaded t o 45% of Ultimate and Notch Area Exposed to Water Individual Results Shown

Figure 7.

Re-Embrittlement of Boeing Zn-Ni Plating Compared t o Cd-Ti and Porous Cd Platings

Notched Tensile Specimen Loading Results Showing Less Tendency t o

Page 9: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

m P

Cd-TI

No Frac ture (removed from tes t J777 af te r ind ica ted time)

I 1-1 Frac ture a f t e r s p e c i f i c a t i o n

m i n i m u m

Bath a

Fracture ( a t ind ica ted time)

Instead o f notch, shank area scratched (1/4 inch from notch) both scratched and notch area exposed t o water

Bath b Bath c**

c I T

Zn-NI Bath VarIatIons

Loaded t o 45% of Ultimate, Notch Area Scratched and Exposed to Water Individual Results Shown

**Bath c is Outside of Boeing Zn-Ni Bath Parameters

Figure 8. Notched Tensile Specimen Loading Results Showing Equal Low Hydrogen Re-Embrittlement and Damage Tolerance of Certain Zn-Ni Alloy Platings Compared t o Cd-Ti Plating

FASTENERS PLATING - Installation UNIFORMITY OF COATING -This Zinc- torque is an important characteristic for fasteners. Torquetension curves for several fastener coatings are shown in Figure 9. The Boeing zincnickel process has installation torque equivalent to those of cadmium-plated (QQ-P-4161, diffused nickel-cadmium-plated, Fig. 10. or aluminum-filled epoxy-painted fasteners when installed in interference-fit holes in aluminum panels. IVD aluminum-plated fasteners require higher installation torque than the above four finishes (fig. 9) (29).

nickel process provides good throwing power and excellent plating coverage, both Of which me problem areas with the Cd-Ti and porous Cd processes. Uniformity of the Boeing zinc- nickel deposit on a fastener is illustrated in

Page 10: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

LOCI0 VERSUS TORQUE

I 0

Figure 9. Comparison of TorqueTension Curves Between Various Finishes:

IVD Aluminum (IVD-Al), Diffused Ni-Cd (Ni-Cd), Boeing ZincNickel (Zn-Ni), Aluminum-Filled Epoxy (Al-Epoxy) and Cadmium (Cd)

Figure 10. Boeing Zn-Ni Plating Thickness Distribution on a Fastener Thread (1OOX)

Page 11: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

. CONCLUSIONS

The high performance of this non-cyanide zinc-nickel plating process has been successfully demonstrated in the laboratory and is a viable cadmium alternative for both high and low strength steels. This process is scheduled for manufacturing scale- up during 1983. Specific features and benefits include

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

Non-cadmium, non-cyanide process

Low hydrogen embri t tlement

Low hydrogen reembrittlement

Sacrificial protection

Damage tolerance

Compatible with aluminum

Torque tension values equivalent to cadmium

Conventional electroplating process

Good paint adhesion

Stable bath

Feature

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

Benefit

Exceeds EPA standard and

Minimizes waste treatment costs

Protects high-strengt h st eels

Increases in-service protection

Provides long-term corrosion protect ion

Provides excellent service lit e

Provides galvanic protection to aluminum alloys

Can be used on fasteners

Minimizes facilities investment

Further corrosion protection

Ease of control and

Fewer rejects

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The author thanks Mr. R.C. Colonel for his valuable suggestions and Dr. J.H. Jones and Mr. P.O. Saelid for their excellent technical guidance.

APPENDIX

Licensing of this process will be available after successful completion of manufacturing feasibility. For information concerning Licensing, contact Mr. B.A. Donahue (206-394-3101) or Mr.R.E. Suter (206- 394-3100). MaiIing address: Patents and Licensing, Boeing Commercial Airplane Co., P.O. BOX 3707, MS 9H-82, Seattle, WA 98124

REFERENCES

1. "Cadmium Colloquy," Plating and Surface Finishing, Nov. 1979, pp. 8-14.

2. R.E. Marce, "Cadmium Plating Still a Must," Industrial Finishing, April 1978, pp. 34-37.

Plating, Are There Processes to Replace It," Galvanotechnik, s, 7 (1977), pp. 590-597 (from German), U.S. Department of Commerce, National Technical Information Service, Nov. 1978.

4. V.C.R. McLoughlin, "The Replacement of Cadmium for the Coating of Fasteners in Aerospace Applications," Transactions of the Institute of Metal Finishing, vol. 57, 1979, pp. 102-104.

3. P, Baeyens, "No More Cadmium

Page 12: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

5. E.J. Dyckman, "Cadmium Utilization and Environmental Impact," Defense Industrial Resources Support Office, June 26, 1975.

ment of High Strength Steels During Cadmium, Chromium and Electroless Nickel Plating," Plating, vol. 47, Feb. 1960, pp. 169- 175.

Embri t tlement in Metal Finishing," Reinhold Publishing Corporation, 1961.

W. Beck, E.J. Jankowsky, and P. Fischer, "Hydrogen Stress Cracking of High Strength Steels," center report NADC-MA- 7140, Naval Air Development Center, Warminster, Pennsylvania, 1'971.

9. A.W. Thompson, "Metallurgical Characteristics of Hydrogen Embrittlement," Plating and Surface Finishing, Sept. 1978, pp.

10. "Alternatives to Cadmkr?, P l S t k c Reflections Five Year s Later," Plating and Surface Finishing, Nov. 1982, pp. 21-13,

11. E.P. Cornwall, "Alternatives to Cadmium Plating," Boeing Document. March 1979.

12. D.M. Erlwein, "Environmental Effect on Notched Tensile Specimens," Boeing Progress Report, 1962.

"Hydrogen Embrittlement of 4340 Steel as a Result of Corrosion of Porous Electroplated Cadmium," Corrosion, vol. 28, June 1972, pp.

6. W.L. Cotton," Hydrogen Embrit t le

7. H.J. Read, "Hydrogen

8.

36-44.

13. J.G. Rinker and R.F. Hochman,

231-232. 14. D. Altura, "Postplating

Embrittlement," Metal Finishing, Sept. 1974, pp. 45,46,50.

15. 3,083,150, 1963.

16. 3,139,325, 1964.

17. and J.K. Liang, "Cd-Ti Eletrodeposits from a Noncyanide Bath," Plating and Surface Finishing, Dec. 1981, pp. 62-64.

18. C.B. Jacobs, "Some Observations on the Deposition of Alloys from Mixed Solutions," J. Am. Chem. SOC. 27, 1905, pp. 972-976.

19. 2,419,231, 1947.

20. 3,420,75 4, 1969.

21. Patent No. 3,558,442, 1971.

K. Takada, US. Patent No.

K. Takada, US, Patent No.

SS. Wang, J.K. Chai, Y.M. Shui

D.H. Schantz, US. Patent No.

E.J. Roehl, U S . Patent No.

E.J. R o d and R.H. Dillon, U.S.

22. S. Ia. Popov, Proceeding Fourth Convention on Electrochemistry, Acad. Sci. US3.R. Press, 1959.

23. G.B. Rynne, U.S. Patent No.

24. L. Domnikov, "Zinc-Nickel Alloy 4,2a5,802,i981.

Electroplated Coatings," Metal Finishing, Aug.

25. V.A. Averkin, "Electrodeposition of Alloys," Israel Program for Scientific Translation, Jerusalem, 1964, pp. 102-115.

ASTM F519, "Standard Method for Mechanical Hydrogen Embrittlement Testing of Plating Processes and Aircraft Maintenance Chemicals,"

27. K.B. Das, "An Ultrasensitive Hydrogen Detector," Hydrogen Embrittlement Testing, ASTM STP 543, American Society for Testing and Materials, 1974, pp. 106-123.

and J.V. Kenkel, "Galvanic Corrosion of 41 Alloys, I. Effect of Dissimilar Metal," Corrosion, vol. 30, no. 10, Oct. 1974, pp. 343- 353.

E,R. Fannin, "Ion Vapor Deposited Aluminum Coatings for Improved Corrosion Protection," MCAIR No. 78407, presented at AGARD Meeting, Florence, Italy, Sept. 26-28, 1978.

1963, pp. 49-54.

26.

28. F. Mansfe ld , D.H. Hengstenberg,

29.

Page 13: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

1 SCOPE a.

b.

This specification establishes the requirements for the electro-deposition of zinc-nickel alloy plating.

Do not plate steels heat treated to strength levels above 220 ksi (1510 MPa). For steels which are heat treated to strength levels above 220 Ksi (1510 MPa), contact Liaison Engineering. Plating in accordance with this specification is compliant with AMs 2417.

Zinc-nickel alloy plating is considered a substitute for BAC 5701, cadmium plating and

c.

d. Q Q-P-4 16.

2 CLASSIFICATION

This process specification consists of the following Types, Classes, Grades, etc., as specified.

2.1 TYPE (POST-PLATE TREATMENT) a.

b.

Type I - As plated (no supplementary treatment)

Type 11 - with supplementary treatment . .

2.2 CLASSES (THICKNESS) a.

b.

c.

Class 1 - 0.0005 inch (13 pm) thick minimum

Class 2 - 0.0003 inch (8 pm) thick minimum

Class 3 - 0.0002 inch (5 pm) thick minimum

This process and bath are covered by U.S. Patent 4,765,871 and corresponding foreign patents and/or applications. Articles made by this process are covered by U.S. Patent 4,765,871, U.S. Patent 4,818,632 and corresponding foreign patents and/or applications. Patent licenses are available. For further information contact: Chief Patent Counsel, Boeing Commercial Airplanes, P. 0. Box 3707, Mail Stop 6Y-25, Seattle, Washington, 98124. U.S.A.

REFER TO NUMERICAL INDEX FOR PSD ACTIVIW INFORMATION

Page 14: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

-

3

4

REFERENCES

The current issue of the following documents shall be considered a part of this specification to the extent herein indicated. ASTMB 117 ASTM B 374

’ BAC 5034 BAC 5408 BAC 5617 BAC 5619 BAC 5625 BAC 5744 BAC 5746 BAC 5748 BAC 5749 BAC 5750 BAC 5751 BAC 5763 BAC 5771 BSS 7217 BSS 7235

CONTENTS

Section

1

2

2.1 2.2 3

4

5 6 6.1 6.2

6.3 7

8 8.1 8.2 8.3

Standard Method of Salt Spray (Fog) Testing Standard Definitions of Terms Relating to Electroplating Temporary Protection of Production Materials, Parts and Assemblies Vapor Degreasing Heat Treatment of Alloy Steels Heat Treatment of Corrosion Resistant Steel Surface Treatments for Ferrous Alloys Manual Cleaning (Cold Alkaline, Solvent Emulsion and Foam Cleaners) Nickel Plating (Electrodeposited) Abrasive Cleaning, Deburring, and Finishing Alkaline Cleaning Solvent Cleaning Cleaning, Descaling and Surface Preparation of Ferrous Alloys Emulsion Cleaning (Immersion and Spray) Stripping Inorganic Finishes Air Cleanliness, Shop Compressed Air Adhesion Test Method, Plating

Subject

SCOPE CLASSIFICATION TYPE (POST-PLATE TREATMENT) CLASSES (THICKNESS) REFERENCES CONTENTS MATERIALS CONTROL FACILITIES CONTROL GENERAL NOTES PRECONDITIONING O F PLATING TANK AND FILTER SYSTEM ZINC AND NICKEL ANODE PRETREATMENT DEFINITIONS MANUFACTURING CONTROL GENERAL NOTES FLOW CHART CLEANING PRIOR TO MASKING

Page 1 1

1 1

2 2 4 6 6 7

7 8 8 9 10 11

Page 15: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

4 CONTENTS (Continued)

Section

8.4 8.5 8.5.1 8.5.2 8.6 8.7 8.7.1 8.7.2 8.8

8.9 9 9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.5.1 9.5.2 10 11 11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 11.5 11.6

Subject

MASKING AND RACKING CLEANING PRIOR T O PLATING LOW ALLOY STEELS CORROSION RESISTANT STEELS ZINC-NICKEL PLATING HYDROGEN EMBRITTLEMENT RELIEF BAKE GENERAL FERROUS ALLOYS PARTS (INCLUDING COIL SPRINGS) SUPPLEMENTAL TREATMENT/CONVERSION COATING (FOR TYPE I1 ONLY) REWORK MAINTENANCE CONTROL ZINC-NICKEL PLATING SOLUTION CONVERSION COATING DILUTE ACID SOLUTION ANODE PRETREATMENT SOLUTION PROCESS WATERS MAKE-UP WATER RINSE WATER QUALITY CONTROL REQUIREMENTS STRESS RELIEF WORKMANSHIP THICKNESS ADHESION CORROSION RESISTANCE TEST SPECIMENS

Page

11, ' 11 11 12 13 13 13 13

14 14 15 15 17 18 18 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 20 20 20 20

BA 563

PAGE 3

Page 16: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

5 MATERIALS CONTROL

Equivalent materials may be used provided that they meet all t h e requirements of this specification. Approval from Boeing Materials Technology is required prior to use.

a.

b.

C.

d.

e. f.

g.

h. 1.

j.

k. m. n.

MATERIAL

Abrasive Materials

(1) Pumice

(2) Tripoli Powder

(3) Silicon Carbide Abrasive Paper

(4) Scotch-Brite Pads, No. 744B, Silicon Carbide

Ammonium chloride, (plating grade) free of humectants, anti-caking agents or organic additives

Ammonium hydroxide (aqua ammonia), 28 percent, technical

Anodes

(1) Platinium plated titanium

(2) Nickel anodes, 99 percent nickel rolled depolarized,

(3) Platinum wire

(4) Zinc anodes, high purity, ASTM B 6 (99.9 percent),

Anode bags, Dynel or polypropylene

Anode hooks, titanium or monel

BOE-NIZ Additive LHE, Boeing proprietary

. . . SUPPlY

or carbon-nickel cast and rolled.

slab

Boric acid, crystals or powder, technical

Charcoal, activated, plating grade, such as Darco S-51 or 6-60 Filter, 50 micron or finer polypropylene or Dynel cloth filter

Filter aid, Diatomaceous Earth, filtering grade

Fluoboric acid, 48 percent, technical

Hydrochloric acid, 20 degree Be', technical, 0-H-765

SOURCE

Open

Open

Open

3M Company, St. Paul, Minn.

3M Company, or other plating

Open

Open

Open

Open

Open

Open

Open

Pure Coatings, Inc. West Paim Beach, F1. Open

Open

Open

Open

Open

Open

BAC 5637

PAGE4 OF2 RFVISED:

Page 17: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

- ~ ~~~ ~-

5 MATERIALS CONTROL (Continued)

P.

q. r. S.

t.

U.

v.

W.

X.

Maskants: Other maskants may be used provided that production experience has proven them to be satisfactory.

(1) AC-850

(2) AC-854

(3) Miccroshield Stopoff Lacquer

(4) B p e , yellow, pressure sensitive, platers

Nickel chloride, hexahydrate, technical

Nickel sulfate, hexahydrate, technical

Nitric acid, technical, 40 to 42 degree Be’, 0-N-350

Supplemental Treatment - CorroBan IC-A . .

Supplemental Treatment - ComBan IC-B

Sodium hydroxide, flake, bead or 50 percent liquid concentrate, technical

Zinc dust, plating grade

Zinc oxide, 0.005 percent lead maximum, plating grade

Adcoat, Inc.

Adcoat, Inc.

Michigan Chrome and Chemical Company

Sequoia Manufacturin Company, or other plating supply

Open

Open

Open

Pure Coatings, Inc. West Palm Beach, Fl.

Pure Coatings, Inc. West Palm Beach, F1. Open

Open

Open

I PAGE 563 5

Page 18: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

-

6

6.1

FACILITIES CONTROL

GENERAL NOTES a.

b.

C.

d.

e.

f.

g.

All surfaces of the plating tank, filter and associated plumbing which are in continuous contact with the plating solution shall be made of, or lined with, one of the following materials:

(1) rigid polyvinyl chloride or polyvinyl dichloride

(2) unfilled polyethylene or polypropylene.

It is recommended to cover the tank, when idle, with one of the above materials. NOTE: Mold releases on plastics are detrimental to the plating bath, and should not be

If filtration is used, the filter shall have sufficient capacity to turn the solution over one to two tank volumes per hour. Filtration shall be through a 50 micron or finer polypropylene or Dyne1 cloth filter (Section 5j.). Diatomaceous earth (Section 5k.) may be used as a filter media.

The plating tank shall be equipped with a temperature indicating and controlling device(s), if required, to maintain the temperature within Table I requirements.

The plating solution should be agitated to minimize temperature and concentration gradients. The maximum temperature gradient measured from the hottest to the coldest points in t he bath shall not exceed 10 F (6 C).

Air used for solution agitation or for drying parts shall be free of oil, water, or solid particles when tested in accordance with BSS 7217.

Power supplies shall have sufficient capacity to deliver the required current at the minimum and the maximum anticipated plating tank loads without current interruption during a strike or plating operation. The power supplies shall be capable of producing DC current having less than ten percent ripple (100 times AC voltage divided by DC voltage) over the desired plating range.

The power supply control panel shall be equipped with an ammeter that is readable and accurate within + 5 percent of the current over the desired plating range.

used when the tanks a re fabricated.

-

Page 19: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

6.2 PRECONDITIONING OF PLATING TANK AND FILTER SYSTEM * * * 1 * 1 * 8 *

$>.; T2p.V The presence of organic material in the plating tank or associated plumbing will affect the quality of the plating.

a.

b.

C.

d.

e.

f.

g* h.

Fill tank with 1 oz/gal (7.5 g/l) sodium hydroxide (Section 5v.) solution.

Heat solution to 140 F (60 C) minimum and operate pump, heat exchanger, and filter system for 6 hours minimum.

Remove and discard the solution and rinse the tank thoroughly with water.

Fill tank with approximately 3 percent by volume hydrochloric acid (Section 5n.) and approximately 0.1 percent by volume BO€-NIZ additive LHE (Section 5g.)

Operate the pump, heat exchanger, and filter system for 6 hours minimum at ambient temperature.

Allow the above leaching solution to stand an additional 24 hours minimum at ambient temperature.

Remove and discard the solution and rinseThe tank thoroughly with water.

New or contaminated anode bags (Section 5e.) shall be treated in the above caustic and ac solutions to leach out any organic contaminants.

6.3 ZINC AND NICKEL ANODE PRETREATMENT a. Manual solvent clean in accordance with BAC 5750, vapor degrease in accordance with

BAC 5408 or emulsion clean in accordance with BAC 5763. Anodes shall be completely c prior to further processing.

Dry abrasive blast clean in accordance with BAC 5748, Type 11, Class 1. Insert the anodes (Section 5d.(2) and Section 5.d.(4)) in the leached anodes bags (Section 5e. and Section 6.2h). Immerse the clean zinc and nickel anodes in the zinc-an@ pretreatment solution (Xable IV) for 2 to 3 hours to allow the formation of a dark-gray fii on the surfaces.

b. C.

d. Cold water immersion rinse. Handle the anodes carefully to prevent damaging the sok, dark-gray film on the anodes. Transfer the anodes to the zinc-nickel plating bath.

NOTE: If the anodes become contaminated or are stored outside of the plating bath a prolonged period of time (e.& one month or longer) reconditioning in accordance with the above procedure may be necessary.

56. PAGE 7

0 ?_. ,.- REVISED:

Page 20: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

DEFINITIONS

The following definitions shall apply to terms which are uncommon or have special meaning as used in this specification.

Lot - any group of parts of approximately the same size, shape, and basis metal which have been processed under the same conditions and submitted for inspection at the same time.

Nonfunctional Surface - a surface on which the presence of a slight plating imperfection will not affect the proper operation of the part.

Plating terms - see ASTM B 374 for standard definitions.

Water-break-free - a surface which maintains a continuous water film for a period of at least 30 seconds after having been sprayed or immersion rinsed in clean water at a temperature below 100 F (38 C).

MANUFACTURING CONTROL

A I Some of the materials employed herein are toxic, flammable, and/or corrosive to human tissue. Boeing personnel should refer to the Hazard Communication Handbook (D1-8301) located in your work area for information contained in the tip sheets and material safety data sheets concerning the health effects and proper control measures associated with the use of hazardous materials. Consult the responsible SecuritylFire Protection Engineering organization concerning appropriate facilities, equipment, and other requirements for safe operation. For disposition of hazardous waste materials, contact the responsible Pollution Control Monitor for appropriate procedures.

Non-Boeing personnel should refer to manufacturer’s material safety data sheets, or contact the manufacturer for safety and health information pertaining to a hazardous material.

1 PAGE 8 20 . ._^..C 0 q.l nq REVISED:

Page 21: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

8.1 GENERAL NOTES a. b.

C.

d.

e.

f.

g.

For ferrous alloys, refer to Section 11.1 for stress relief requirements.

Unless otherwise specified, the zinc-nickel alloy plating shall be applied after all basis ’ metal heat treatments and mechanical operations (such as machining, brazing, welding, forming and perforating) have been completed.

Surfaces must be water-break-free following any immersion in any processing solution or rinse, except following vapor degreasing, manual cleaning, emulsion cleaning or solvent cleaning. Reclean parts which develop a water break.

Auxilliary anodes (such as platinum plated titanium 5d.(l) or platinum wire 5d.(3)) may be used, as necessary, to meet the thickness requirements of Section 11.3.

Place all contacts and electrode connections in a nonfunctional area. When in doubt, consult the applicable design engineering department.

Filtration may be used when necessary to remove particulates from the zinc-nickel plating bath.

When the plating tank is inactive for more than 120 hours, the zinc anodes shall be removed from the plating bath. Removal is necessary to prevent degradation of the zinc anodes. . .

I PAGE 9 563’i (

Page 22: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

8.2

(Section 8.4)

FLOW CHART

7

Low Alloy Steels Clean and Activate (Section 8.5.1)

Stress Relieve as Required (Section 11.1)

Corrosion Resistant Steels Clean and Activate (Secrion 8.5.2)

I I

- Zinc-Nickel Plating (Section 8.6)

I

Clean Prior to Masking (Section 8.3)

i *

I - Hydrogen Embrittlement Relief

Bake, As Required (Section 8.7)

1

Supplemental Treatment (Section 8.8)

I 1

t I 1

Quality Control Inspection (Section 10)

I 1

Page 23: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

8.3 CLEANING PRIOR TO MASKING If parts are greasy or oily, vapor degrease in accordance with BAC 5408, emulsion clean in accordance with BAC 5763, solvent clean in accordance with BAC 5750, manual clean in accordance with BAC 5744 or alkaline clean in accordance with BAC 5749. Descaling in . accordance with Section 8.5.la. or 8.5.h. may be accomplished prior to or subsequent to masking (Section 8.4).

, '

8.4 MASKING AND RACKING

OPTIONAL Parts may be masked and racked after Section 8.5.la.(l) provided the abrasively cieaned surfaces are not contaminated (rusting, soiling or discoloration). If the surfaces become contaminated, the parts shall be reprocessed in accordance with Section 8.5.la.

a. Mask area not to be plated using maskants listed in Section 5p. NOTE: To reduce the effect of shadowing and/or robbing of current, it is recommended

to mask any area of a metal rack, with the exception of the contact points, whick may be immersed in the pIating solution.

b. Rack parts to prevent entrapment of gases generated during plating, and to facilitate draining. Make firm electrical connections to the part(s) to prevent arcing. Provide sufficient contact to carry the required current.

8.5 CLEANING PRIOR TO PLATING a.

b.

Wet processed activated surfaces shall not be allowed to dry prior to immersion in the zinc-nickel alloy plating bath.

Parts which have been masked after descaling may be cleaned, if necessary, in accordance with BAC 5744 or BAC 5749 to remove any grease or oil from handling.

8.5.1 LOW ALLOY STEELS a. Descale by one of the following methods:

(1) Method 1

(a) Abrasive clean in accordance with BAC 5748, Type 11, Class 1 using glass bead or aluminum oxide abrasive. Use of larger particles (e.g., 80 grit aluminum oxide) to produce a rougher finish will improve plating adhesion.

return to Section 8.4, otherwise, transfer to activating step (Section 8.5.lb.) withir minute.

@) Alkaline clean and rinse in accordance with BAC 5749. If parts require masking

(2) Method 2

Descale in accordance with BAC 5625, Method 1, or BAC 5751, Method 1. Wate rinse thoroughly. If parts require masking, return to Section 8.4, otherwise, transfer to activating step (Section 8.5.lb.) within 1 minute.

(3) Method 3

Descale in accordance with BXC 5749, Method 3. Water rinse thoroughly. If-pa require masking, return to Section 8.4, otherwise, transfer to activating step (Section 8.5.lb.) within 1 minute.

5 6f PACE 11

Page 24: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

I

PAGE 12 OF 20 - R EVI s ED:

8.5.1

8.5.2

LOW ALLOY STEELS (Continued) b. Activate the surface by one of the following methods:

(1) Method I

(a) Immerse in dilute acid solution (hydrochloric acid or fluoboric acid in accordance

(b) Cold water rinse for 10 to 60 seconds.

with Section 9.3) for 5 to 30 seconds.

(2) Method 2

(a) Anodic clean in Isoprep 58 in accordance with BAC 5749.

(b) Warm water rinse for 1 to 3 minutes.

(3) Method3

(a) Periodic reverse clean in accordance with BAC 5749, Method 3. End with a 15 to

(b) Remove smut, if present, by scouring using abrasive material specified in

(C) Continue periodic reverse cleaning until a water-break-free surface is obtained

(d) Cold water rinse for 2 to 3 minutes.

25 second anodic cycle.

Section Sa. Rinse thoroughly with water.

(typically 2 to 10 minutes).

. .

c.

CORROSION RESISTANT STEELS Proceed to Section 8.6. Do not allow parts to dry.

a.

b.

Descale by one of the following methods:

(1) Method 1

(a) Abrasive clean in accordance with BAC 5748, Type 11, Class 1 using glass bead or aluminum qxide abrasive. Use of larger particles (e.g., 80 grit aluminum oxide) to produce a rougher finish will improve plating adhesion. .

return to Section 8.4, otherwise transfer to activating step (Section 8.5.2b.) within 1 minute.

(b) Alkaline clean and rinse in accordance with BAC 5749. If parts require masking,

(2) Method 2

Descale in accordance with BAC 5625, Method 111, or BAC 5751, Q p e XI, Class 3. Water rinse thoroughly. If parts require masking, return to Section 8.4, otherwise, transfer to activating step (Section 8.5.2b.) within 1 minute.

Activate surface with a Nickel Strike in accordance with BAC 5746.

1 BAC 5637

Page 25: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

. . ~

8.6

8.7

8.7.1

8.7.2

ZINC-NICKEL PLATING a. Immerse in zinc-nickel plating solution (Section 9.1) and then apply current at 10 to 40

ASF (1.1 to 4.3 A/dm2)

OPTIONAL Strike parts at a current density of 60 to 90 ASF (6.5 to 9.7 A/dm2) for 15 seconds before regular plating. For CRES steels, nickel strike in accordance with Section 8.5.2b.(l).

Plate to the required thickness. The plating time to apply 0.0005 inch (13 pm) (average) is estimated to be 40 minutes at a current density of 20 ASF (2.2 A/dm2). (Every 160 ASF-min (17.2 A/dm2 - min) will deposit approximately 0.001 inch (25 pm)).

If required, plating may be interrupted for re-racking of parts to obtain 100 percent coverage. Parts may be removed from the solution for re-racking, but do not allow the parts to dry.

Plate control specimens, when required, with the parts for subsequent adhesion and corrosion tests as required by Sections 11.4 and 11.5, respectively.

Cold water rinse for 1 to 10 minutes.

Dry within 5 minutes. A rinse for 1 minute in hot water will facilitate drying.

b.

C.

d.

e.

HYDROGEN EMBRITTLEMENT RELIEF BAKE

GENERAL a. Unless otherwise specified, all steel parts requiring baking (See Secrion 8.7.2) shall be

baked within 8 hours after plating to provide hydrogen embrittlement relief. Records shall be kept to provide evidence that each lot of processing has been properly baked.

DO not flex springs prior to baking. b.

FERROUS ALLOYS PARTS (INCLUDING COIL SPRINGS) a. Bake ferrous parts within 8 hours following plating according to the drawing. If not

specified on t h e drawing, bake in accordance with the following schedule:

(1) Carburized parts and 440 series CRES: 5 to S hours a t 275 - + 25 F (135 - + 14 C).

(2) Externally threaded parts heat treated from 160 to 220 ksi (1100 to 1500 MPa), all coil springs regardless of heat treat and all other parts heat treated from 180 to 220 ksi (1200 to 1500 MPa): 3 hours minimum at 375 - + 25 F (191 - + 14 C).

(3) PH steels not specified in Section 8.7.2b. shall be baked for 12 hours minimum at 375 + 25 F (191 + 14 C).

The following ferrous alloys do not require baking:

(1) 17-4 PH, 15-5 PH, 17-7 PH; all below 180 ksi (1200 MPa), if nor externally threaded

(2) 17-7 PH (CH 900 condition)

- - b.

(3) A-286

(4) 300 series CRES

( 5 ) All other ferrous alloys with tensile strengths less than 180 ksi (1200 MPa), except as specified in Section 8.7.2a.(2).

563' I PACE 13 1

REV Is ED: ORIGINAL I S S U E 8 - 2 1 - 9 2 .. - .-- ,. ̂ ^. .-,"*

Page 26: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

8.8 SUPPLEMENTAL TREATMENTKONVERSION COATING (FOR TYPE I1 ONLY) a. If there is a delay prior to application of the conversion coating, dry the parts and protect

the plated surface from contamination in accordance with BAC 5034, Type 11, Class 3, Grade A. (Insure parts are kept dry while in contact with Kraft paper. Wet Kraft paper can deposit sulfites on the part surface.) If parts have been allowed to dry because of a delay, alkaline clean prior to applying the conversion coating in accordance with BAC 5749 using a medium duty alkaline cleaner (e.& 15 minute soak in Isoprep 58), and water rinse. Do not allow the surfaces to dry.

Immerse part(s) in conversion coating solution (Section 9.2) for 40 to 60 seconds.

Immersion rinse in water (130 F maximum (54 C)) for 0.5 to 2 minutes.

Within 5 minutes, air dry thoroughly at a maximum of 130 F (54 C). Blowing with compressed air may be used to facilitate drying.

Other conversion coating solutions may be used as a supplemental treatment of they meet the requirements listed in Section 11 of this specification. However, any solution not specifically mentioned in this specification must have the prior approval of Boeing Engineering and Quality Assurance.

b.

c.

d.

e.

f.

8.9 REWORK . . . The following rework shall be documented as required by the applicable quality assurance provisions.

a. Parts not meeting the requirements of this specification shall be stripped in accordance with BAC 5771. Solution 46 or Solution 11.

BAC 5637

PACE 14 OF 20 REVISED:

O R I G I N A L ISSUE: 8 - 2 1 - 9 2

***.. . I . .

Ffi*v??p.? BAC 5771, Solution 11 contains cyanide.

b. Parts heat treated above 160 Ksi (1100 MPa) shall be baked at 375 - + 25 F (191 2 14 C) for 3 hours minimum after stripping is performed. Reprocess parts in accordance with this specification. c.

Page 27: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

9 MAINTENANCE CONTROL 9.1 ZINC-NICKEL PLATING SOLUTION

a.

b.

C.

d.

e.

f.

g. h.

1.

The tank and filter system shall be preconditioned prior to the initial make-up of the zinc-nickel plating bath (Section 6.2)

NOTE: Subsequent bath make-ups do not require the tank and filter system to be preconditioned.

Clean tank thoroughly and fill approximately half full with warm water.

For each 100 gallons (379 L) of final solution, add the appropriate chemical amounts in the following order:

(1) 142 pounds (65 kg) of ammonium chloride (Section 5b.). Mix until completeiy

(2) 61 pounds (28 kg) of nickel chloride (Section 5q.). Mix until completely dissolved.

(3) In a separate tank or container, add 2.5 gallons (9.5 L) of hydrochloric acid

dissolved.

(Section 5x1.) to 0.5 gallons (1.9 L) Of water. Add and dissolve 9.3 Ib (4.2 kg) of zinc oxide (Section 5x.). Add this solution to the main bath.

(4) 17 pounds (7.7 kg) of boric acid (Section 5h.). Mix until completely dissolved.

Fill t h e tank close to operating level with water.

Check the pH of the bath. Adjust the pH, if required, to 6.2 to 6.3. Ammonium hydroxide (Section 5c.) is used to raise the pH, and hydrochloric acid is used to lower the pH.

When the bath temperature has cooled to 65 to 85 F (18 to 29 C) add 3.0 gallons (11.5 L) of BO€-NIZ additive LHE (Section Sg.) per 100 gallons (379 L) of total solution. Stir the bath thoroughly.

Add additional water if necessary. Recheck the pH and adjust to 6.2 to 6.3 if necessary.

Before placing a freshly prepared solution into production, dummy plate at 3 to 5 ASF (0.3 to 0.6 A/dm3) for a period of 8 to 12 hours. Analyze and adjust in accordance with Section 9. li.

Maintain the plating solution within the ranges specified in Table I and adjust, when necessary, as prescribed by the Quality Control lab.

NOTE: Organic contamination occurs due to ineffective removal of oils and greases during the cleaning operation. Treatment with activated carbon (Section 5.) is usually effective in removing organic contaminants. The carbon treatment wil! also deplete the BOE-NIZ additive. Thus, it must be replenished before resuming plating.

563' PAGE 15

REVISED: ORIGINAL ISSUE: 8 - 2 1 - 9 2 - . .-

Page 28: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

9.1

MATERIWCONDITION

nc Metal

ckel Metal

,tal Metal Content :n+Z + Nif2)

ickel/Zinc Ratio

hloride

,oric Acid

IOE-NIZ Additive LHE

,H

I'emperature

Cathode Current Density

Nickel to Zinc Anode Area Ratio 1/ 2/ - - Anode to Cathode Area Ratio

CONTROL

0.7 to 2.0 oz/gal (5.2 to 15 g/l)

1.4 to 4.0 odgal (10.5 to 30.0 g/l) 2.5 to 6.0 odgal

(19 to 45 g/l)

1.0 to 3.5

16 to 20 oz/gal (120 to 150 g/l)

1.6 to 3.7 odgal (12 to 28 g/l)

1.9 to 11.5 odgal (14 to 90 mlll)

5.9 to 6.5

65 to 95 F (18 to 35 C)

10 to 40 ASF (1.1 to 4.3 A/dm2)

1 to 3

21

OPTIMUM

1.2 oz/gal (9.0 g q

2.4 oz/gal (18.0 g/l> 3.6 ozlgal

(27 g/l)

2.0

18.5 odgal (139 g/l)

3.8 odgal (28.5 gn)

6.30

75 F (24 C)

20 to 30 ASF (2.2 to 3.2 Afdm2)

---

- 1/ Remove zinc anodes when the tank is not in use for more than 120 hours.

- 2/ Use anode bags with all anodes. Leach new or contaminated bags in accordance with Section 6.2.

Page 29: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

9.2 CONVERSION COATING a. Clean tank thoroughly. Fill tank approximately one-half full of water.

NOTE: Thnk material should be PVC or polypropylene. The tank should be equipped such that heating and air agitation of the solution is possible (to minimize temperature and concentration gradients).

b.

c. Make-up the solution in accordance with n b l e 11.

Fill the tank to the operating level and check and adjust, if necessary, pH and CorroBan IC-A (Section 5t.) concentration in accordance with the control values listed in Table 11.

TABLE I1 CONVERSION COATiNG CONTROL

MAKE-UP PER

MATERIAL/ CONDITION

C O L T O B ~ IC-A

CorroBan IC-B

PH

Temperature

100 GALLONS

75 lbs

1 percent by volume

- - -

100 LITERS

9 kg

1 percent by volume

CONTROL

10 to 13 oz/gal (75 to 98 g/l)

1.9 + 0.2 -

100 + 5F (38 F 2 C l

BA( 563’7

PAGE 17 REVISED: ORIGINAL ISSUE: 8 - 2 1 - 9 2

x-?d97 A RFV 5IRS

Page 30: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

3.3 DILUTE ACID SOLUTION

Make-up and control t h e bath as indicated in liible 111.

TABLE 111

DILUTE ACID MAKE-UP AND CONTROL

MATERIAL/CONDI-

Water

Hydrochloric Acid, HCI (Section 5n.)

Fluoboric Acid, HBF4 (Section 5m.)

Temperature

SOLUTION A

Balance

3.0 gal (3.0 1)

- - -

- - -

Balance

2.5 gal (2.5 1)

CONTROL

SOLUTION A - - -

0.8 to ' 1.6 oz/gal

(6.1 to 12.3 g/l) - - -

Ambient

9.4 ANODE PRETREATMENT SOLUTION Make-up and control the bath as indicated in Table Iv.

TABLE IV

ANODE PRETREATMENT MAKE-UP AND CONTROL

MATERIAL/ ZONDITION Ammonium Chloride (Section 5b.)

Nickel Sulfate (Section 5r.)

Water

Temperature

MAKE-UP PER

100 GALLONS

208 lbs

46 Ibs

Balance

- - -

100 LITERS

25 kg

5.5 k.g

Balance

- - -

SOLUTION B ---

1.2 to 2.0 oz/gal (9.3 to 15 g/l)

Ambient

CONTROL

30.7 to 36 oz/gal (230 to 270 g/l)

6.7 to 8.0 oz/gal (50 to 60 g/l)

---

Ambient

1 PAGE 18 OF ZO REVISED: .

ORlGlNAL 1SSUE: 8 - 2 1 - 9 2

Page 31: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

3.3 9.5.1

9.5.2

10

11

11.1

11.2

PROCESS WATERS

MAKE-UP WATER Water used for solution make-up shall not contain more than 100 ppm total solids.

RINSE WATER

Control the total solids in the rinse water to 500 ppm maximum.

QUALITY CONTROL a. Monitoring of the process and examination of end-items shall be in accordance'with the

applicable Quality Assurance provisions which assure the requirements of this specification are met.

Testing shall be done with sufficient frequency to ensure compliance with the requirements of this specification.

-- b.

c. Analyze the solutions at intervals that have been determined through experience. Prescribe and record any changes that are necessary for compliance with this specification.

REQUIREMENTS

STRESS RELIEF a. The plater must receive written verification from the parts fabricator that all stress

relieving has been accomplished in accordance with Section 1l.lb. and 11.1~.

b. Ferrous alloy parts, heat treated to 180 Ksi (1240 MPa) (160 Ksi (1100 MPa) for externally threaded parts) or higher, shall be stress relieved prior to plating if they have been subjected to any of the following operations after heat treatment: Grinding, machining, straightening, cold working, or proof loading. Parts which only have been honed, lapped, or shot peened do not require stress relief. When stress relief is required for parts it shall be performed in accordance with BAC 5617 and BAC 5619.

If more than one plating operation (including different plating or re-plating) is performed on the parts, stress relief shall be accomplished only once.

c.

WORKMANSHIP a. The zinc-nickel deposit shall be smooth, fine-grained, adherent and visibly free from

blisters, pits which expose the substrate, nodules, porosity, excessive edge buildup, indications of burning and other defects when visually inspected without magnification. Uniformity of color is not required.

The Type I1 supplemental treatmentkhromate conversion coating shall be continuous, smooth. adherent. and free from powder. Loose coating which can be wiped off with a clean cloth. exposing bare plating, is unacceptable.

b.

Page 32: A New Zinc-Nickel Electroplating Process: Alternative to ... · Porous Cyanide Cadmium Plating - 1960 Cyanide Cadmium-Titanium Plating - 1962 1 Non-Cyanide Zinc-Nickel Alloy Plating*

113

11.4 -

11.5

11.6

BAC 5637

PACE 20 OF 2(

~

'fl

a. Unless otherwise specified, the zinc-nickel ailoy plating thickness shall be Class 1 for all hardware, except fastener hardware shall be Class 2.

b. Part surfaces designated on the drawing shall be completely covered with visible Zinc-nickel alloy plating, within the capability of the throwing power of the plating solution. Unless . otherwise specified, measurements of plating thickness apply only to those surfaces which ' '

can be touched by a ball 0.75 inch (1.9 cm) in diameter. c. Unless otherwise specified, the maximum thickness shall not exceed 0.0010 inch (25 pm).

ADHESION The deposit shall be firmly adherent wbcn tested in accordance with BSS 7235 after baking and supplemental treatment, if required, is completed. -- CORROSION RESISTANCE Zinc-nickel alloy plating with the 'Qpe II supplemental treatment shall show neither white corrosion products of zinc nor base metal corrosion products at the end of 96 hours when tested in accordance with Asiu B 117. The appearance of corrosion products, visible to the unaided eye at norma1 reading distance, shall be a cause for rejection, except that white corrosion products within 0.25 inch (0.64 an) from the edges of the specimens shall not constitute failure.

T E S T SPECIMENS Test specimens may be used in lieu of parts provided they are processed in the same manner as the parts they represent. For corrosion tests, low-carbon steel test specimens may be used to represent low-alloy steel parts. For other than low-alloy steel parts, corrosion test specimens may be of a generically similar material.

THICKNESS