5.mrp - ppc-app-mrp ii-jit

68
TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, June 8, 2022 June 8, 2022 , DOMS, IIT Madras , DOMS, IIT Madras 1

Upload: preetdeep-kaur

Post on 02-Apr-2015

173 views

Category:

Documents


5 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

1

Page 2: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

2

Page 3: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

3

ImagineImagine

Page 4: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

4

MasterProduction

Schedule (MPS)

InventoryStatus

File

MRPProcessing

Logic

Bill of Materials

File

OrderRelease

Requirements

OrderRescheduling

PlannedOrders

MRP SystemMRP System

Other SourcesOf demand

Inventorytransactions

Engg & Process changes

Page 5: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

5

Page 6: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

6BOM for ChairBOM for Chair

Page 7: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

7

A Typical MRPA Typical MRP

Week NoWeek No 11 22 33 44 55 66 77 88

RequirementsRequirements 4040 -- -- 6060 -- 6060 -- 5050

End Item: Wheel barrowsEnd Item: Wheel barrows

Page 8: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

8

Page 9: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

9

Page 10: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

10

Page 11: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

11Comparison of MRP and Traditional SystemsComparison of MRP and Traditional Systems

ABCABCControl on all Control on all itemsitems

Control ConceptControl Concept

Based on past Based on past demanddemand

Based on master Based on master scheduleschedule

ForecastForecast

ReplenishmentReplenishmentRequirementsRequirementsOrder PhilosophyOrder Philosophy

IndependentIndependentDependentDependentDemandDemand

TraditionalTraditionalMRPMRPDimensionDimension

Page 12: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

12Comparison of MRP and Traditional SystemsComparison of MRP and Traditional Systems

Finished goods and Finished goods and spare partsspare parts

Work-in-process Work-in-process and raw materialsand raw materials

Types of InventoryTypes of Inventory

RandomRandomLumpy but Lumpy but predictablepredictable

Demand PatternDemand Pattern

EOQEOQDiscreteDiscreteLot SizingLot Sizing

Meet customer Meet customer needsneeds

Meet Meet manufacturing manufacturing needsneeds

ObjectivesObjectives

TraditionalTraditionalMRPMRPDimensionDimension

Page 13: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

13

Logical Analysis Preceding MRPLogical Analysis Preceding MRP

When do we want to make how many of each product?

What components are required?

How many of each of these is already on hand?

How many have already been ordered? When will they

arrive?

When are more needed and how many more?

When should these be ordered?

Page 14: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

14

Requirements for a Sound MRPRequirements for a Sound MRP

A valid master plan

Accurate bills of materials

Accurate information on current inventories

Accurate information on orders already placed.

Reliable lead times

An adequate flow of materials

Page 15: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

15

Pre-requisites of MRPPre-requisites of MRP

A time-phased master production schedule in which

every item is described by bill of materials (BOM)

A unique number identifying each component and the

parent in every BOM

Properly structured, accurate BOM and tight control of

engineering changes

Accurate current inventory balances

Accurate quantities and reliable delivery dates

Reliable lead times

Page 16: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

16

Further requirements for practical Further requirements for practical applicationapplication

Computer software and hardware to handle huge volume of data

Timely reporting of issues, receipts, inventory adjustments and order

releases

Discipline in handling and order releases

Capable people (for handling and deciding)

Page 17: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

17

Reasons for failure of MRPReasons for failure of MRP

It is part of an incomplete system

Driven by an invalid / mismanaged Master Production

Schedule

Inaccurate data

Improperly structured BOM

Under qualified users

Page 18: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

18

Production Production Planning and Planning and Control (PPC)Control (PPC)

Page 19: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

19

Inter Relationships of Inter Relationships of Production Planning Production Planning

and Controland Control

Page 20: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

22

Masterscheduling

Forecastof FutureDemands

Long-termCapacityPlanning

OrderEntry

ShortTerm

CapacityPlanning

ShortTerm

Scheduling

Dispatching, Releasing &

Shop-floor control

InventoryPlanning &

ControlOrder,Manufacturing& engineeringinformation

Order,Manufacturing& engineeringinformation

Capacity &

Personnel plans

Actual shopLoads, Backlog

& lead time

Shop status& backlog

Job status,Queues and

loads

Priorities,PredictedLoads &Due dates

PredictedShop loads &Production

plans

Job status,Lead times &Open capacity

Stock Status &Status frequency

Require-ments

Long termInventory

plan

Capacity &Personnel

plans

Replenishment orders &

stock on handMachine &Workforcecapacities

Queues, times,Job status,

WIP levels &Shop efficiency

Page 21: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

24

Aggregate Aggregate Production Planning Production Planning

(APP)(APP)

Page 22: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

25Aggregate Planning GuidelinesAggregate Planning Guidelines

Formulate output plans that adjust production activities to provide a rational response to demand

Determine corporate policies regarding controllable variables

Use a good forecast as the basis for planning Plan in appropriate units of capacity Maintain as stable a work-force as possible Maintain as much inventory control as needed Maintain as mush flexibility as possible Respond to demand fluctuations in a controlled

manner Evaluate planning adequacy on a regular basis

Page 23: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

26

Aggregate PlanningAggregate Planning

Plans a desired output over a time-range

Pure Aggregate Planning Strategies

Work-force Overtime / idle time Inventories Back-orders Subcontracting Adjusting plant capacity

Page 24: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

27

Aggregate Production PlanningAggregate Production Planning

Each strategy has associated costs Usually mixed strategies are adopted

Master SchedulingTranslates end-product requirements to

materials and capacity requirements

Page 25: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

28

Capacity plan ascertains if schedule is feasibleCapacity plan ascertains if schedule is feasible

Materials PlanningMaterials Planning Capacity PlanningCapacity Planning

What materials ? When are they required ? How much ?

Concerns labour and machinery

What ? When ? How much ?

Page 26: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

29

Aggregate Production PlanningAggregate Production Planning

Page 27: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

30

Aggregate Production PlanningAggregate Production Planning

Page 28: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

31

Aggregate Production PlanningAggregate Production Planning

ProductionCost

LabourCost

InventoryCost

Back OrderCost

WorkforceChangeover

Cost

Page 29: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

32

Aggregate Production PlanningAggregate Production Planning

ConstraintsConstraintsRelationship between Net Inventory “NI” Relationship between Net Inventory “NI”

and time “t-1” and “t”and time “t-1” and “t”

Work Force ChangeoverWork Force Changeover

Page 30: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

33

All decision Variables > 0

Other Possible Constraints are on

Upper limit on maximum change in work force level

Upper limit on scheduled overtime

Upper limit on maximum backlog

Aggregate Production PlanningAggregate Production Planning

Page 31: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

34

11 22 33 Final InvFinal Inv SlackSlack SupplySupply

Initial InvInitial Inv IIoo

Regular 1Regular 1 RR11

Overtime 1Overtime 1 OO11

Regular 2Regular 2 RR22

Overtime 2Overtime 2 OO22

Regular 3Regular 3 RR33

Overtime 3Overtime 3 OO33

DemandDemand DD11 DD22 DD33 IIff SS Grand TotalGrand Total

0

r

v

c

r+c

v+c

r

v

r

v

2c

r+2c

v+2c

r+c

v+c

3c

r+3c

v+3c

r+c

v+c

r+2c

v+2c

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

Sales Periods

C= carrying cost per unit for the interval of timer = regular production cost per unit V = overtime production cost per unitIo = initial inventory If = Final inventory

Basic

tran

sporta

tion

alg

orith

m

XXXX X

X

Page 32: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

35

11 22 Final Final InvInv

SlackSlack SupplySupply

Initial InvInitial Inv IIoo

Regular 1Regular 1 RR11

Overtime 1Overtime 1 OO11

Subcontract1Subcontract1 SS11

Regular 2Regular 2 RR22

Overtime 2Overtime 2 OO22

Subcontract2Subcontract2 SS22

DemandDemand DD11 DD22 DD33 SS Grand TotalGrand Total

0

v

c

r+c

v+c

r

v

v

s

2c

r+2c

v+2c

v+c

0

0

0

0

0

Sales Periods

Tra

nsp

orta

tion

alg

orith

m w

ith

sub

con

tractX

XX X

X

s

C= carrying cost per unit for the interval of timer = regular production cost per unit V = overtime production cost per unitS = Subcontracting cost per unitIo = initial inventory If = Final inventory

0

0

s+c s+2c

Page 33: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

36

11 22 33 Final InvFinal Inv SlackSlack SupplySupply

Initial InvInitial Inv IIoo

Regular 1Regular 1 RR11

Overtime 1Overtime 1 OO11

Regular 2Regular 2 RR22

Overtime 2Overtime 2 OO22

Regular 3Regular 3 RR33

Overtime 3Overtime 3 OO33

DemandDemand DD11 DD22 DD33 IIff SS Grand TotalGrand Total

0

r

v

c

r+c

v+c

r

v

r

v

2c

r+2c

v+2c

r+c

v+c

3c

r+3c

v+3c

r+c

v+c

r+2c

v+2c

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

Sales Periods

C= carrying cost per unit for the interval of timer = regular production cost per unit V = overtime production cost per unitIo = initial inventory If = Final inventory

r + b r + b

r + 2b r + 2b

r + b r + b

Tra

nsp

orta

tion

alg

orith

m w

ith

back o

rders

Page 34: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

37

Operation scheduleOperation schedule

Operation sheets:Operation sheets: Sequence of operationSequence of operation

Processing timesProcessing times

Factors of productionFactors of production

SchedulingScheduling

Forward scheduling : Forward scheduling :

Excess stock for distant due datesExcess stock for distant due dates

Backward scheduling: Backward scheduling:

Initially machine idleInitially machine idle

Risk of breakdown and shortageRisk of breakdown and shortage

Page 35: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

38

Schedules include transit timeSchedules include transit time

Some typical possibilities of schedulesSome typical possibilities of schedulesOperation 1 Operation 2 Operation 3

Operation 1

Operation 2

Operation 3

Operation 1 Operation 2 Operation 3

Time

Page 36: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

39

Possible Corrective actions for Possible Corrective actions for nearing due datesnearing due dates

Over timeOver timeExtra Shift (if not available)Extra Shift (if not available)Sub contractSub contractExtra menExtra men ‘‘Other purpose’ machineOther purpose’ machineReschedule less critical areasReschedule less critical areas

Decide based on situation!!!Decide based on situation!!!

Page 37: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

40

Production Control SystemsProduction Control Systems

Order Control – BatchOrder Control – BatchFlow control - MassFlow control - Mass

Page 38: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

41

Order Control – BatchOrder Control – Batch

Identify what to produceIdentify what to produceSales ordersSales orders

ForecastForecast

Manufacturing ordersManufacturing orders

Shortage listShortage list

When to produceWhen to produce

How much to produceHow much to produceMaster ScheduleMaster Schedule

Page 39: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

42

Order Control – Gantt ChartOrder Control – Gantt Chart

Order No Time Scale

3142

Operation1 Operation2 Operation3 Scheduled

Operation1 Operation2 Actual  

3219

Operation1 Operation2 Operation3 Operation4 Scheduled

Operation1 Operation2 Operation3 Actual

Time

Page 40: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

43

Machine Control – Gantt ChartMachine Control – Gantt ChartMachine

NoTime Scale

3142

Order No 1 Order No 2 Order No 3 Scheduled

Order No 1 Order No 2 Actual  

3219

Order No 1 Order No 2 Order No 3 Order No 4 Scheduled

Order No 1 Order No 2 Order No 3 Actual

Time

Page 41: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

44Master ScheduleMaster Schedule

When to produceWhen to produce

How much to produceHow much to produce

Product # 1

# 2

# 3

# 4

# 5

# 6

# 7

# 9

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

100

200

300

400

500

11 12

Week

Qty

Page 42: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

45

How to do?How to do?

Processing InstructionsProcessing InstructionsAssembliesAssembliesBOMBOMBlue Prints & part drawingsBlue Prints & part drawingsExploded Assembly requirementsExploded Assembly requirementsRoute sheetsRoute sheets

Page 43: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

46

Information on factors of productionInformation on factors of production

Check with Check with Stock levels - Buying or makingStock levels - Buying or makingMen – efficiency of labor, quality circles, Men – efficiency of labor, quality circles,

union meetingsunion meetingsMaterials – rework/ rejections/ scrapMaterials – rework/ rejections/ scrapMachine - efficiency of machine/ breakdownsMachine - efficiency of machine/ breakdownsAccessories – Toolings (Tools, Jigs & Fixtures)Accessories – Toolings (Tools, Jigs & Fixtures)

gaugesgauges

Page 44: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

47

Dispatching and ExpeditingDispatching and Expediting

DispatchingDispatchingShop formsShop forms

Manufacture orderManufacture orderMove OrdersMove Orders

ExpeditingExpeditingFollowup chartsFollowup charts

Page 45: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

48

Capacity plan ascertains if schedule is feasibleCapacity plan ascertains if schedule is feasible

Materials PlanningMaterials Planning Capacity PlanningCapacity Planning

What materials ? When are they required ? How much ?

Concerns labour & machinery What ? When ? How much ?

Aggregate Production PlanningAggregate Production Planning - Revisited- Revisited

Page 46: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

49

Manufacturing Manufacturing Resource Planning Resource Planning

(MRP-II)(MRP-II)

Page 47: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

50

Rough -cut capacity plan

Prospective MPS

Authorized MPS

Capacity available within MPS?

Change for MPS sufficient?

More capacity required?

YesNo

No

No

Yes

Yes

CAPACITY REQUIREMENTS PLANNING CAPACITY REQUIREMENTS PLANNING – – INTERACTIONS WITH MPSINTERACTIONS WITH MPS

Page 48: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

51MRP IIMRP II

Production Planning

Sales Demand Sales Forecast

Actual Inventory or Back Log levels

Senior Management Decisions

Resource Requirements Planning

Master Schedule

Capacity Requirements Planning (In-house)

Material Requirements Planning

Purchase Orders Shop Orders

Compare with Supplier Information

Supplier Communication

Shop Floor Control

Compare with Shop Floor Information

Continue with plans

Supplier Capacity Requirements Planning

On Schedule

On Schedule

YESYES NONO

Page 49: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

53

Just in Time (JIT) Just in Time (JIT) ManufacturingManufacturing

Page 50: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

54

Page 51: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

55

COMPLETE AND ACCURATE DATA

SIMPLIFIED MODULAR STRUCTURE SHORT CHANGE OVER TIMES

MACHINE RELIABILITY

PROCESS CAPABILITY

FLEXIBLE PEOPLE

EDUCATION AND TRAININGQUALITY ON LINE

QUALITY CIRCLES

LEVEL SCHEDULES

SUPPLIER DEVELOPMENT

KANBAN

J.I.T

STEPS TO JIT MANUFACTURESTEPS TO JIT MANUFACTURE

Page 52: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

57

JIT vs. MRP: a comparisonJIT vs. MRP: a comparison

Asset, useful to Asset, useful to absorb absorb

fluctuationsfluctuations

Liability, try to Liability, try to eliminateeliminate

InventoryInventory

Impersonal-drive Impersonal-drive themthem

Involve themInvolve themWorkersWorkers

Plan with themPlan with themMinimizeMinimizeLead timesLead times

Not criticalNot critical

Allow queuesAllow queues

Constant care to Constant care to minimize breakdownsminimize breakdowns

MaintenanceMaintenance

TolerateTolerateEliminateEliminateScrapScrap

AdversariesAdversariesPart of your teamPart of your teamVendorsVendors

MRPMRPJITJIT

Page 53: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

58

JIT vs. MRP: a comparison (Contd.)JIT vs. MRP: a comparison (Contd.)

Medium to low Medium to low volumevolume

High to medium High to medium volumevolume

SuitabilitySuitability

NecessaryNecessary

RE-ACTIVERE-ACTIVE

EliminateEliminate

PRO-ACTIVEPRO-ACTIVEQueues Queues

(WIP)(WIP)

Plan for themPlan for themCut down the timeCut down the timeSet-upsSet-ups

To balance set-To balance set-up cost & holding up cost & holding

costcost

Bare minimumBare minimum

(Single piece?)(Single piece?)Lot sizeLot size

MRPMRPJITJIT

Page 54: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

59

Evolution of Manufacturing Control systems Evolution of Manufacturing Control systems [1/2][1/2]

Order Point systemOrder Point systemForecast with past data.Forecast with past data.Inventory control with EOQ and ABC analysis.Inventory control with EOQ and ABC analysis.

MRPMRPBased on Master schedule, B.O.M. and Based on Master schedule, B.O.M. and

predicted demand.predicted demand.Complete inventory control.Complete inventory control.Convenient lot-size.Convenient lot-size.

Page 55: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

60

Evolution of Manufacturing control systems Evolution of Manufacturing control systems [2/2][2/2]

MRP IIMRP II

Incorporates capacity planning.Incorporates capacity planning.

Incorporates feed back.Incorporates feed back.

JITJIT

Emphasis on waste reduction.Emphasis on waste reduction.

Aim for Zero defect.Aim for Zero defect.

Aim for Zero Inventory.Aim for Zero Inventory.

Quick change-overs.Quick change-overs.

Small lots.Small lots.

Multi-skilled worker.Multi-skilled worker.

Page 56: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

61

Page 57: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

62

Page 58: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

63

Page 59: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

64

Page 60: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

65

Page 61: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

66

KanbanKanban

Page 62: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

67

Page 63: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

68

Page 64: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

69

Page 65: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

70

Page 66: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

71

Page 67: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

72

Page 68: 5.MRP - PPC-APP-MRP II-JIT

TTN - OM 2008, TTN - OM 2008, April 11, 2023April 11, 2023, DOMS, IIT Madras, DOMS, IIT Madras

73

Thank You !!!Thank You !!!